09: Q&A: A Traumatically Clean House

I have the perfect person to answer a question about “trauma cleaning” as a result of being raised by a parent who was emotionally and verbally abusive about keeping a clean house. This question came from Maria, a TikTok follower, and I’m jumping into this topic in today’s episode with my guest, Amanda Dodson. Join us!

Show Highlights:

  • Why this is a common feeling for many people when they sense barriers around care tasks

  • A good first step: Try to separate the behavioral home care task from the interpersonal problem with the parent

  • Why you have to decide how YOU want your home to be for your own comfort and safety–not how your parent would want it to be

  • Why it’s important to have compassion for yourself and awareness of what you need in your space to function well

  • How to identify what you need from your space and use a triage approach to get there

  • How to have your environment and emotions “meet” at a halfway point

  • How to take small steps toward organizing that work for you and your family

Resources:

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello, you sentient ball of stardust. This is Struggle Care, the podcast about self care by a host that hates the term self care. And we're going to do a Q&A episode and I have a special guest Amanda Dodson, who is a therapist and home organizer. Say hi, Amanda.

    Amanda Dodson 0:22

    Hello, everyone.

    KC Davis 0:24

    Alright, so, Amanda felt like the perfect person to bring on to answer this question. Okay, here we go. Hello, I've been following your tic tock, and I've watched almost all of them. I was wondering if you could do a series or a talk about trauma cleaning as a result of being raised by a parent who was verbally and emotionally abusive about keeping a clean house, I grew up in a house which looked like a museum with absolutely nothing out of place, my mother would lose her mind if a fork was left in the sink. She was controlling critical and type A, if you already have made these visit videos, let me know. But how do I heal from years of this? Thank you for what you do. Okay. And that's by Maria. So there's a lot there. I will say that this is a really common thing for people, when they start to figure out why they're feeling barriers around care tasks, whether it is I don't know how to start, I don't know how to keep up, or I don't know how to stop, I don't know how to rest, I don't know how to embrace good enough. And so many times it comes back to trauma or an adverse childhood experience that they had with their family of origin around care tasks. Because how your family treats care tasks has a huge impact on your relationship to care tasks as we grow up. And one of the phrases that I use a lot is that says, neurons that fire together, wire together. So if you experience an environment, or an action, in a certain emotional context, your brain starts to associate the two. So for example, if you grew up in a neglectful environment where everything was dirty and messy, and you always felt uncared for unprotected and ashamed, you actually can begin to associate feeling ashamed with that messy home. And so you can grow up and have a totally safe home and be a great adult. But you know, maybe it gets messy after a party and you feel shame, you feel like things aren't safe. But what's interesting here is actually someone experiencing the opposite, where they had this really sort of cold abusive context emotionally, with this perfect museum house. So curious what your thoughts are on that, Amanda?

    Amanda Dodson 2:27

    Yeah, that's such a tough question. And I just feel a lot of compassion for the person who asked it, because that sounds really hard. And, you know, I also get questions like this a lot from the people that I talked to about this, and coach, and I think as hard as it is, a good first step is to try to separate the behavioral home care, the thing that you have to do from the interpersonal problem with the parent, right? Because the problem wasn't really the cleanliness of the house. That was how the problem was coming out and how it was presented to you as a child. But that wasn't what was really going on, what was going on, was that the parent was overwhelmed, it sounds like with their own expectations, and anxieties. And instead of being able to regulate and cope with that, it got kind of spread all over the household and projected onto the children with being critical, and controlling, right. And like, These are behaviors that could happen in any home of any cleanliness, right, and their interpersonal and emotionally damaging behaviors. So if we can kind of pull that out away from the expectation of what a home is actually supposed to be, it can give you permission to think about, okay, as I am coping with the fact that my parent was quite cold and controlling. How do I actually want my home to be like, if I could, like you know, magic wand it and it's exactly the way that I would enjoy it being not like mom's never gonna see it. Right? Like, oh, we're not picturing like mom walking into the space and whether she approves or not like, this is your own clubhouse? What do you want it to look like? I think that then people can start to think about, like, how do I actually want to be in my space, if I can get rid of all the expectations of what a home is supposed to be like?

    KC Davis 4:29

    I love that. And I think sometimes building in routines that allow for rest, because I think sometimes when you come from this background, you have a hard time ever resting if things aren't perfectly in place, because the anxiety from your childhood, what has taught you that things being out of place, means that you're in danger. And now it may not have been physical danger, but it was certainly social emotional danger, right. Your mother was going to come in the room and criticize you and tell Are you down or punish you or take something away that you like, right? And so it takes quite a bit of deprogramming. Like we said, neurons that fire together wire together. So when you are at the end of the day, and you're going, I'm so tired, I just want to sit down, but you're seeing things around the house that need to get done. Taking a moment to have compassion for yourself, and that inner child at that moment, and just becoming aware of what's happening in that moment, and like you said, you can go, Okay, what's functional? Is it functional? Okay, and you have your little, okay, I, what do I need in the morning, I need a trash can. That's clear, I need enough dishes to eat off of, I need clean clothes to wear, I need a clear safe path to walk, I need a clean place to prepare food. And I would like a place in my home to sit down and relax that isn't over cluttered. Like maybe that's your little list of what is functional for you. And if you can recognize, okay, the functional things are in place, and I'm still feeling this anxiety, sometimes just the recognition that is your inner child trying to help you, right? Like this was a really adaptive behavior in your childhood that went You're not safe, don't sit down yet. And so sometimes just remembering that little warning signal of anxiety is not coming from your current home.

    Amanda Dodson 6:21

    Yes, totally. And I honestly can really identify like, as a very, very neat and tidy person. Because cleaning was the way when I moved out of my house and went to college and felt very exposed out in the big world. Cleaning and making my home and my room a certain way was the way that I dealt with the anxiety of life, right. And this over the years took on a bit of a life of its own, until I realized that I really struggled to relax unless everything was clean and tidy. And in its place, which as life went on, and I got older and tireder and sicker. It's just like, not going to be an option anymore. So one strategy I love. And I think the switch you mentioned is to think about, like, what's the bare minimum of what I need, at least to get that anxiety to a level that's tolerable? Right? Like, my goal is I want to be able to lay down and rest. And I feel like I can't do that unless the space is a certain way. Right? Okay. So instead of cleaning the whole house, before I can rest, I'm gonna pick one corner where I can lay down, whether it's from a little corner on my couch, or whether it's just this one spot in my bedroom, where I can put it orderly within five minutes tops, and be able to sit down and rest and understand emotionally regulate around the fact that like, everything doesn't need to be that way for me to be able to chill out.

    KC Davis 7:51

    Yeah, and I think this is also an example of, you know, when we talk about like, you don't exist to serve your house, your house exists to serve you. And so your unique sort of needs and emotional context is really going to color what you do with your space. So like when we have someone like myself, right, who has ADHD, who I'm not typically I'm not super anxious around like a high mess, tolerance, ADHD, busy mom, all this stuff, you know, that colors what I need from my environment. And what that means for me is like, I need lots of things visible. So I have a lot of things on my countertop, I have a lot of clear bins that I can see into a good friend of mine who's similar to me actually ended up taking off the cabinet doors off of her cabinets, because she's like, I want to see what's in there. That helps me I don't want things shut away. And I'm like that too. I need to see everything. However, Maria might be someone who needs something different from her space, she might say when I'm thinking about how much stuff I want to own, maybe I want to pare down so it's easier to put away. And when I'm thinking about organizational solutions, I want to go for bins that are not clear. I want to go for cabinets, I can shut drawers, I can push in. And like you said, I think a good sort of triage thing is to pick one room or one corner and have that be your safe haven have that be your everything is spic and span and immaculate right now. And that will kind of color some of the things that you can do because I think at the end of the day, she doesn't actually have the physical time or energy to make everything as immaculate as her anxiety would demand and so we want to do this dual approach where emotionally we're trying to meet ourselves halfway, but we're allowing our environment to meet us halfway as well into what we build into that environment.

    Amanda Dodson 9:39

    Yes, exactly. And I love like I love your stance on like home care is morally neutral. Because I love the idea that like the way at home is is morally neutral. The only thing to focus on is function and like what pleases you and what would look really nice. So you know for Maria like she was taught If that like having a museum quality home was the only acceptable way. And it's not, it is one acceptable way, I don't know how compatible it is with having children. But if it was just you and your house, you could totally keep your house like that if you wanted to, like, who cares? If you want to have your house just filled with stuff that brings you joy, and you don't care if the dishes are done all week, and like, it's not affecting anybody that lives with you, and it's not affecting you. Like, who cares, you know, you get to make it exactly how you want it. So I think my advice to Maria would be to just really like embrace the fun, even though fun might feel really far embrace the fun of making our home and our home care routines exactly the way that she wants them. And there's

    KC Davis 10:45

    little things like I'm thinking about, like what my family does with shoes. So we have three baskets, and they're pretty, right and they're big, that sit by the back door, and everybody has a basket and we throw shoes into the basket, it is a basket of shoes. And that's fine. For me, it takes me I like it, because it contains them. It also takes me very little time if people's shoes are left out of my shoes or left out to chuck things in there. And somebody else might say I'm fine with a pile on the floor. That doesn't bother me at all. And it's better for me after worry about baskets I'm gonna write, and then someone like Maria, someone else might go, Okay, I can't do the baskets. I'm looking at them. They're all a mess. It really bothers me. And so Maria might be someone who wants those thin shoe holders with the doors that shut a

    Amanda Dodson 11:30

    cover on them so that you can't see the shoes.

    KC Davis 11:33

    Yes, exactly. Yeah. And what Maria probably doesn't want to do, or people like Maria is they don't want to go, Well, I want it to look speaking Spanish. So I'm gonna get those shelves, and they'll sit nicely on the shelf. That's fine, if you like that. But Maria has to be honest with herself about what kind of capacity she has. And so you know, if it's something where I don't want to feel anxiety, every time I looked at it, I want it to look tidy when I'm in taking in my home at you know, as a whole home. But I don't reasonably have the time to sit and make sure every little shoe is lined up perfectly on an open rack. That's when we go okay, so you don't need to see it. And you know, having things with clean lines and shut drawers is going to be more beneficial to you. Because it's just not as she probably has a level of anxiety that just reasonably she could never get house clean enough and live there to satisfy her anxiety. And that's why we're like why I say we're trying to get emotionally Yes, you want to grow? Yes, maybe some therapy, yes, some things like that, you know, but we want your emotional skills and your home to sort of meet halfway in the middle so that you can enjoy your space.

    Amanda Dodson 12:41

    Totally, totally, I love closed storage for Maria. I love clothes storage for her. And we just can't overstate the importance of like baskets. And like cute little dishes like things that can corral items in a way that looks like pleasing to your eye, whatever that is, like in that's also easy to just like throw stuff into right. So you don't have to spend too much time.

    KC Davis 13:10

    And I don't know if Maria has kids. But the other thing that came to mind is like there is this play mat that I saw recently. And it's huge, right? And it's for Lego so your kids sit on their own, they play with their Legos. But the outer edge of the play mat, it's a circle play mat actually has a drawstring in it, it's the bag. So when they're done, you just pick it up and pull the drawstring. And it's a giant bag of Legos. So I think that those are like that's what we're talking about when we're saying when you're thinking about organizational things, right. And then for me, like there's, I've always had a space in my house that's like the Doom space, whether it's a closet or just a box or a whole room where it's like, okay, you know what, my room looks incredible right now it's decorated the way I like it's clean the way I like, and I just redid my daughter's room, because I wanted her to have more space to play in her room cuz she's getting older. But what that meant was I had some things that it didn't have a place and they were kind of bigger. So I had to put them in another room and I now I have a room that was a nice guest room. But now it's kind of a storage room. But that's okay. It's okay to have places in my house that just exists to kind of contain things so that the rest of my house is serving me and enjoyable to me.

    Amanda Dodson 14:21

    Yes, yes. And I love a room. You can close the door.

    KC Davis 14:26

    Absolutely see it? Yes. And if Maria is going to buy a house soon, maybe not an open concept for Maria.

    Amanda Dodson 14:33

    No, no, maybe not an open concept for her. Maybe we need good closet space. Right? Yeah.

    KC Davis 14:40

    So Maria, I have a lot of compassion for you. I hear you. And I hope that that is helpful advice to you and anybody else that's listening that could relate to that situation. So thank you, Amanda, and thank you for listening

KC Davis
08: When Creators Collide, Part II with Kate Leggett

If you joined us for Episode 7, you heard the beginning of my series with Kate. If not, you can listen to Part 1 on the Restoring Relationships Podcast. Kate and I met because of our differing viewpoints as we interacted through TikTok videos. We have since taken the time for discussion, proving that disagreements, conflicts, and drama are part of normal life that should be approached with mutual respect and understanding. 

I’m continuing the conversation with Kate Leggett, a student in her final semester of graduate school to be a Marriage and Family Therapist. Kate uses her TikTok channel to help restore   relationships. Even though our relationship didn’t begin well, we are making strides in communicating with respect and understanding around disagreements and conflicts. The ability to gain a fresh perspective and engage with another person in the face of disagreement is an important topic in today’s world! Listen in and be the “fly on the wall” as we model real-life conflict, relationships, and reconciliation. Join us for a closer look!

Show Highlights:

  • Why KC’s initial reaction to Kate was aggravation

  • The idea behind KC’s context: “How people treat you when they are angry is more revealing than how they treat you when they are happy.”

  • The idea behind Kate’s context: “Anger isn’t necessarily the issue, but the lack of repair after the anger is the issue.”

  • What our backgrounds and upbringings teach us about anger, hurt, abuse, relationships, and our worthiness

  • Why it’s different trying to communicate to the masses, like online, rather than on a one-to-one basis in a relationship

  • What Kate wishes she had done differently in her initial exchange with KC

  • Why we should be able to expect creators, especially those with expertise, to be accountable for their words

  • Why it’s tricky to make mental health content on social media

  • Why therapy content can’t replace in-person therapy

  • Thoughts on relationship boundaries, “gray areas,” and why “people are not disposable”

  • The difference in “Setting boundaries” vs. “Being boundaried”

Resources:

Connect with Kate: Website, TikTok, Podcast

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

  • KC Davis 0:05

    Hello, you sentient balls of stardust. This is struggle care the podcast with your host, KC Davis. And today's episode is a special episode. It's actually a part two, where I talk with fellow content creator and therapist, students, Kate leggett, Kate and I got into a bit of a disagreement online, and then we sat down to hash it out together to have an honest, vulnerable, open conversation. So you don't want to miss part one. Part one is actually happening over on Kate's podcast, which is restoring relationships. So head over there, listen to part one, and then come back here for part two. So without further ado, welcome to part two.

    Kate Leggett 0:44

    The real with me, Casey, how when you saw my first video, what did you think? What were you like? Because you saw I was

    KC Davis 0:52

    totally aggravated? Yeah. Yeah, for sure. And I think I mean, that happens on social media a lot, especially because in the context of like, 60 seconds, yeah, there's so little room for nuance. And sometimes you can be bragging about something. And there's several points that you could make, right. And you're choosing one point. Yeah. And I think what is hard is that when you hear someone say, well, but here's this other point that I think goes into this conversation is one thing, but then sometimes, if I hear someone say, like, no, that point is wrong, because x, and that was my first impression when I watched your video. And but the other context of that, though, is that like, if you and I were just friends that we were like sitting on the couch, and I was like, hey, what do you think about this? And you're like, I don't feel it. I'm not feeling it. Because I think this, then that would have been like a completely different context. But for some reason, when I make videos on like, social media, what it feels like sometimes sometimes it's just the amount. You know what I mean? It's like the ninth stitch that day that I've seen. Yeah, yeah. But like, I was watching something recently, and like the scene was this woman was giving her paper, like her research, like paper at a conference, like her thesis or something. Yeah, something right. It wasn't like her PhD. But she had written this paper. Gotcha. She's presenting it at a conference. She gets like, halfway through and this guy in the audience stands up and is like, how do you sort of reconcile that with these new papers that we found? And she was like, what new paper? Yes, no remaining, like correspondence. And they were like, oh, no, there is it was found two weeks ago. It's over at my college. And she was like, Oh, I look forward to reading and then she like goes about and he's like, Well, but it completely disproves your whole point. And I'm not saying it's like that at all. I'm just saying that like, the feel like the gut feeling as a creator sometimes, yeah. Is that sitting on the couch with a friend just sort of, or like, I call my friends who are therapists all the time? And I say like, here's the thought I have in there, like, No, that's wrong. But sometimes when you're making forward facing, like educational content, yeah. That's what it can feel like. It's like someone standing up in the middle and being like, no wrong. And whether they mean that or not, that's sometimes like the initial reaction.

    Kate Leggett 3:17

    Totally. I mean, to be honest, I've like cringe watching both of the video. So like, you made the first video, I think I your context, was maybe talking about a neighbor. Like was that kind of what you're thinking like when someone's Oh,

    KC Davis 3:33

    so the TikTok that I made was the one more I said, I have a boundary that I go by, and I apply it to everyone. And that is you're only as good as how you treat me when you're angry? Mm hmm. Okay. Yeah. So that was the comment. Yeah. And it blew up. Because obviously, there are lots of ways that you could take that there are lots of like, personal experiences that you can kind of project onto that. And, and people did like, there were some people that were like, Absolutely, yes. And then there are people that like, no, absolutely not, don't judge me by my worst moments. Yeah. And like the context that I was referring to, was I was thinking about how so many times in relationships that are really harmful, toxic, like worst case, relationships that are abusive, but even ones that are just toxic? Do you know what I mean? I think that what happens a lot of times is that when we think about relationships that are harmful or degrading to ourselves, we picture an abusive person being abusive all the time. Right? Right. Right. Like and surely that exists right there. It does exist that there's like the guy that comes home and dinner's not on the table at exactly six and he like bangs you over the head with a plate, right? That exists but I think that a lot of people have the idea that that's what abuse and degradation, right bad toxic relationship look like. And then what they're experiencing is that this person is sweet to me and kind To me, most of the time, but when they get angry, they tell me I'm a stupid cut. Who in No wonder nobody loves you. But it only happens when they're angry. And so they're living this life of well, it's just because he's angry. And some people grew up in an environment where they think that that's just what everyone does when they're angry. Right? Yeah.

    Kate Leggett 5:24

    I mean, I grew up in that environment. Yeah.

    KC Davis 5:27

    Like that was sort of my context was like, totally, we need to judge people by that standard, not just how, how you try, gotcha, when you're happy with me, is the standard, that I judge people by how you treat me when you're angry with me, like, Are you capable of like, treating me like a human being with dignity even when you're angry with me? Right. So that was my context.

    Kate Leggett 5:53

    And that makes total sense. I think anger is a really hard, complicated thing to deal with and talk about in real life, because it's so scary. And I think especially with women, it's, you know, our anger is more internalizing, and it's depression and anxiety more than it is yelling and screaming all the time, or, you know, or so anyway, I think it's such a nuanced thing. I appreciate your different context. I definitely looking back was coming from my context, obviously. And I think what would have been more helpful and constructive,

    KC Davis 6:34

    Before you tell me that, I totally want to hear your context, though.

    Kate Leggett 6:37

    Yeah, okay. Well, I appreciate that. My context is that anger isn't necessarily the issue. It's the lack of repair after anger, that's the issue, it can be so destructive. But at the same time, if someone's 20 years old, and at school, they were bullied, and on the bus, they were bullied. And at home, they were neglected. And, I mean, you know, we envision that as like, you're saying, kind of the incessant assault, and it's not like that. It's more like those five comments, maybe from the same person or random, you know, whatever. And, you know, I think that's, especially now in schools, like kids on social media in high school, like, I can't even imagine the language that they're just around, you know, it's kind of I think of that cruelty as, like a second language in a way, you know, if you're smaller, you have to adapt in a way that is effective for you. And a lot of times, that's, you know, being the meanest person possible. I mean, I recently read this book by Jon Ronson. It's. So you've been publicly shamed. And it literally talks about people that have been canceled, it's real stories, it's so good. And it just taught the he interviews this troll from, I don't know, Reddit, or some online community. And she gives kind of context and a face to a true on online troll. And it's like, they're this person that has zero power, anywhere, and even out in the world. And like, people can't loiter anymore. Like they can't hang out in general areas, because of like, Stop and Frisk is out at us. Yeah. So anyway, so they're this just powerless person, and they don't know anything else. And so I think people like that still can have a healthy relationship if they want. So it's more so like, you're gonna be this way. Like, it's going to be natural for you when you get angry to like, cut throat. But if you recognize that and like, become aware of that, and like, builds, you know, change, like there's an opportunity for change, right? Yeah.

    KC Davis 8:49

    And what you're saying is, you are still deserving of love and compassion, even that person, and they actually, here's how I experienced that and how I experienced it a lot of times is that so when I made that tic tock that was my context, that was my and even if I really look at myself, and I identify my own personal context, which is that I grew up in an environment where for in sort of different people, but all in my childhood, were very cutthroat with me, and cruel to me when they were angry. And I went through so much hard work, trying to get sober trying to heal trying to be a healthy person, that I no longer have any tolerance for anyone that treats me that way. And again on that axes, right, like, I'm not gonna like throw away my you know, Mom, if she gets angry and said something, right. But if I make a new friend or dating someone, and that is something that comes up with them, what happens with me is, Hey, you are a person, you have dignity. You have the right to recover at your own pace. I don't think you're unworthy of love. Hmm, but I'm not going to continue a relationship with you like that you're not the person for me where your places are. And I think a lot of times what happens, especially in talks about this is that like, I'm almost talking as if I'm the therapist of that woman who's like, but he's nice most of the time, or that man who's like, well, she's great most of the time, but then she, you know, tells me that I'm worth nothing, and no one will love me, and someone else hears it, but like you hear it, and what you think of is like, you're the therapist of that person sitting in your office crying, because when they get angry, they fly off the handle, and they feel like they don't deserve a good healthy relationship, because they keep hurting people. And your job is to come around them and say, like, that doesn't make you not worthy, right how to do it again, I wish I would have chosen a different language than saying, you're only as good as, because that implies that I'm making a judgement about their worthiness. And that wasn't my intention. And so and I've tried to explain that, but yeah, you know, people felt very triggered by that, that the goodness was referring to like, goodness of fit, or like, good for me.

    Right? Right. Like, I'm not going to judge you on how you treat me when you're nice. I'm Judging You by how you treat me when you're angry with your dad, I'm not judging your worthiness, but I am judging whether or not I'm going to be in this relationship with you appropriate to that X Y axis. So it was an interesting interaction, because I thought that there's this very interesting conversation in the intersection of cut off culture, and like boundaries and toxicity that I think we're still trying to figure out because we've swung to both sides, right on from this sort of, like white supremacy cut off, act the right way, or I'm done with you. And we're trying to say, Well, let's not do cut off culture. But I think sometimes we swing all the way to like, you should accept all behavior from all people at all time, right? When the truth is so nuanced.

    Kate Leggett 12:03

    I totally agree. And it's, it is so nuanced. And I think, you know, so your context, if I'm getting this right is like kind of when you're meeting new people, and when you're choosing, like when you have choice and still like autonomy, and my context more, is it within the context of a long term relationship. So again, so, you know, say, you grew up this way, you got married, you've been married for 15 years. And then you're kind of learning about all this toxicity, and you're going to therapy, and you're like, oh, shit, like, this is so bad. What do I do, I go online, I look at all this stuff. And everything's just like Leave, leave, leave, leave. And it's like, so much more complex than that. And I think that's a swing the pendulum thing where women, for example, haven't been able to leave a marriage, you know, ever, until, you know, 1973 or four, I think we can have a credit card like, so women haven't been able to leave before. And then now we have the option. But like, I just think it's fascinating that even when you have the option you don't like what is that? And so I wanted to add a nother voice to the conversation of like, you don't have to just like leave right now. And because that perpetuates the breakup makeup cycle. And it's like not as simple as when they're angry or what because you probably do it to like, that's the thing is like, they might do it, but you probably do it too. And even if you don't do it in the same way, you might, you know, a lot. Esther Perel talks about how women lie by omission or like denying more so than, like, an explicit lie. And anyway, so I think that influence of social media all there's so much information, and I think my voice on that platform is just like, it's not all or nothing. And there's always like, I just believe so much in redemption and restoration of relationships, especially like people aren't disposable, your life isn't disposable, like, you don't have to leave your kids and your whole, you know, like your whole life to like, be healthy and safe. And so

    KC Davis 14:13

    I think the interesting thing to me about making, like mental health or therapy content is that if we had an actual couple and an office, like if you and I were both like tag teaming, like therapy, and we were both like seeing a couple, and we had to decide whether to give the not necessarily advice, but whether or not we think, Hey, we should encourage this person to break this relationship off. Or we should encourage this person to not just, you know, toss away something, I bet you 99.9% of the time that you and I would actually agree on which of those things to say, based on one specific individual when we could see all of the different variables, all of the different like what is behavior, how long has the behavior been happening? What is this person's willingness to work on it? What's this person's willingness to work on it? How long have they been together? Like, I bet you we would agree, because there'd be times when we would be like, ooh, considering it's that type of violent behavior, or it's been that consistent of toxic behavior, that this person doesn't seem to want to change that content. He, you know, the gaslit, whatever, like, we'd be like, Oh, you're better than this baby. Or he'd be like, No, you know what, like, you guys are both healing. Like, I don't need to throw away a 15 year marriage, because you're both coming like that, when you're making content for the masses. It gets really tricky to communicate in a way that has enough nuance that truism like, Hold truth for people, right? Make sense.

    Kate Leggett 15:48

    Yeah. And I think what I'm getting is like, when the relationship is there, like when you and I are in the room with these people, we've spent time like so much time with them, we really gotten to know them. That's when as people we can kind of have it's, like, see it for what it is. Whereas online, there's no relationship. And so everyone's coming from all their different experiences, and it's just like a mess. And yeah, I think my favorite thing I've learned in school is like, you know, the highest like, factor that determines a positive client outcome is the quality of the therapeutic relationship. Like, it's not the technique, it's not the research, it's not the treatment, it's like, it's literally the quality of the relationship. And that's totally missing on social media, like, especially for with creators and audiences. And so I think it's really powerful that we can connect in this way. And kind of, I mean, I definitely, like feel badly about how I communicated my contacts. And I think I could have added a lot of, I think I could have given a lot of like, I don't know, cushioned it a lot more and like seeing you and validated your point, while also making mine. I think that I chose the approach that was like mine over yours. And I think that just that's not as helpful and not the kind

    KC Davis 17:18

    And I hear you, I hear you and I think that that's like a lovely thing about you, you know, just like I'm reflecting on like, probably should have said good. But what the other thing that I think this brings up that's really interesting is that therapists are seen as professionals, and when we speak in a session, or when we write a paper or we write like, it's like we have all this time to formulate our thoughts, choose the exact right words, things like that. But on social media, particularly on Tik Tok, where there's kind of a discourse happening. Even though I always attempt to be intentional, it's hard to feel like you get graded on every single word being the exact right word, every single intonation and every single and you're like, Okay, maybe, and then you end up kind of defending everyone and going well, it's an information superhighway. So like to see a video and go, wait, I have some input, and then go on there and give your input. Like, we should also have a little more grace for each other. Yeah. And, you know, okay, here's this feeling of defensiveness I'm having, but how can I use my own tools of regulation to sort of breathe through that? Let that sit and then make sure that when I'm actually engaging with that person, I'm not sort of like shots fired? Like, unless someone's obviously come at me and being rude. But yeah, cuz I mean, it's the same thing happened to me when people are like, good, good. I can't believe you said, good. You shouldn't have said good. And I'm like, Okay, well, I didn't mean it in that context. And then people were like, Yeah, but you should have known your audience. You should have known we would take that were like, yeah, maybe you're right. But also like, it's like, it's okay. Like, it's firing off the hip, right? Yeah. Yeah. Not most things I say on Tik Tok are not some long scripted, going through. I mean, listen, when I wrote my book, the amount of edits back and forth, and then it went to a sensitivity reader, right, someone that I paid to read it from a different point of view, making sure and I changed words, singular words, yeah, my book, because of the impact they might have on people. But I think we have to hold this tension of, yes, I can expect creators, especially ones that have some sort of social credit or some expertise to be accountable to their words, and recognize that like, this platform is not putting out content that is going through like several rounds of edits and making sure and that way, if they use a word here or there, they don't need to be crucified for it. Yeah,

    Kate Leggett 19:39

    I totally agree. I think that's a really great point. And that kind of packages, everything that I think is conflict resolution, and like a relationship and like health and growth. And I mean, because we're doing like when you're doing tic TOCs, three to four hours a day. You're just like, it's like, Oh, I'm just going about my day. I have this thought I'm going to post it and And then it's okay. You know,

    KC Davis 20:03

    Same thing that you talked about with like, relationship like cut off versus so and I think another great example of that, though, is when it comes to division of labor. Mm hmm. So there has been such an issue with women shouldering the whole division of labor, and men putting that upon them. And men not caring about that, and men being unwilling to step to the plate and redistribute that the pendulum has swung all the way over, where if someone makes a tick, talk about how, like they're frustrated that they're doing too much around the house, the comments are like, Leave him leave him, Lea, kick them, leave them. And, and here's the thing, like,

    Kate Leggett 20:47

    It's so funny to me,

    KC Davis 20:48

    Right. And so I think in that is that same nuance that we're talking about, where sometimes I see someone say something where it's like, no matter the context, that's not okay. And I wish that that woman could find a way to not put up with that. However, this is where I am like you where I'm like, Okay, you guys like, this is a systemic issue. And there are good men and loving fathers and loving husbands that are really operating under what I call Dad and male privilege. And they don't see it. They don't know what they don't know. They don't know what they don't know, they don't see it. And like, we don't need to throw away the whole relationship. Like it's like, yeah, exactly, like, give them the chance to go through a process of unpacking this huge piece of privilege, systemic, right blood. And it takes patience, and it takes

    Kate Leggett 21:50

    time. It takes time. Like, it doesn't happen like this. And I think that's the kind of goes back to the whole thing of like, if you're angry, you know, like, it's not just a transactional thing of like you being angry boundary or like, cut off, you know, like, it's a reciprocal thing. It's not a transactional thing. It's more like, over time, slowly, gently over time, but consistently, and giving people the chance, you know, but I think it doesn't make it any less painful, I think. And that's what is the thing, it's like, when we see that every time even though we know it, even though maybe we've worked through that, or we've helped people do that. It's still like, Ah, I hate this is this makes me feel so bad.

    KC Davis 22:38

    It's a tricky thing about making mental health content, because I don't want to make a piece of content that says, You shouldn't put up with you know, unequal distribution of labor, you should not, you know, live your life being like in this position of never getting to have your own identity, never getting to have your life with someone who refuses to take like, I don't want to make that content. And then someone who is married to a good man that doesn't see it goes, Okay, that's what Casey Davis said, I'm done with you. But conversely, I don't want to make a piece of content that says, you know, what, like, guys are really trying, like they've been indoctrinated their whole life, like we really need to have some patience, and some woman in a relationship where that man is refusing to do anything that saying, I don't care, Melissa, you're the one that wanted kids. I'm gonna go on my 10 day hunting trip. And you clean everything. You figure it out, like, I don't want that woman to hear that content go. Okay, well, I don't want to be like a bad person, or I don't want to not be nice. So I guess I'll just stay with it. And I think that is like the crux of everything we're talking about. Totally till right is like and I don't want because we want to help people. And I don't want either advice, piece of advice. Or even worse, I don't want some man to hear and be like, see, Melissa, you should be patient with me. Messing around the house.

    Kate Leggett 24:02

    I hate those comments. I get like, Oh, my boyfriend just sent this to me, like I don't know, like enabling his own thoughtlessness and negligence,

    KC Davis 24:12

    but I don't want our Yeah, it's our advice weaponized? Well. And I think

    Kate Leggett 24:16

    that that is a great reason that to, I think have these conversations and to bring, you know, another platform to a 62nd video or a couple interactions. And I think this circles back to the whole thing that struck me about you from the minute I saw your videos two years ago was that like you are doing what is best for you. And that is having an impact on everyone else. And I think like ultimately people get to decide for themselves like just because we're trained as therapists just because we have this following just because we have a TEDx talk in a book like we don't live your life and wake up in your bed and have The experiences you've had and have the job you have, and the kids and the family, you know, the work culture, wherever you are, like, we don't have that. So take it with a grain of salt. And like, if it brings you relief, if it makes you feel hopeful for the future, then maybe it's good for you. And if it makes, you know, like, I don't know, what's your own system of decision

    KC Davis 25:22

    What is your support system also, that's another reason for like, emphasis of, like therapy content can't replace in person therapy totally, because an emphasis therapist would be able to contextualize that advice for you and tell you whether or not that was good advice for this time. So even if you can't afford a therapist, like having a good support system of friends, people that you can check things out with like, because I could call a good friend that knows me knows my husband knows my marriage, and say, Hey, I heard this thought this content about how I should not put up with XYZ or how I should always forgive XYZ. And my support system, I think of it like a strainer. Yeah, right. Like I can put the whole can of soup in there. And they will be able to help me see. Okay, but Casey and this assertion, like you're someone who is so constantly struggled with boundaries, and like, yeah, I feel like you have to forgive everyone, because you feel like you have to be some good Christian girl. Or they can go, okay, Casey, but you also are so afraid of being abandoned, you have this history of abandoning people first, so that they don't abandon you. And I'm afraid that maybe this advice is sort of helping you do that, like, it's really key to have totally

    Kate Leggett 26:37

    I love that. I think that is ideal. And I think people that do have the support also have you know, that's you're very lucky, you know, and but it takes time to build and it's the most important thing ever, like when I got married is when I kind of realized the value of my girlfriends. I was like everyone matters. This isn't like the one person that's going to do everything like it's a system, like you said, and I think that's where social media can fall short as these parasocial relationships that aren't real relationships where people know you intimately as an individual, and they just know your online persona. And I think I love that. I think that's the biggest point that people matter. People aren't disposable, relationships are real. And that's like, my opinion is like, they're the hardest thing. But it's the bravest thing to face your shit and a relationship and, like, grow from the inside out in a way so.

    KC Davis 27:40

    And I think when we say people, I love that just like boiling it down to people are not disposable. Because I feel like that speaks to both truths that like you and I kind of feel passionate about, which is on the one hand like people are not disposable. And so like they don't deserve to be thrown away over one mistake. They even people with extremely ingrained patterns of sort of maybe reactive abuse or borderline personality disorder or PTSD, exactly at are having trouble regulating. Yeah, in the midst of overwhelming feelings. And sometimes that comes out as being mean. They don't deserve to be thrown away. Yeah, just because they like we don't choose how abuse shapes our reactions. And for some of us abuse makes us curl in and become a doormat and say yes, okay, no matter what, and for others of us, abuse makes us puff up and get big and reactive. So I will hurt you before you hurt me. Yeah. And there's not like one of those doesn't make you a better person or a more worthy person of being in a relationship and you're not disposable. You deserve somebody who will love you and work through that with you. And, and keywords also true that you are not disposable. And so if the person you are in relationship with regardless of how genuine their struggle is, continues to engage in behavior that demeans you and belittles you and makes you feel disposable. You don't have to decide that that person is not worthy of love to decide that. You don't want to be desolation.

    Kate Leggett 29:24

    Yeah, it doesn't work for you. Like you're not right fitting, you're not growing, you're not learning. It's not changing. I think that's like the key is like it's not changing, no matter what happens

    KC Davis 29:36

    And changing like long term, not just oh, tomorrow they're sorry. Right,

    Kate Leggett 29:40

    Right. The transactional thing like like a heart, yeah, it's deeper. It's not just behavior. It's an attitude. And, yeah, I love that.

    KC Davis 29:49

    And sometimes I need that support to help us figure out what's inside of that. How do I balance that? How do I balance the fact that I am a person who Who deserves love and community and respect? And that other person is too? So like, how do we navigate that? Because it's not true that like, one of us deserves to be abused just because this person deserves to not be alone. But yeah, right. It's also true that this person doesn't deserve to be thrown away just because they struggle in a certain way. And so how do we help people navigate relationships, where they are both worthy of love and respect and dignity. And sometimes, that will mean they stay together and reconcile the relationship. And sometimes it means that they decide to discontinue that relationship, in order to preserve both their own dignity and the dignity of the other

    Kate Leggett 30:44

    totally. And sometimes it's more nuanced, where they just need a break, and they need to move out. And they need to get different jobs where they're not working together and separate, but not in an existential way. And that's totally parts of it. But I think this has just been such an enriching conversation of you're so intelligent and see things and I think your platform is really I don't know, I just think this will have a huge impact, hopefully, thank you

    KC Davis 31:11  

    It reminds me of sometimes when I'm talking to people that are married, and they're trying to like, quote, unquote, set boundaries, but the only like, boundary, they notice that is like, if you don't fill in the blank, I'm gonna leave. And but they're not actually like ready to leave, they don't want to leave. They don't want to do that. But they're so frustrated, because they can't get their partner to like, make some necessary changes. And so they come and they're like, Okay, so do I stay? Or do I leave? And it reminds me of what you said, where it's like, that's such black and white thinking, yeah, right. Like, those are the only two choices that I need to make them now. And I'm such a fan of reminding people that there's so much gray area in between, including, you know, okay, like, Let's separate, let's live in different places for a while. And you can live in different places and not be in relationship, but stay married, you can live in different places, and remain monogamous, but not see each other. You could remain living in different places and date each other.

    Kate Leggett 32:14  

    Yeah. And, you know, I think of going back to how you said, people setting boundaries, it's kind of more on someone else's behavior than it is around your own well being. So I like to think of it as like, okay, when you do this, it makes me I get really angry. And when you continue to do it, I get angrier and angrier, especially when I'm telling you to stop doing it, it doesn't change. And for myself, I don't like myself, when I get that angry. I don't like feeling that out of control. And so because of that I'm going to take care of myself and remove might go to the other room or sleep in a separate bed or take a walk or take care of myself. I like thinking about boundaries is that too, because it's for yourself, but also acknowledging the other. But it's not like only the other because I think you know, I think the biggest to me a huge takeaway from this conversation is it's always and it's not either, or it's always and there's always gray area. And I think support is what helps you discern what that is.

    KC Davis 33:20  

    I also think because I believe in boundaries in the same way you do I always tell people boundaries is not about how close I will let you come. It's about how far I'm willing to go. It's not about trying to control the behavior of people around me. Yeah, it's about understanding that there is a point where I end and you begin, yeah.

    Kate Leggett 33:40  

    And understanding myself. Yeah. Understanding myself in this environment of you of this environment of the relationship. Yeah,

    KC Davis 33:48  

    yeah. Yeah, I always like I think that being I try not to use the language of setting boundaries. I think that the better language is being boundaried. Ooh, that's good. Like, I am a boundary the person you have boundaries, whether you like it or not, yeah, I just am going to act as if I have them. I can honor them. And I think that's that understanding of like, there's a place in time, there's an emotional social context where I end and you begin, so I'm not responsible for what happens after that stopping point, right? I am responsible to you I'm not responsible for you.

    Kate Leggett 34:28  

    Yes. Yes.

    KC Davis 34:32  

    I'm not responsible for what you feel, but I am responsible to you, meaning I don't get to say, you know, I don't get to like act horrific towards you and and be like, I'm not responsible for your feelings like No, but I am responsible to you. I am receiving your feelings. Yeah, yeah. I'm responsible to, you know, how I treat you and my own behavior. Yeah, right. And

    Kate Leggett 34:52  

    I think I think and there are limits to my responsibility also, like that's what you're saying not for but to Like record that in itself recognizes your own limits. You can't control someone else you can influence it. That's really it. Yeah. Well, I don't really know how to I haven't figured out how to like, end these things. How to land the plane. I want to lay it off awkwardly,

    KC Davis 35:17  

    And I'm like, Okay, well, sounds good. Well, I can say that this has been a really cool conversation. This is like one of my favorite things to talk about is that sort of nuance between sort of this weird place we find ourselves in of giving, making mental health content, knowing everything is super nuanced, and dealing with how we contextualize that and how we intersect with other people who may be contextualizing it differently for different and very valid reasons.

    Unknown Speaker 35:46  

    Yeah, and giving ourselves grace in the process of figuring it out in this, like ever evolving, ever changing, like, social media landscape. But yeah, it was really I feel like I'm gonna be processing this conversation for days. There's it was so rich with perspective and information. And yeah, I think most of all, I appreciate like, just the opportunity to, I don't know, connect over our similarities and our differences and perspective and, you know, respectful, fun engaging way. So thanks so much, KC.

    KC Davis 36:27  

    Thank you.

    .

Christy Haussler
07: Teaser: When Creators Collide

I’m offering up an appetizer–because today’s show is a teaser for an upcoming two-part episode. Disagreements, conflicts, and drama are part of normal life, but there CAN be mutual respect and understanding at the same time. 

I’m talking with Kate Leggett, a student in her final semester of graduate school to be a Marriage and Family Therapist. Kate uses her TikTok channel to help restore relationships, and we became aware of each other because of a video exchange on TikTok. Our relationship certainly didn’t begin well, but we are making strides in communicating with respect and understanding around disagreements and conflicts. Come along as we model real-life conflict, relationships, and reconciliation. Join us for a closer look!

Show Highlights:

  • How Kate felt the need to fill in the gray area in relationships around boundaries and toxic relationships

  • How online interactions can be transactional, personal, and very different with someone with whom you have a prior relationship

  • A look at the TikTok videos that started the interaction between Kate and KC–and the thoughts behind the comments

  • How people hold conflict in different and vulnerable ways

  • How KC and Kate made space for deeper conversations around their conflict

  • The difficulties around communication and conflict in the social media space

  • An overview of Kate’s podcast, RR The Podcast, which you can find on YouTube and Spotify (Part 1 of Kate and KC’s conversation is up now!)

  • Kate’s perspective on the much-used phrase, “You teach people how to treat you.”

  • How to listen to the rest of our “respectful drama”

Resources:

Connect with Kate: Website, TikTok, Podcast

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

  • Unknown Speaker 0:00

    KC Davis 0:04

    Hello you sentient balls of stardust. Welcome to Struggle Care. The podcast by me, KC Davis, a therapist and host who kind of hates the term self care. Today I want to talk about what happens when to online content creators and one being a therapist, one being a therapist student, get into a bit of an online clash. And what is it like for us to actually see the people beyond the screen. I'm talking today with Kate leggett, who is a therapy student who runs the account, restoring relationships. She and I had an interesting conversation via Tik Tok, where we really disagreed about something and we kind of came out swinging. And then Kate did something interesting. She reached out to me and asked me if I would talk with her. What follows here is a little teaser about what we sat down and talked about and what it was like for us to sit down as two mental health professionals and unpack the conflict that happened. I hope you enjoy.

    Kate, you and I sort of came across each other via Tik Tok, and really got, like became aware of each other through a video exchange. Yeah, correct. Which is interesting, because first of all, I find online the online space. So interesting. I was actually doing recording recently with a woman named Yolanda, who I've kind of become friends with. But we had done like a live together. We had talked together, we had planned to do a podcast together. And I had done a Tik Tok where I was referencing, like sleep training. And she had commented and said like cry out is trauma. And what's interesting to me is that, like there were a lot of people commenting on it, and how like I get defensive, and I want to push back. And I think and it comes across as a comment on my parenting. But what was interesting to me is that, because I know Yolanda, she said something that tons of other people were saying, and yet I held it differently because she and I have a relationship. Right. Right. Like I didn't immediately hold it as she's talking about me, I held it as this is a strong opinion that belongs to her. Right. Right. It's super interesting to me how different that is, when there's an existing relationship.

    Kate Leggett 2:25

    That's right. And I think that brings up an interesting point how online, you know, relationships, I guess, or interactions are so transactional, and they can feel so personal. But then when you know, someone there's like, it's like a different energy. It's hard to describe, I'm still figuring out how to put it into words.

    But I love that, that that's been we're able to experience..

    KC Davis 2:48

    Yeah, a couple of times, like somebody will say something. And I'll just have more space to hold that. Even if it seems like they're criticizing me, but I know them. And so I have a completely different context. And I thought it was interesting in comparison, because you and I honestly kind of met the opposite way. Like our first interaction was just like a couple of shots across the bow. It was a conflicting opinion. Yeah. And so I wanted to play those TikToks for us. Yeah. So this was the TikTok that I posted first, and so I'm gonna play it so we can hear it.

    Okay. I have a life rule that I judge everyone by and I think you should do. And it's that a person is only as good as how they treat you when they are angry with you. So that was the one that I posted. And pretty quickly, you had a stitch to it. So I'm gonna play your stitch.

    Kate Leggett 3:41

    So this video right here is exemplary of the concept I call cut off culture, it's the same thing as canceled culture, just in the smaller systems of relationships. The problem with it is that it doesn't solve the problem, it reinforces the problem. In the mental health field, there's literally the term cut off, which is cutting somebody off. So you don't have to feel those hard emotions. You see it a lot in families where there's geographical cut off where someone will move across the country to get away from their family. But when they come back, and they're around their family, they're just as reactive as if they never left, y'all. It wasn't 100 years ago that three year olds were cleaning chimneys. Like we're still catching up emotionally with what is healthy and relationships. And I see this in my office all the time. Sometimes cutting someone off isn't the answer that learning how to deal with it is.

    KC Davis 4:33

    Okay, so yeah, let me ask you this. Let me start with this. What like thoughts were going through your head what emotions were going through your body when you viewed my tic toc? Be very honest, because I'm going to be honest too.

    Kate Leggett 4:45

    Okay. All right. Well, the first thing I think that struck me was you used the word judge. And my context is relationships. So it kind of annoyed me. I thought it was a general realization, which is funny, you know, it's ironic we all, you know, I thought it was a generalization. And I thought it was pretty antithetical this. So these are my thoughts that it was pretty antithetical to my own message a lot of the time because I talk so much about women and anger. And it's such an internalized thing that we don't even know, were aware of it. And so part of my whole, like, theory on restoring yourself in a relationship is restoring your anger at the gaslighting at the, you know, in justices that are upon you. So when I saw that, and put it in my own context of my platform, and my audience, it annoyed me, and I didn't think it fit and I guess in, you know, giving myself the benefit of the doubt, I think it deserves some clarification and like expansion into different contexts.

    KC Davis 6:08

    Okay, follow up question. What are you okay, all right now, sitting here and saying it to me?

    Kate Leggett 6:16

    Gee, uh, well, I mean, I think watching it and hearing it is hard. Because now that I've interacted with you a couple of times, and there's we don't have the most developed relationship. But I would say, you know, I'm more fond of you now, because of interacting with you than I, you know, that's normal. I'm nervous. I'm very, I wouldn't say confrontational but comfortable with conflict and disagreement and relationship. And so because that's backwards for us, my heart is pounding a little bit.

    KC Davis 6:52

    Thank you for being honest about that. I think that's a cool thing. Because I feel similarly in that, like, I actually can hold conflict pretty well.

    Kate Leggett 7:01

    Yeah.

    KC Davis 7:02

    Right. Like, I can deal with the beating heart, I can deal with the, like, sort of holding that truth. But it's still not like a walk in the park. Like, right, I have a good friend. Go ahead.

    Kate Leggett 7:13

    I was gonna say I'm like trying to take deep breaths and not make it audible in the microphone.

    Okay, so my therapist supervisor, when I did my supervisory hours, she had this saying that is kind of coming to mind right now where she talked about, like, basically, she talked about differentiation, which, if you're listening, you don't know what that means. Think of differentiation, for love. We're just gonna use some pop psychology terms, because I think that's easiest differentiation would be like the opposite of codependency. Yeah. Right. So like, understanding, you know, that I'm a different person and things like that. And she used to talk about how, like, the most important skill you could have in a relationship was to be able to hold on to yourself in the face of someone else's emotions. Mm hmm. And so I practice that skill. And I feel like that's what really what you're talking about, which is like, Okay, we're gonna talk about something that is not necessarily like congruent between the two of us. Like, there's some disagreement. There's some feelings, there's some.

    KC Davis 8:14

    And there's a lot of vulnerability, because I know, so let me let me tell you kind of what my experience was. So the first time I saw your TikTok, the first thing I felt was anger.

    And yeah, and part of it was, I think, like, that wasn't necessarily the context I was speaking of. So I sort of felt like it was being misrepresented. But honestly, a big part of it was like, because I consider myself an expert, right? I had this moment of like, Who is this person? To like, tell me that I'm wrong about this thing. I'm an expert in and listen, that is super shitty. And I'm not proud that that was something that I thought but it was like that was like the humaneness that came out. Right.

    Kate Leggett 8:59

    I love it. I mean, you're saying it now too. I think that's another layer to this for me is that I remember being like, here we go. Like I'm posting this. She's this expert. Like she's licensed. She has a TEDx. Oh, I don't know if you did that at that point. But you have a million followers and I'm just a student and even I feel like that right now. It's like surreal to even be discussing this with you on your podcast and mine that's coming out to you know, it's just, it's wild. So, I don't know if I would say it's a power dynamic, but it's definitely like, I totally respect your authority on these things. For sure. And you know, again, and I'm really grateful but also very anxious to keep going and even I remember I made a comment on yours, where I said, this is not applicable period. My TikTok was about justifying toxic and abusive behavior when someone is angry because, quote, they treat me so well when things are good and a quote. And I remember writing that and being like, like, obviously I didn't want to be mean, but I did. I definitely wanted to be. I didn't want to be dismissive, but that was like the feeling that I had. Right. I felt Yeah, yes. So well, that. And, you know, you and I are going to spend a lot of time getting into those experiences. So I don't want to do too much like reconciliation. Yeah, right now, that's no fun. Because that's what the next two episodes of our podcasts are about, is us sitting down and talking about how did you feel? And how did I feel? And I think what's so interesting is, and you can tell me what your experience was, because we've actually already recorded those. Yeah, yeah. But I think what was the most interesting for me in that process was how, when we were sitting in front of each other, and we had talked about, like, who we were and where we were coming from, and the things that we cared about, and we were re expressing really the same message, right? Like, I stand by what I meant, and that tick tock, and I know that you stand by what you meant and your response. But what was so interesting to me was how differently we communicated it to each other when there was one, like, in the forefront of our mind was like, a another person with whom we are in relationship with. Right? Did you feel that too? I did. And I think for me, it was just the space, you know, like, the conversation and not so much the exchange? Because, yeah, I mean, because after that comment, too, I doubled down and made another video. And so I just like, my experience recording that episode was, it was so cathartic, I don't know if that was the word. But just so I don't know, it's just so nice, the space to figure it out, and not have to fit it in a however many characters on a comment or in a message, where tone is can be misread. And there are so many factors of like nonverbal communication that are just easy to miss. So even talking now, it's like, this is what it should be, to me is this, like holding the space, but actually having the space, it goes a lot, I think to say about what the social media space is, and what it means. And I think we're still in our infancy of figuring out what it means to relate to other people in a social media space. Because I have had people sort of come out shots blaring to disagree with me. And they did not like me, and they were antagonistic against me, and they were committed to remaining. So then what can happen is that you have that experience, and then you start to like, see every experience like that. Right? You know what I mean? And then once you go in with your one little like, defensive, you know, response, and it's like, no, now I'm committed.

    KC Davis 13:08

    Yeah, I'm committed. Right? So what we did is that we sat down, and we recorded a big long episode, where we talked in depth about this and our thoughts and feelings about it. And what we would have done differently, had we kind of been able to have that conversation first. And I think it was a really, really cool thing to do. And so we are going to now talking to the audience, obviously, you know this, because we already talked about this. But we're going to split that episode into two different podcast episodes. The first episode is going to release on Kate's platform. So do you want to plug kind of the name and when that will release?

    Kate Leggett 13:47

    Yeah, so my account is restoring relationships. And I actually I don't know if you know this, but I changed the name since I saw you. Now it's going to be kind of, you know, as these things happen, my podcast is restoring relationships. And it's basically just conversations between me and other people whose background is in mental health, where the audience is just kind of getting a fly on the wall perspective. And yeah, part one of this episode is out now. Nice. And can they subscribe on all major platforms? Are you on a specific platform? They can subscribe on YouTube and Spotify right now?

    KC Davis 14:28

    Okay, excellent. Okay, part one of our conversation is up on restoring relationships right now. And then next week, so next Monday, tune in and part two of that conversation will be up here at the struggle care podcast, and I'm excited for you guys to hear it. I think it's super. It really is like a fly on the wall perspective of two people talking and just holding on to themselves in the face of this new relationship and I'm excited for you guys to see it. I did want to leave people with a little like nuggetof information or like expertise today. And so I wanted to ask you about a phrase that gets used a lot. And I'm curious your perspective from a restoring relationship perspective. So the phrase is, you teach people how to treat you. Thoughts? Do you like it? Do you not like it?

    Kate Leggett 15:22

    I don't like to hear that. I don't like it. I hate it. Now, I would love to kind of process this with you. I don't know if I have a complete thought on it right now. But my initial thought is, I hate it. Because I feel like it puts the responsibility of other people's behavior on yourself. And my context, my platform is about pushing, taking that off letting people you know, the boundaries. Yeah, I kind of like when I hear it, I think there are some ways in which I think what it's trying to say is true. And there are some ways in which what it's actually saying is totally not true. That's like my initial thought. And I think I would agree with you that like that phrase, I think gets used to blame primarily women, yeah. For being in a relationship where the other person is not treating them with respect, like, somehow it's the woman's fault in that way. It's a very stupid phrase. I totally agree. And I think that the people that hear that phrase and internalize it, whoever it's targeted to our women, and I think what that also reinforces, is, it's kind of like behaviorism, you know, where it's transactional between two people. And it's like, you teach people how to treat you, like you teach a dog, how to respond to reward and reinforcement.

    KC Davis 16:51

    Yeah, it is really dehumanizing. You shouldn't treat your partners or your kids like their dogs, like you don't train them. Yeah, I actually ran with you on that.

    Kate Leggett 17:00

    And you're not someone's teacher, like, you know, perhaps the more important, like, you're not supposed to educate, you know, this. That's so much energy. And I think there's needs to be maybe the sentence itself is incomplete. You teach people how to treat you, and they need to want to learn,

    KC Davis 17:23

    Or maybe it's better to, like, you teach people how you expect to be treated, right? Like I can communicate my expectations to you, I can communicate my limits to you my boundaries about the kinds of things I will and won't, like tolerate in a relationship, but I'm not actually teaching you how to behave.

    Kate Leggett 17:41

    I still think that's an individual individualistic phrase, I think, well, if the context is in relationship, you know, it's not a neighbor down the street. And it's someone you're in a relationship, friendship, romantic co worker, you know, like, where you're in it. I think the missing piece sometimes is you can teach someone all day long, and expect them to change all day long. But if they're not in that process with you kind of consensually, they're not going to and they don't want to learn, and no matter what you do,

    KC Davis 18:17

    Yeah, that's honestly my issue with most like boundary talk is that yeah, when people talk about boundaries, they're usually talking about it from the perspective of like, if I could have the right boundaries, I could make this person change their behavior, as opposed to talking about boundaries as only belonging to me and my sort of internal understanding of where I end and where you begin.

    Kate Leggett 18:40

    I totally agree. i That's why I still hate it. I still hate the phrase.

    KC Davis 18:46

    So let me ask you this. Is there any sense in which that phrase is saying something true? And if so, what? So? Okay, well, I think it's in the word teach, because we think of teach as, like a teacher explaining things in simple terms, and, you know, like, to kindergarteners, where you're using your words, and, you know, but I think maybe expanding the kind of definition of that word would make it more true. Like, you teach people by how you behave by how you treat other people, you know, if how, you know, the look on your face, if they say something mean to you, and you get meaner, you know, as opposed to being sad or angry and looking like that. I think that's a feedback loop. You know, that's another way of communicating.

    Kate Leggett 19:42

    So, I think there's truth in that. But again, yeah.

    KC Davis 19:47

    Did you learn about the vulnerability cycle in school?

    Kate Leggett 19:50

    Maybe

    KC Davis 19:51

    The vulnerability cycle is this really interesting? It's basically talking about feedback loops, where it says every person has this like, let's say there's a curtain and in front of the curtain is the behavior that you see. And behind the curtain are the like emotions and beliefs that I have that you don't see. And so let's say that behind my curtain is like I'm afraid to be abandoned. And so that comes out in my behavior as being really, really clean. And then you see that behavior. But behind your curtain, you have sort of these beliefs or these issues or these traumas of, you know, I can never do anything good enough. And so you interpret my cleanness, as, like, I'm never enough for you, you're always wanting more from me. And the behavior that you enact to do that is that you push away, because you don't want any more criticism, you don't want any more smothering. And then of course, I take that to sort of validate my own behind the scenes thing, if I'm being abandoned. So I'm going to cling harder. And the harder I cling, the more you pull, because you and so it's that same concept of like there are these feedback loops, where we could, I think that to me is, is if there's a kernel of truth in that it's about like our own agency or autonomy. And I think it goes hand in hand with what we were saying, which is that stop trying to control another person's behavior. And let's look at the things we actually can control. Because maybe there are some behaviors or beliefs, or ways you're going about interacting with the world that aren't necessarily there maybe or like setting up situations that are helpful to you, or might be just like, not aligned with the goals that you want for yourself. You don't try to say, Yeah, I do. I like that. And I think there's a freedom in learning what's in your control and what's not. And I think maybe what I'm hearing you say is, instead of making assumptions about the reasons behind someone's behavior, just address the behavior and how it makes you feel that's a boundaried way to deal with that, I think, is that kind of what you're saying. And then I'm using a different response. If I go around, because every time I'm afraid, I get really angry, and then people don't want to be around me, and then I'm going really likes me and it's like, I get to look at some stuff and go, Oh, maybe I'm like doing some behaviors that make people not want to be around me. But I think that that's a wholly different, like, process than this idea. And I love what you said, when you said the issue is the word teach, like, it's not your job to teach someone the value of respect. Dignity.

    Like, I'm not their mom. That's right. Right. Okay, well, I could really talk about this with you forever, but I don't want to drag out too long. So I want to say thank you, first of all, for reaching out and even wanting to connect. And it's been it's been a really cool process. And if you're listening, hop off right now go over to restoring relationships and fire up that first half of our conversation about our TikTok. Is it could we call it drama. I don't know that it love it.

    Kate Leggett 23:02

    I love drama. I mean, I love drama. And I think it's totally counts as drama. It's I mean, in the most...it's srespectful drama, yeah, totally.

    KC Davis 23:14

    With an audience of two, like we were the only two people that were looking at drama, but now we're inviting you all to it. And then tune back in next week when I'm going to drop part two of that conversation. So Kate, thank you very much for coming on.

    Kate Leggett 23:26

    Thank you, KC, This is so fun. I love it. Thank you for the you know, for gracing me with your expertise.

    KC Davis 23:36

    Yes, and thank you for your perspective and for just being like being willing to show up and have a conversation absolutely anytime.

Christy Haussler
06: Is Too Much Self-Compassion a Bad Thing? with Dr. Lesley Cook

In our first episode, you heard my conversation with Dr. Lesley Cook about executive functioning. Because she has so much great information and wisdom to share, I decided to bring her back to discuss self-compassion. Is it a bad thing to have TOO MUCH self-compassion? Join us for the conversation with Dr. Lesley!

Dr. Lesley Cook is a psychologist who does a lot of work with ADHD and other neurodivergencies. Born and raised in Hawaii, she now lives in Virginia and works with children, adolescents, adults, couples, and families. 

Show Highlights:

  • How to find the balance between the message of self-compassion and the need for better life management and progress

  • A basic understanding of self-compassion from Dr. Kristin Neff’s writings

  • A closer look at shame and how we experience it in relation to self-compassion

  • How to gently shift shame into self-compassion

  • How self-compassion can become a learned behavior that we pass down to our children

Resources: 

Connect with Dr. Lesley: TikTok and Instagram

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

  • KC Davis 0:06

    Hello, you sentient balls of stardust. Welcome to the Struggle Care podcast. I'm your host, KC Davis. And this is the podcast that doesn't care if you wash your face. I'm here with my good friend, Dr. Leslie Cook, say, Hello, Leslie.

    Lesley PsyD 0:17

    Hey, it's nice to be here. Again,

    KC Davis 0:19

    if you're tuning in with us, you probably heard Dr. Lesley Cook last week because I had her on to talk about executive functioning. And I invited her back and I had this great idea that we were going to talk about weaponized incompetence. And then as we got closer to the recording, I remembered we already did a recording on weaponized incompetence. And so I'm going to call an audible and pepper Leslie with Q&A that we're going to answer together.

    Lesley PsyD 0:45

    About that. It sounds great. I cannot wait.

    KC Davis 0:47

    Excellent. Okay, so I just want to jump right in because I've got some fascinating ones. Here we go. So as you know, much of my, I'm just gonna start with a real spicy one. Is that okay? Yeah, that sounds great. Alright, so as you know, my my content on tick tock is primarily about home care, self care, mental health, and self compassion, right all about sort of recognizing how many things in our life we feel like failures about and then being able to internalize like that struggling with that thing doesn't make me a failure. What often happens when I talk about this, is I get a lot of feedback that says like, Oh, thank you, I feel so much better. Thank you. I'm operating so much better in my home. Thank you. This really helps. But I occasionally will get people that have a similar reaction to this commenter. Okay. And so she actually commented twice. And the first time was when I asked for people who wanted to do q&a, and this is what she said. I think it's great to help people get past feelings of failing for not doing maximum levels of housework. But I hope you also teach that when someone is using the struggle care techniques to survive, they need to also be facing how to get out of crisis, not having more kids or adding to their load, while they forgive themselves for a mess and allowing for doing less, they need to also get real about getting their life to a more manageable place. All right. So here's the second comment, this was on a different video. Your videos have me spiraling this week, because I'm worried some people not you are getting the message to forgive themselves too much, and really not doing enough really failing their kids, I hope you'll keep reinforcing the part about how to do what needs to be done, versus doing too much or nothing. And this comment, first of all, thank you to this commenter for commenting this because I can tell that she's having a legitimate sort of emotional reaction. She's not trying to be any type of way, right? And I just, it's been rattling around in my brain. And I've been having trouble finding the words for what it brings up or what I'm seeing in it. So I'm just curious, your thoughts off the top of your head?

    Lesley PsyD 2:59

    I think in both of those comments, I do I do a lot of parenting work. And I almost feel like I hear a version of some of these early parenting messages that perhaps people receive when they're younger. And when we are under stress, a lot of those early messages tend to just come out all of a sudden. So when I hear that I almost hear, you know, it's okay to take a break on your homework today. But don't forget, you can't get too far behind. So you need to keep going to reach this optimal level. So part of me wonders if that's an old message. And the other part of me wonders, when we work with very young children, especially during their developmental period. We always meet them where they are, right. So if a child is learning to walk, our first statement isn't, you know, it's okay that you're crawling. But we got to we got to get to this walking phase, we have this understanding that crawling, you know, rolling leads to creeping leads to crawling leads to walking. But as adults, I think sometimes we forget that, that it's okay to meet ourselves with compassion, where we are today, even if where we are today is non functional. That doesn't stop our progress. In fact, it's an incredibly important starting point, and it can be freeing to do that.

    KC Davis 4:14

    I hear a lot of fear in this comment. And my initial reaction when I saw this comment was that this person is perhaps either a child who was not cared for in the way that they deserve by their parents. Or is perhaps someone that knows someone who is not giving an adequate or functional amount of care to their children, right? Like I really didn't read this as someone who's like, I really want permission to be judgmental, because sometimes that's what people mean, right? They feel like it's okay to extend compassion or teach people self compassion up to a point. But they have this like line in their head where it's like But if you're doing X, you are you should not be using self compassion on yourself. You should be feeling shame, which I think just goes back to this idea that ultimately, as much as we say that shame is not a good motivator long term that that shame isn't the best change agent that we have. And in fact, it most often backfires, and stalls out change. That I think underlying belief is really hard to root out. And I feel like this is where it comes to the surface is like, okay, it's okay for us to be self compassionate about not getting our dishes done. But what about that mom who just left their kid in a dirty diaper for 12 hours, and now they have, you know, open sores on their bottom? Like, they're not allowed to be self compassionate, right? And so we get into this place of well, what do we mean by self compassion? What do we think self compassion does? And that's kind of where my brain goes with it.

    Lesley PsyD 5:59

    Yeah, I think I think what I'm hearing in what you're saying too, is there's some belief that's tied up with fear, if I have compassion for myself, I'm afraid that I could become that person, if I let myself versus I think one of the messages from from your content across all platforms is giving yourself Self Compassion, radically, unequivocally where you are, is less likely to lead you there that it's more likely to free you to imagine where you could be next.

    KC Davis 6:32

    So let's just take a minute and actually talk about like a definition of self compassion, because probably there's people listening that are going well, I don't even know what that is. Okay. So I'm gonna read you a definition of self compassion. This is from Dr. Kristin Neff. She's sort of the pioneer of self compassion research. Let me see Here she talks about the three elements of self compassion. So number one is self kindness, versus self judgment. It says self compassion entails being warm and understanding towards ourselves when we suffer, fail feel inadequate, rather than ignoring our pain or flagellating ourselves with self criticism. Self compassionate people recognize that being imperfect, failing and experiencing life difficulties is inevitable, so they tend to be gentle with themselves when confronted with painful experiences. Rather than getting angry when life falls short of set ideals. People cannot always be or get exactly what they want. When this reality is denied our fought against suffering increases in the form of stress, frustration and self criticism. When this reality is accepted with sympathy and self kindness, greater emotional equanimity is experienced. Number two, common humanity versus isolation. So first stration at not having things exactly what we want is often accompanied by an irrational but pervasive sense of isolation. As if I were the only person suffering or making mistakes all humans suffer. The very definition of Being human means that one is mortal, vulnerable and imperfect. Therefore, self compassion involves recognizing that suffering and personal inadequacy is part of the shared human experience. It doesn't just happen to me alone. And then number three, mindfulness versus over identification. Self Compassion also requires taking a balanced approach to our negative emotions, so that feelings are neither suppressed nor exaggerated. This equilibrium stance stems from process of relating personal experiences to those who are also suffering and thus putting ourselves in a larger perspective. It also stems from the willingness to observe our negative thoughts and emotions with openness and clarity, so that they are held in mindful awareness. Mindfulness is a non judgmental, receptive mind state in which one observes thoughts and feelings as they are without trying to suppress or deny them, we cannot ignore our pain and feel compassion for it at the same time. At the same time, mindfulness requires that we not be over identified. So self compassion, I think part of what I'm sort of hearing in this is that I think some people misconstrue that self compassion means permission for the behavior you're experiencing.

    Lesley PsyD 9:07

    Mm hmm. And when you think about permission, that's an attachment to something, not this kind of observational lens that we're talking about. So if it's, there's cups all over my house that have old coffee in them, and I'm allowed to do that, and I give myself permission, and I don't care what impact that has on me or anybody else. That's a that's an anxious attachment to that as a way to not have to feel as a way to get away from my feelings, or standing back. And being an observer that is not attached to that. I can come from a place of compassion, which is like, wow, this is really a challenge for me. Here's the story of how this impacts me and other people. And there's no attachment there's no end to that story. I'm free. So I love that. That detached observer

    KC Davis 9:56

    Well, and I'm just curious, like the actual definition of compassion. Let's look it up. Okay. Yeah. Let's see, let's see. All right, sympathetic pity. I don't love the word pity. But let's go with it. And concern for the sufferings or misfortunes of others, who I love that sympathetic concern for the sufferings of others. So what, what we're talking about when we say self compassion is a sympathetic, and I would say, sympathetic by nature is gentle, right? A gentle concern for the suffering of ourselves. Right. And I also just think about compassion in general, like this idea that compassion has to be permission or that it will give permission if we're too compassionate. But like, I have felt compassion for people and permission at the same time, right? Like I've looked at moms who are struggling, or young men who are struggling, really anyone and been like, they're giving themselves too hard of a time, they actually should be giving themselves permission to rest, right. But I think sometimes we don't recognize that we're doing two things at once I'm having compassion for their struggle. And I'm feeling sort of permissive or wanting to give them the the, quote, unquote, permission to rest or do whatever or let go of the dishes in the sink. Right. But I don't know about you, but like I can, I have had compassion for people that I was not giving permission to. I've listened to actually just heard one recently. And I don't know how accurate the facts of the story is. But I'm just reacting to as if the facts of the story were what I heard. It was this woman who was talking in a court case, and I'm going to do it just trigger warning, because I'm going to talk about some child abuse, but I'm not going to be graphic. She was describing to the judge in graphic details, how she had abused one of her children, and horrible ways. And she's crying as she says it. And at first, you're just like, horrified. And then you learn that what's happening is that this child was doing the same things or abusing her younger baby, like in really horrific, sadistic ways. And this mom is sort of like, crumbling in the courtroom saying, like, I was trying to say, you know, you don't like it when someone does this to you, and then doing it to him. This child eventually died from the abuse. Now, no part of that do I feel is acceptable, permissive. Okay. And yet, I found myself listening to this mom, who was clearly in pain, who was like thinking about her infant being harmed and tortured continuously, and was kind of at her wit's end and was clearly not equipped, mentally, not support it, like, I felt compassion.

    Lesley PsyD 12:52

    I think that that's an area that we really struggle with, at least in our culture at this time, is the duality of many things that you can be this and that at the same time. And in fact, that's important to be able to separate our compassion, and whether we are signing on to something or saying, oh, yeah, we throw our hands up, that's fine. I do find it a lot of folks are really struggle with that with others, but especially with themselves.

    KC Davis 13:19

    Well, and I mean, I also felt compassion for that child that had passed away. Right? Like that should not have happened to him. He deserved better, right? And you have compassion for this tiny little infant, right? Who has no one to protect them except the person that's protecting him in a way that's like not functional at all? Yeah. So those are kind of the things that it brings to mind. And specifically, going back, like, let's talk about, I saw a video recently of a person who kind of was saying, Gosh, I'm my neighbor's kids, like, keep hanging out outside on the stairwell. They're like two and three, and nobody's watching them. And she goes out with our video camera and sees and one of the little boys has a diaper that's kind of almost falling off covered with equal matter. And you're just thinking What mother could do this. And I think that's where people's minds go when they go. We can't give that mother permission to be self compassionate.

    Lesley PsyD 14:15

    Yeah, but I think that one of the points you made earlier, so important that that focusing on permission separates us from other people. It does protect us a little bit from having to contemplate that, well, I could never be I could never do that. I don't give permission. I don't I don't make excuses, because that's a whole other thing that I'll never do. Compassion requires that we see our connection. Compassion requires that we see ourselves in that person and imagine what would have had to have happened to take place in order to end there. And I think that that's hard. If you didn't learn that as a child, or an adolescent, it's hard to be asked to find yourself in someone who is struggling at that level.

    KC Davis 14:55

    Well, and the idea that compassion and accountability can't Be together. And here's what it also brings to me. There are people out there that for whatever reason, whether it is psychological or moral, there's a and it's probably a small percentage, but like they're just, they're doing outright evil things. And they do not care whether they do not care because they have some sort of psychological, whatever going on that prevents them from tapping into that empathy, or they just don't that exists. And I think what a lot of people worry is that what if, you know, my mother who mistreated me horribly, what if she was listening to Casey Davis and Casey Davis was saying, Oh, let yourself off the hook. Not all moms are perfect, you know, you're doing your best like, then that would have given my mom permission to like, feel right. But in my experience, people who are doing like evil, abusive things to people don't need permission to do them. Not only do they not need permission to do them, like they're going to do them either way. But, you know, they also weren't stopped by shame. They aren't permitted by permission, and they're not stopped by shame. So at some, at some level, like, I don't actually worry that much about some sociopathic person, you know, getting permission, quote, unquote, because like, they're gonna get that permission from themselves from somewhere else, it doesn't matter. I worry more about the person, like the woman that was my client a while back, who relapse on heroin while she was pregnant. And she sat in that group therapy every day, and she could not stop beating herself up, she could not stop being consumed with a feeling of failure and worthlessness. She recognized I have done this horribly harmful thing to my child, she recognized Yes, I have a brain disorder of addiction. And she felt 100% accountable. And I can tell you that sitting in that group over and over and over the majority of the way in which she was not able to show up for her child, the way her child needed at that time, was not related to the fact that she used heroin, when she was pregnant. It was related to the fact that she now hated herself to such a degree. She had basically frozen herself psychologically, with how worthless she felt. And we all know what kind of life choices we make when we feel like we're worthless, right? We get with the wrong people, we self sabotage ourselves at work, you know, we don't put in effort to maybe making progress in therapy, because at some point, that motive of I want to get better. But when you're saddled with I don't deserve to be better, right? And so that, of course, is compromising her sobriety. And putting at risk not only not showing up for her kid the way she needs to, but dying, if she relapses again. And I'll never forget her because we're so afraid that if we were to give this mom permission, to have self compassion on herself, to gently look upon her suffering with concern, and kindness, that would lead to her sort of quote, unquote, letting herself off the hook, not taking accountability, not learning how to change her behaviors. But in my experience, we've really got it flipped flopped. It is that radical self compassion that allows that mom to stand up and start to recognize what her values are, how her behavior in the past hasn't matched to those values, and not be too ashamed to ask for help changing herself so that she can live up to those values in the future.

    Lesley PsyD 19:03

    Yeah, thank you. No shame is a closed door. It's a period at the end of a sentence. There's nothing that comes after shame. Shame is the reason right? Because I'm bad, because I can't help it because I'm broken. But self compassion leads us to questions like How did it get here? And what would have to happen for this to be different? It's an open door. It's it's multiple open doors, in fact, and if we can learn to view ourselves in that way and each other, I think we start asking the questions that actually do get us moving and are motivating. It's interesting, shame really does feel motivating, even though it isn't. That's an interesting phenomenon. It always has been for me, and so it can be hard to break away from that pattern.

    KC Davis 19:47

    You know, have this weird theory about shame if I ever told you this. So most of the therapists that I practice with talk about how there's really only seven primary emotions Have you think of like a color wheel, there's like, untold, you know, different hues. But they all kind of come back to one of seven emotions. So there's fear, anger, pain, loneliness, joy, guilt and shame. Now, I actually would replace shame with disgust. Right, like disgust because we feel that ver lots of things. And Disgust is this really interesting beast? Because it's both an emotion and, like a sense. Like, you know, like, touch, smell disgust. And so when we think about, like, what the role of disgust is, when I think about things that disgust me, you think of like, poop, and vomit, and pus and open sores? And like, what's interesting about that? And is that almost exclusively, like, almost a unanimous what I whatever word I'm looking for, it's like all human beings of all cultures experience disgust at these things, almost like it's biological, right? Yeah. And it's smart. Because when I feel disgust, I want to get away from something. And it's really smart for human beings to have this sense of disgust towards things that could get them sick. And I think that some of that overlaps socially, right? Like, what we feel disgust at socially, is typically what society is rejecting or pushing out. And so we don't want to associate with that we don't want to mate with that we don't want to get sort of lumped into the same category. And this is why like, I think when you look at a lot of the phobias, like homophobia, fat phobia, there's a real element of disgust in it. And we want to get out, we want to put that thing as far away from we want to separate ourselves from it, because that's the thing that is going to be pushed out. And we don't want to do that. And I really believe that shame is just disgust at oneself.

    Lesley PsyD 21:59

    But you can't get away from the thing you're disgusted by,

    KC Davis 22:03

    Exactly, you cannot get away from yourself. You believe yourself to be something that is, should be put out should be rejected. And yet, the other part of you is fighting for what is on a very basic level life and death, which is inclusion in your pack. And, and so it feels like it feels motivating. Oh, God, I gotta get, I gotta stop this, I gotta get away from this, I gotta fix this, or I'm gonna, it's not motivating. It's just panic, panic feels like motivation. Yeah. But I haven't really seen, I mean, you can get a little movement, right? Like, when I scream at my kids, and I feel shame afterwards, there's that this isn't my values. Like, that's like the gift of shame is it tells me when I'm not behaving in line with my values. But that's it. Like, it's just information, shame can give you information. And if we take that information, and then practice self compassion, we can then do something with that information to actually change. But it can only give you information, it can't give you momentum, it can't create change. And so what we do with that information matters, right? Like we depending on what we believe about ourselves, we can either bury the information, oh, my God, I don't act within my values, I must be a piece of shit, I just screamed at my kid, I can't let anyone know that I do this, I'm gonna go drink to not feel about it, right. And then it gets worse and worse. Or we can go, wow, that's not the kind of parent I want to be. And I'm probably experiencing a universal experience right now. And I'm going to reach out for help. And I'm going to get support. And I'm going to figure out what's going wrong so that I can be different.

    Lesley PsyD 23:49

    And that's the small shifts, I think that compassion allows us to have. And maybe that's another piece of this is I think it may be difficult for folks to imagine going from a place of shame based behavior, to a place of self compassion. I mean, those seem like poles. But in actuality, self compassion just enables you to make 1000 Tiny shifts, and they don't always have to be in one direction. So I still experience I do this for a living. I talk to amazing people like you, I still experience shame. I'm looking at a side of a room right now that does not bring me joy. But when you practice of compassion enough, that shift becomes very quick and what you what happens starts to happen is I noticed the shame. And I gently shift towards self compassion. It becomes just a learned behavior that you can then pass down to children.

    KC Davis 24:39

    I love it. Thank you so much. This was so wonderful. Thank you for having me. Of course.

Christy Haussler
05: Gentle Organizing with Alison Lush

Do you have too much stuff? As you look around your home, is it crowded and cluttered? Does your space make you feel burdened, unhappy, and frustrated? If you said–or shouted–YES, you can’t miss today’s show. Join me to learn more about gentle organizing. 

Alison Lush is a Certified Professional Organizer, Certified Virtual Organizer, and Master Trainer. After a 20-year catering career, Alison knew she needed better organization and management skills for her home and personal comfort. She learned to live and shop intentionally, creating and protecting the space in her home. Now she puts her expertise to work in helping others by empowering them and teaching them to put themselves at the center of their organization efforts. 

Show Highlights:

  • How Alison became an organizer with a gentle spirit

  • Why our interactions with our home, space, time, and belongings form the foundations of our lives

  • Why Alison’s focus is on “organic organizing”

  • Alison’s answer to a question sent in by Samantha about dealing with clutter, letting things go, and the functionality of her space

  • How to organize your space by using Zone 1, Zone 2, and Zone 3—and consider the frequency of access for each item

  • Ways to keep, honor, and display memorabilia by identifying the risk level in letting items go

  • How to consider the purpose of items in our lives in deciding to keep them or let them go

  • Alison’s answer to a question from Kitty about decorating, a sense of style, and learning to feel good about her space

  • How to reframe what might look crappy and rundown to you as a life well-lived, meaningful, and full of love

  • Why your decor should fuel you and recharge your batteries

  • Alison’s answer to a question from Aria about separating and managing work life and home life

  • How to legitimize, categorize, and systemize your space for the best functionality

  • Why the professional organizing industry has the reputation of telling people to “just get rid of your stuff”

Resources:

Connect with Alison: www.alisonlush.ca and TikTok   

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

  • KC Davis 0:04

    Hello, and welcome to struggle care the podcast. I am so excited about who I have on today. Her name is Allison Allison lash is a certified organizer. I got that. Right, right.

    Alison Lush 0:17

    There's other titles, but that's absolutely fine.

    KC Davis 0:20

    What are the other titles?

    Alison Lush 0:21

    Well, I'm a Certified Professional Organizer. I'm a certified virtual organizer. Plus, I'm a master trainer.

    KC Davis 0:27

    That's impressive. Well, I can't tell you how excited I am to have you on today. Because when I started my tic toc channel and I started talking about you know, cleaning, being morally neutral and having your home serve you and not the other way around. I remember stumbling on your content, and being like, Oh, shit, she gets it like, this is someone who I could totally see, I would invite her in to organize my home, and you just had such a kind and gentle presence. And I feel like that is not something that I see a lot in organizers like usually you think of, you know, Personal Organizer, or professional organizer, as someone who is like, let's get it. Let's go. You know, we're going to organize these books into rainbow color. And you but you just had such a different presence. And I wondered if you could talk just a minute about, you know, how did you get that way?

    Alison Lush 1:21

    Well, I have to start by saying, I'm going to take a little pause here and say, I'm absolutely thrilled to be here. I am a massive big fan of yours. And I send everybody to your page, I say if you're following me, you have to be following Casey. She is the bomb. There's it's amazing of the voice that you've created in the platform you've created. And I'm so grateful for your presence on social media, because people obviously need to hear what you are saying. And you add weight and volume to what I'm saying. So I want to say thank you and congratulations, just need to get it's really important to honor what you've done. It's tremendous amount of work. So oh, well, it's all very true. I'm so thrilled that we found each other how did I get to where I am the short story because people can read a little bit about my background on my website, I don't let's not waste time getting into that I fell into the world of professional organizing. And I landed quite quickly in 2010 in a school, a professional school for professional organizers called the Institute for challenging disorganization. And I just felt comfortable there that's like those people, they just resonated with me in the way that they were talking. It's like I wanted to buddy up with them. And I wanted to invite them into my home, the vibe was just like all about where I felt comfortable. And the way I describe it today, my industry is that there's a spectrum. And on one end of the spectrum are people like me, and on the other end of the spectrum are people who are mad crazy about organizing the stuff. And there is nothing wrong with that. Because there are clients who want that there are clients, that's all they want come and make my house pretty. And that's what I want. And because that's a it's an open market, and there's people who need that the fact that organizers specialize in that, more power to them. But there's this other end of the spectrum where what I'm focusing on is people, I'm not really very concerned about the books and about the boxes, and about the cups and all that stuff. What I'm concerned about is the person and how they feel in their home. Does the person feel okay in their home, do they feel comfortable in their home? Do they feel functional in their home, because if we don't feel good in our home, that launches us for the whole rest of our life. And it impacts on how we can accomplish whatever it is we want to accomplish in our lives. Whether we're full time, parents are working full time, or volunteering, or we're retired and just wanting to have you know, spend time doing record doesn't matter what we're trying to do in our life, our home, and the way we interact with our home and our belongings and our stuff in our space and our time, the way we manage that is our foundation for the rest of our life. So the better we manage those things, the better able we are to accomplish our goals in life, which is what is the target?

    KC Davis 4:02

    I feel like that's where you and I really resonated with each other was that we're both focusing on a person's relationship to their space, right, not just their performance in their space, or the aesthetics of their space, but that the real work and the real reward is the relationship to their space.

    Alison Lush 4:22

    And the measure that I use to identify where are the issues is literally how do you feel like I see the way your desk is you showed me a picture of your desk. I don't have any judgment about that. I don't care if it's piled up to the ceiling. My question is, how do you feel about your desk? If you feel fine about your desk and it's working for you? Let's talk about something else. If you're unhappy about your desk, and it's causing you problems, do you want to talk about it? Do you want to talk about it? Because even if it's a problem for the person, that doesn't necessarily mean that they're ready or willing or able to deal with it?

    KC Davis 4:55

    Yes. And if you push that they're more likely to kind of go to this protective As where they're not going to be honest, are not going to be open, they're not going to call you back for the second session. And, you know, what you're describing about, you know, does it bother you is similar to when I talk about, you know, does it work, that's all it does it function. And that changes over a lifetime to because I'm someone who has almost always function just fine with clothes strewn about the floor, and dishes being done every three days. And you know, nothing really having a a formal organization. But I always kind of knew where everything was, that worked. For me for most of my life, it really wasn't until I had my second kid, that all of a sudden, those sort of pseudo systems began to sort of grown under the weight of the extra family labor. And that's when you know, my platform launched was me going, Oh, my God, I have to go back to the drawing board. Like I have to figure out some new ways existing in this space, because things that were working are now not working.

    Alison Lush 5:55

    Mm hmm. The way that that shows up in my work is what I say to people is organizing should be organic. Our lives are changing all the time, the things that we own are changing all the time, our interests, and habits and lifestyle and daily routines are changing all the time. And so if we focus on the stuff in the space, we're only dealing with today's problem, what about next year, what about two years from now, so what I try to focus on is the human being and their understanding of themselves, because they carry themselves in where whatever situation they're in whatever time they're in, whatever needs they're in, they carry themselves. So if they can focus on their own understanding and their skills, they carry that wherever they're going, it empowers them to be able to face whatever challenges they have in the future. I don't want people hiring me now to organize their cupboard. And then for them to have to organize hire me again next year, when they change what's in the cupboard. I want them to be able to organize their cupboard next year.

    KC Davis 6:49

    Yes, that's awesome. Okay, I feel like we could talk forever. But I really want to get into some of these questions. Because I've had people writing in, and I picked out a few that I felt like it'd be really good for us to talk about, and here we go. So this is from Samantha, and she says, I grew up moving around. And I have a lot of emotional issues and shame around resisting getting rid of stuff and decluttering. But I also have ADHD. And I feel overwhelmed by the clutter and an effects by functionality, any tips, both in terms of practicality, so ways to make it easier to let go of things I need to let go of. And in terms of philosophy, your message is morally neutral mantra has already been such a difference. So I love this question. I feel like this is right up your alley. And I would love to hear your thoughts.

    Alison Lush 7:33

    It touches on a couple of really big issues. What is the meaning of our stuff? How does our physical stuff from our past add value to our life today? So there's our memorabilia type stuff? And then there's the stuff we're actually using today? And how do they actually live in our physical space. I encourage people to develop a personalized environment so that they have what they need. So if they need it in front of their face, it's in front of their face, if they need peace and quiet in front of their face. That's what they have. So it I encourage everybody to look inside pay attention to how you respond to your space. Does it help you and make you feel calmer? When you can see all your stuff? Or does it make you feel calmer when you can't see all your stuff, for example, that's the first thing are you hypo visually sensitive or hyper visually sensitive. And the same thing with space and with touch, if we can pay attention to how we react physically, personally to everything around us, we gather information that helps us therefore create personalized solutions. So that's one element. Second of all, the ADHD thing is a whole package unto itself. And there are so many specialists who talk specifically about ADHD, I talk about it a little bit on my platform, but not because there's so many people out there who that's all they talk about, I tend to defer to them. It is a personal path. And it's real. And it affects the way that a person interacts with their space and their time and their focus and their attention. And learning about yourself is the number one powerhouse thing that you can do. And it will change over time. So this year, whatever you learn about yourself and your ADHD, it could be different six months from now or two years from now be ready for paying attention to change.

    KC Davis 9:14

    So she says she grew up moving around. And that gave her a lot of emotional issues about getting rid of things.

    Alison Lush 9:20

    Right. So that's an issue that is like a really big topic of conversation on my page, because I hear in my see people and the issue of shame and expectations and judgment. And I think that our society in general does us a tremendous disservice by setting up this notion that life is supposed to be like anything specific. It's supposed to be like this for all of us. I reject that. And I encourage everybody to reject that. I don't think it helps us. I think what helps us is to figure out what works for us. So when people come to me and they say I have all of this stuff, and I don't know if I should be keeping it or not. I asked them digging it We delve down, we dig down and ask questions about what value is it adding to your life? Is it actually adding value to your life? That's really super important. The second question is, what is it costing you? Does it cost you anxiety and stress every single month that you've got those 12 boxes of memorabilia sitting there? Or are they just sitting there and they're not bothering you at all? So the more we can get clear about the costs of holding the stuff and the benefits of owning the stuff, the more it helps massage us towards finding our own personal answer of just to what extent it's problematic to be owning that stuff. Because we, I do not believe that we should be allowing other people to be pressuring us to get rid of our stuff. That's not an answer, that's helpful. It's just not,

    KC Davis 10:45

    I kind of love where you're going with this, because that's where I always start with people too. Because we do have these sort of external ideas. You know, like, minimalism is really big right now. And people talking about, you know, you just you have to have a peaceful space, but they're sort of saying that the only way to have a peaceful space is to have a minimalist space. And so I do think there are people out there thinking, Oh, I've got to declutter, I've got to declutter. But you know, if you jump right to teaching them how to declutter, you can sometimes miss what you're talking about, which is, is this even a problem? Exactly. Some people love to have their stuff around them, some people have a peaceful place. So I want to give kudos to Samantha because she was able to say that she feels overwhelmed. And it affects her functionality. So she's kind of got that piece. But But you're so right. And that's why I really want to encourage people to always start with the functionality like is it working? Is it even a problem that you don't ever called your laundry? Is it even a problem that you do your dishes every three days? Is it really affecting you? Or are you going off of some external messaging about how your house should run

    Alison Lush 11:52

    100% could not agree more.

    KC Davis 11:54

    So if Samantha says to you, you ask her these questions, she says, Yes, it is actually a problem, it actually affects my functioning. And I would like to get rid of some of these things. But I don't even know where to start.

    Alison Lush 12:05

    It depends on what kinds of things we're talking about. One of the cores, elements of the work that I do with clients is I talk about Zone One, two, and three. And I find that this is a concept that is almost universally helpful for people to think about, I talked about in terms of the human being as being zone one, anything I can reach with my arms from wherever I am. So right now I'm sitting at my desk, anything I can reach with my arms without getting out of my chair, that zone one space. And for my functioning, I should be prioritizing only things in my zone, one space that are contributing to whatever it is I'm trying to accomplish in this space. What However, I did define that for myself, it's up to me, so only things that are contributing to what I'm trying to achieve here. Same thing at the kitchen counter, when you're standing at the kitchen counter, what are you trying to accomplish? Most people at the kitchen counter most people and I don't even make any assumptions about that. Most people at the kitchen counter are trying to either make food or clean up most of the time. So if that's the case, the only things that should be right there in that space is only one space prime real estate should be the things that are contributing to making the meals or cleaning up, if that's what you've just defined your use of that space. Right? Some people might do their podcast on their kitchen counter, and therefore it's a completely different conversation. Every person has to decide for themselves. So that's zone one. You start with one, right? Always because you start with the human being the human being is the center of the story. That's the thing that's kind of like the core of my philosophy. Because we typically start in our society with starting with the stuff, where does the stuff need to be? I flip that on its head? What does the human need?

    KC Davis 13:42

    Because I feel like a lot of people would start with the attic, or the garage, right? The place where things are piling up, or oh, I have this extra bedroom, and they would just throw everything in there. I feel like that's where a lot of people think they're supposed to start because that's what they would say is the quote unquote, problem area. But you're saying no, it's how are you functioning in your home? And so if I'm sitting at my desk, what do I do at my desk? If I'm at my kitchen counter? What am I doing here? If I'm in my playroom, what are we doing there? I love that,

    Alison Lush 14:10

    Okay, what zone to that's zone one. And in order to help us keep zone one, purified and functioning and minimalists so that we have just the things that we need, whatever that means, and it could even mean memorabilia. I'm not saying you shouldn't keep pictures of your family on your desk. If that contributes to you feeling good. As you're sitting at your desk trying to get whatever it is you're trying to get done, then that's perfectly valuable. Every person decides for themselves what they need. That's like rule number one every person decides for themselves. So zone two is the space that like I have to get up from my chair and walk across the room to get to that zone two storage. It's totally easy to get to but I wouldn't want to have to stand up 25 times a day and go to my zone to to get something that I need 25 times a day. So it's frequency of access decides what should be in Zone One and what should be in zone two zone To it's hugely valuable storage space, but it's across the room, I have to get up from my chair. So this is why

    KC Davis 15:04

    I intuitively keep my vacuum cleaner out in my kitchen, because I have small children, and you reach for it 50 times a day, 50 times a day, right? I had it in the closet, I was trying to make it a zone two. And you know what, for most of my life, it was a zone two object. But then my life season changed. And now it's a zone one object, and that's why it's in the kitchen, okay?

    Alison Lush 15:28

    100% your instincts are right on the market, on the ball. And the third zone is longer term storage. And I the perfect example of what we I put I use it as a visual example to help people understand what zone three storage is, it's a pain in the butt to get to, it's like you have to go all the way down three flights of stairs to the basement, maybe you have to use a key to get into a storage locker, maybe it's in your parents basement, maybe it's up in the attic, and you have to climb a ladder, it's a pain in the butt to get to, you only want to go there a few times a year. So what do we keep in zone three storage, we keep things like Christmas decorations. We keep things like our seven years of taxes, we keep things like childhood memorabilia, we keep things that we don't need to access on a frequent basis. Again, it's all based on frequency of access, how often am I gonna reach for this thing? And therefore does it deserve to be in Zone One? Should it be in zone two? Or should it be? Could it be relegated to zone three?

    KC Davis 16:19

    Okay, so is in terms of decluttering? Can you almost reverse engineer this and say, Okay, here's this, you know, earplugs sitting on my desk. This is not something I ever need at my desk. And so then go well, is it something How frequently do I need this? What do I need it once a year? Do I even need it? They're like, is that a way that you can sort of begin to sort of ripple effect clear out and declutter some spaces?

    Alison Lush 16:46

    Yeah, absolutely. I visualized it in my own head. I don't know why. But I've always used the term massaging, I'm massaging my belongings, I'm pulling closer to me, things that are more important and meaningful, like your vacuum, your pulled it closer to you, because you need it more often. And pushing away things that are less instantly necessary in order to make room for because one of the things I have 20 years background in the catering industry, I was a myth for the hotel. And I manage the floor of dining rooms and catering events. And one of the key things that I learned from that is humans need space to move and to do stuff. And we frequently forget to leave space for the humans. And so we have to factor that in. It's valuable to push things away so that there's more room for the humans to function.

    KC Davis 17:30

    And will you is that the zones? One, two and three? Yep.

    Alison Lush 17:33

    And then when you get to the end of zone three, it's like, do I even need to own this?

    KC Davis 17:38

    So when people talk about this, so let's say they get the end of zone three, and they're going to even need to own this. And if they're still having trouble letting go. There's a couple of things that I've seen you talk about that I thought were genius on your channel where you talked about memorabilia, and ways that you can keep honor and or display parts of memorabilia or your memorabilia without it, you know, maybe just living in its entirety in a Rubbermaid bin or whatever. Can you talk a minute about that?

    Alison Lush 18:08

    Yeah, there's two things I'd like to say on the memorabilia because it is such a huge issue. One is the example that you're giving is my daughter's Playmobil collection. It was a massively important part of her childhood. If we all had to choose one thing that was like significant of her childhood, it would have been the Playmobil. So I took a selection of it and put it in a shadow box. And it's literally hanging on our bathroom wall. And it's so cheerful and beautiful. And it honors her childhood and you know, our parenting and it honors a whole bunch of things on many different levels. And it means we don't have to keep that great big tote of claim a bill. That's one thing. So keeping a sampling. Some people call it a sampling. Some people call it I forget something else. There's other terms. I learned that from Judith Kohlberg, who's an amazing person. She has a book called chronic disorganization. And it's available to the public. She has two versions, one for professional organizers and one for the public. Anybody who is interested in chronic disorganization can easily find her little book available on the internet and they might be interested in buying it. The second thing I want to say about memorabilia that I think is hugely important is a measure that me personally I use to help me decide sometimes, is it okay for me to actually let this thing go or not? When I'm when we're sitting on the fence and we're feeling ambivalent, oh, I've got this thing. I wonder if I should be letting it go or not. I want to let it go. But I'm afraid to let it go. That we so often find ourselves in that position, and it's very uncomfortable. So I came up with this visual that I think is really helpful. And people seem to get if it was a white t shirt that I was debating about, should I keep this white t shirt or let it go, Oh my gosh, I don't know what to do. If I let it go. And tomorrow morning, I wake up and I go, Oh my god, I should have kept that white t shirt. I could really use a white t shirt. How difficult is it for me to go out and replace it? It's super simple. I could even go to a thrift store and for four bucks, I could get a white t shirt like they're everywhere white t shirts, right? And if we're just talking about a white t shirt, it's just a thing. I can easily replace the thing. It sort of echoes the minimalists advice that if you can replace it for 20 bucks, or within 20 minutes, then let it go. I like having guidelines like that so that we don't hang on to just everything. The other example I give like to complete the imagery is okay, what if I'm sitting on the fence and we're talking about my grandmother's pearls? She gave me her pearls when I got married. It's a necklace and a pair of earrings. I've worn them a few times, they're sitting in my jewelry box. But the reality is, they don't resonate with me, I don't feel comfortable wearing them. It's not my style. It's strictly a piece of memorabilia that was meaningful to my grandmother and meaningful for our relationship, I will probably never wear them again. So if I'm looking at that set of pearls, and I'm sitting on the fence, and I asked myself the question, if I let these go, when I wake up tomorrow morning, and I regret the decision, how easy or difficult is it going to be to replace them? The reality is, it's impossible to replace them because they came from my grandmother, they're one of a kind. So what that identifies using the example of the white t shirt and my grandma's pearls that identifies the level of risk. So the level of risk, if I make a mistake is not the same for every item, this is a mistake that we make, we simply often look at everything, and only think of the money value, or it's memorabilia, therefore I have to keep it we put so much value on belongings, it makes it so that they're like a ball and chain, and we can't let them go. So anything that we can do to identify ways that we can loosen our grip and let go of things that are less important. It means that we can hang on to things that are more important with a higher value and a higher risk value if we let them go, because we can't keep everything.

    KC Davis 21:37

    I like that. What also reminds me of is that I think sometimes when people are getting rid of things, maybe they don't want them, they don't need them. It doesn't function in their life. But it's not that having it is bringing value to your their life. It's that they feel as though the act of getting rid of it is somehow betraying it, or disrespecting it or you know, it's just so hard to get rid of something. And I think that's a part to look at too. Because in your example, like let's say you decide, okay, you know, you don't want the pearl earrings, I think talking about then where are they going to go is different? Because of the choices? Do I keep the pearl earrings for my grandmother? Or do I throw them in the trash? Like, obviously, I'm not gonna throw those in the trash. But if it's do I keep them? Or do I take them to a secondhand shop? Or do I donate them to a dress for success for lower income women that can't afford Moni then I feel like well, that's really honoring to my grandmother, actually. And I'm going to take sort of one of the Marie Kondo tips where she talks about, you know, has this item given its gift to me, and that gift can't be taken away, even if I pass on. And maybe it's honored if I pass it on. And in that vein, I sort of wanted to share a story that I found when I was younger. So I think everyone has had an experience with their first love. Right? Maybe you were 1516 20. And I had this box of memorabilia from my first love, right? This is the you know, just life changing, you know, you'll never forget that person, and pictures and love letters and these things. And when I got engaged, I said, you know, I think as we move into this new space, I don't want to bring this box, right? Like it was a sweet relationship. And it gave me so much. But I don't need to keep hanging on to, for lots of reasons we could go into what the emotional significance of these things are for me when I move into this new space with my husband and my you know, like that. And but the stopping point, Allison was that I couldn't bring myself to throw it in the trash. And it's not like somebody I can't read gift pictures of me and my 16 year old boyfriend. And you know, what I ended up doing was I had a good friend at the time, who was sort of mentoring me. And I said, you know, I'd really like to sit down with you and show you my box. And I want to show you every picture and I want to read you every letter. And I want to tell you about this relationship that I had that shaped the course of my life and how sweet it was and how bittersweet it was, and the things that still mean something to me today. And I want you to know, I want to tell you the story. And when I'm done telling you the story, I want to give you the box, and I don't ever want to hear about what you do with the box. And I mean, I know logically, she threw the box in the trash. She's not keeping this box, but I was removed from the significance of putting in the trash. That's not what I did with it. I told the story, honor the story. And I handed the box gingerly over to her and she said out loud to me. I will take care of this for you. And I will honor it. And obviously it didn't need to go somewhere and I don't even like to say out loud that I don't want the trash but it was such a cool way of honoring this thing that was this memorabilia, but it didn't serve my life anymore, but I didn't want it to go in the trash and so uh love to share that story because it was one of my better strokes of genius about how to kind of get rid of something that had that weight to it.

    Alison Lush 25:06

    It's so powerful that story. It's a very, very beautiful, elegant and just infused with honor, what you did for yourself for the relationship for that other person for that collection. on every level, it was just filled with honor. And you found your solution, which is beautiful and phenomenal that you liberated yourself from the weight of that ownership of that thing. It takes a lot of courage to do that a lot of the people that I'm dealing with, that I'm working with that I'm conversing with, haven't yet gone to the place where they could have that confidence or that courage to do that. So what we're doing is always just exploring anything that they could possibly do to liberate themselves, could they reduce the collection, I often encourage people to explore the meaning of the thing. So the meaning of the relationship, the meaning of the pictures, what might you do in the future, I still have my tiny collection, I've reduced it down to a very minimal but that collection that you were just talking about, I've still got mine. And I've still got it tucked away, because I haven't been able to let it go yet, but it's very small. One thing I did get let go of was my collection of journals, I had a whole years and years of books that I had filled with writing years and years from about age, I don't know 16 to 25, or something like that. And when I started going on my real journey of decluttering. For myself, it's a whole process. I've been on this journey for 11 years now. And in about year five, I actually hired a professional organizer to help me get past some of the things that I was struggling with. And just by having her working with me off on my own, I went off on this tangent, I said, I want to deal with my journals, and I did it and I shredded them, all of them. I ripped them out of their books, I shredded all the paper through the covers of the books into the garbage. And I feel fantastic. Because what I realized is the purpose of those books, and this gets back to the meaning of the belonging, what was the purpose of those books, the purpose of those books was to help me in that moment to work through issues, and to learn and to move beyond whatever issues I was struggling with. They were like work papers, working through issues. And now it's like five years, 10 years, 2030 years later, I don't need to go back and see the work that I did on those issues. I've moved way beyond those issues, you are the work that you did exactly. So the books served their purpose. That's one of the things that I do love about Marie Kondo philosophy is thank the thing for what you got from it, and then move on and let it go. And that that was one of the examples of how I applied that philosophy. Absolutely.

    KC Davis 27:32

    Well, so when Samantha talks about a group moving around, I think it's really significant that that's how she starts it, because she's telling us that the emotional issues around getting rid of things probably has to do with the sense of either instability or impermanence that she felt when she was younger, you know, we typically associate the stability or the permanence of being in one place with the concept of home. Right home is not transient home doesn't change day to day, we're going month to month. And I think a lot of people who either it could be that you had a great, wonderful family and you moved around a lot, it could be that you experienced some adverse childhood experiences, whether that's abuse or a loss. And I think that brings a new level of complexity into our things. And I think it's important to recognize that I think it sounds like Samantha does and and to honor that, like we've been talking about where we say, okay, you know, this broom, that, you know, is falling apart? What is that bringing up for me that fear of getting rid of that? Is it that I used to not be able to afford another broom? Is it that we grew up poor, and I can hear my meme on my head saying, you know, don't waste things, you know, good people don't waste things. Is it that the transient nature of getting rid of things, you never got to hold on to anything long enough to feel a sense of home? And there's no easy answer to that. But just being willing to say these are valid things to experience around my stuff. And I think that there are also some things you can do. First of all, I always want to say like, there's nothing wrong with recognizing that's why I want to hold on to things and so I'm going to hold on to them, hold on to them if that's where you are in your journey and you need that comfort that reassurance hold on to them. Now if maybe the manager says well, it is affecting my functioning well, but maybe we can find ways to keep those things in a way that doesn't affect your functioning. Right. And that's where we get creative, but maybe she does say no, I really do. You know kind of need to get rid of it. And I think that sometimes we don't have to meet it head on. Like I have this picture in my online shop and you can buy it as a print or you can download it for free and it says this home is a safe home and I am safe in it. And I think sometimes we need these visual reminders. This is not my childhood home. I am safe here. This is my you know, stable home and I think there's A lot of things we can do in our environment that can help us kind of gain that reassurance we need so that we can maybe sometimes let go of an item we need to.

    Alison Lush 30:09

    Yeah, that's an excellent point. I don't think I've ever heard anybody talk in that in those terms about comparing the childhood home versus the today home and how we can create our today home to feel more secure. That's very beautiful. The way you just describe that.

    KC Davis 30:23

    Well, thank you. And it kind of brings just because I talked about hanging a piece of artwork. This question I thought was really interesting. This is from kitty. It says one of my struggles is decorating. Which sounds stupid as I write it. But when I look around my house with its crappy, mismatched decor, and it's dirty walls, Kid destroyed couch, hand me down furniture and lack of any style, I'm defeated and deflated. Not talking about high end interior decoration, although what, what I wouldn't do to win the lottery. I would like my house to look more like a family lives here and less like squatters do. How do you hang photos? How do you paint walls? How do you feel good about your space? And this question almost makes me have tears in my eyes. Because I feel like when you're talking about our relationship to our space, and how do we make a home, and I was just curious if you had any thoughts on that,

    Alison Lush 31:13

    I certainly don't specialize in interior decoration. But I have got an image that and a notion that I had developed a several years ago, which I think might be helpful here. You've probably heard of home staging, when people are putting their house on the market, they want to sell a home, the real estate, people want to be able to bring strangers in and walk them around and show them the place and we want what you want is for anybody walking in to be able to imagine themselves being able to live there. Therefore, it's important that the decor in the space be neutralized so that anybody can imagine themselves living there. That's the goal. So in staging, and I'm not a home stager, I hope I'm not speaking out of turn here. But my understanding of home staging is neutralizing the environment taking out the personal the over personal from the environment. And when I realized that number of years ago, what I realized is my personal goal working with clients is to do the exact opposite. My goal is to reach inside of the human being, reach inside of the human being and help them extract and pull out whatever is personal and meaning for them and then infuse their environment with who they are and what's meaningful to them. There's no such thing as it should be this way, it should be that way. Don't have to worry, I personally don't think the focus needs to be on how to hang a picture. The focus could be perhaps better invested in what do I want to be looking at it every every day, that makes me feel good. That reinforces my feeling of pride about my family, and I'm a good mom and I my beautiful kids and my kids love each other and look at them having a great activity in this picture that picture. That's what matters. It doesn't matter what frames they're in, it doesn't matter what wall they go in, it doesn't matter how they're hung. It's the images. It's the life inside. It's the personal connection, and the resonance with the person and their life. That's what the value of home decor is. Whether it's color, whether it's I want to have a yellow wall, because yellow makes me feel cheerful, then that's the right color to have on the wall. There's no right and wrong, the answers are inside of us. That's my view.

    KC Davis 33:17

    I love it. And I think obviously if we're worried about oh, is it aesthetic? Does it look right together? There are obviously people you could ask to come in and tell you that that you could get a handyman to hang photos. But I think I mean, I hear kitty asking the deeper question that you're really answering which is we don't have to worry about creating some sort of aesthetically cohesive look, if you want that you can do that. It's more about as you say, kind of unstaged in the space and getting into you know, when she says the crappy mismatched decor, the dirty walls, the kid destroyed couch. Some of that is just changing the way you look at those items.

    Alison Lush 33:55

    It's a life that's being lived in when I look at my sink of dirty dishes. If I get up in the morning and I look into my sink of dirty dishes, I can either say oh Ellison, you know you lazy slob. You should have to wash the dishes last night or I can say aren't we lucky? We had a wonderful dinner last night.

    KC Davis 34:10

    Yes. And the like I have a crappy kid destroyed couch. I have cats, my couch is gross to look at. I mean, there are stains on it. There's cat hair on it. But you know the meaning of that couch is a life well lived. And now it's not pretty to look at. But what I did was right above that couch on our window sills are hung, these handmade ladybugs that my three year old made, and I feel like it's the perfect representation of okay, we don't love the couch. We'd like to get a new couch. The couch isn't nice looking. It doesn't. I don't feel warm and fuzzy when I look at it. But in conjunction with these handmade ladybugs, there's something about them together. I mean, they're holed. They're up there with scotch tape. There's something about that picture together. That gives that couch meaning right it's not squatters that live here. It's little kids.

    Alison Lush 34:57

    I think that it's really important that we record igniters that every phase of life that we're in, has different needs. And we're focusing on different priorities right now, anybody with kids growing up, like in Kitty's house, the focus is raising a family supporting those kids so that they can go out and have friends supporting those kids. So they can go out and get an education, supporting the parents so that they can support the kids. That's what it's all about right now in the family. My personal home, for example, right now, my kids have moved up, moved up, grown up and moved out. And so now it's just my husband and I, the phase of life that we're in is completely different. Our home, we have more space, we have more peace, there's fewer dirty dishes in the sink, it's a different phase of life, if we aspire to a style or an aesthetic that is beyond our reach, because it's not appropriate for the phase of life that we're in, we're guaranteeing ourselves to be dissatisfied. If we rather like you did with your coach. And with the ladybugs, if we rather say this is this phase of life I'm in right now and honor it and say I want to be a great parent I what's important to me is to have a comfortable, warm, fuzzy family home and couch where we can all cuddle up together. And we're not going to be stressed out about spilling the chocolate milk on the couch or whatever. What's more important is our time together, then the stains on the couch become much less important. And then later on, when the kids are grown up and moved out, you can get a pretty couch or you can always put a cover over it or something if you want to.

    KC Davis 36:19

    And when she says the mismatched decor, I want to bet money that that decor is something that she got off of a shelf somewhere because she thought to herself, that's looks like something that would be hung on an adult's wall, right, as opposed to something meaningful. And I think what you're saying can go hand in hand with what I'm about to say, which is sometimes when we are in the trenches of little kid life sometimes or thinking about decor, you know, we do want to be reminded that we are people outside of this phase of life. And one thing that comes to me is I mean, you know, I'm thinking kitty, do you have a favorite band? Do you have a favorite band? Do you have a favorite painting? Do you have something you love? Maybe because when you were in college before kids, maybe you had those band posters on the wall. Now, you may not want to tack them up on the wall, but you can frame it, you can make it look like an adult lives it and have these representations of you know, this is this is who I am. And that makes me happy to look at, you know, if you've got some sort of live, laugh, love nondescript sconce on the wall, because that's kind of what you thought adults put on the walls. Maybe that's why it's not speaking to you. So I would lean into both like lean into Okay, let's put the ladybugs on the wall and lean into this is my favorite band. Why did I ever take that poster down? My husband and I have this was supposed to be a game room. But it was sort of our guest room slash where he was working for the longest time. And it just kind of became the Doom room. We dumped everything there. And we decided that, hey, when we sell this house, we will have to stage this area. And then we will be mad at ourselves that we waited until we were leaving to make it like a nice cool area. So we redid the area, and we didn't do anything like we didn't paint anything or do any construction, just simple, you know, got rid of some things brought a couple of little bookcases and chairs and, and when we stepped back, we looked at it and it's our favorite place in the house. Because it's the only place in our house the kids don't. And we find ourselves hanging out here all the time is sometimes my husband even sleep up here, because it just it almost feels like a little bachelor pad. It feels like a little one room loft. We didn't want to buy new pictures. So we ended up putting some pictures of some renderings that I did when I was in college as a costume design student on the walls. We have a throw that says I wait here for you forever as long as it takes and we just tacked it up on the wall. And so we joke with each other that like we come up here to sort of cosplay like single people living in a loft in New York. Because, you know, the majority of our house is dedicated to sort of a kid centric space. And so I think there's a way to sort of lean into both of those things at once. You know what makes me happy because if you put something on the wall that makes you happy to look at all the sudden it doesn't bother you as much that it doesn't match the theme.

    Alison Lush 39:12

    100% Yes, anything that we can do to recharge our batteries and fuel ourselves so that we can continue giving to other people and doing whatever it is that we're trying to accomplish. That's so valuable.

    KC Davis 39:25

    Okay, I feel like we have question time for maybe one more question. And I thought this one was interesting. It this is from Aria. She says my home life and my work life blur into endless chaos. Do you have some tactics for how to separate and manage the mental and physical clutter? When that clutter meshes into inappropriate times, ie I cannot turn off work on off days because I'm very available to my clients, or I'm at work but I'm worried about the mess in the kitchen. And you know, she's kind of talking about mentally How do I turn it off? But what I was reminded when I read this is that throughout this pandemic, we've had more and more people staying at home and where it used to be, well, home is my home life, my family and office is my office. And you know, the bar is my social life. And then I go to the library to knit, like, all of a sudden everything's at home. And I'm curious what any kind of insight you have on when we think about organizing our stuff, is there a way to organize our stuff that helps us with those boundaries and delineations. And I'm thinking, particularly for someone that doesn't have the obvious option of Oh, yeah, just put it in your home office, right, because not everybody has a home office.

    Alison Lush 40:32

    I'm reminded of the notion of what's enough. So for example, typically, well, one of the themes in people feeling absolutely overwhelmed and being very ambitious in their career or whatever, trying to squeeze in so many things in 24 hours, there's a density to what they're trying to pack into 24 hours and things over overlap, and they don't get time off. And I find it very helpful to pull it back and try to identify what is enough, if I give support to my clients, what is just enough support to my clients, what is just enough housekeeping, it's very much resonating with all of the language that you use, which is just enough to get myself you know, started on the next state, for example. Because when we're being ambitious, professionally, and out in the world, it's sort of like a black hole, it will suck out everything that you will give it, we have to make the boundaries ourselves. And we only have 20k. Here's another thought, and I'm bouncing a little bit on this one, too, I will confess time management, productivity is not my zone of comfort. And it's I don't specialize in it, because it's not something that I feel that I master on the one hand, and it's not a place where I feel comfortable speaking, my zone of comfort is physical stuff, and emotional attachment and skill development and getting people unstuck. That's where, especially with their physical belongings, and helping people get refocused. But this comes up a lot. People who are stuck with feeling overburdened with their meant how they manage their time and their space, one of the most powerful things that any of us can do is to remember that we only have 24 hours in a day, it's just like money, you only have so much we're accustomed to talking about money and money being a finite resource, you only have so much money to get through the month, or to get through the year. And we function with whatever money we've got. Or we keep sliding into debt. And it's obvious, we can see it right there on the balance sheet. But what we forget often is that we only have 24 hours in a day, and we only have so much energy and time. But we spend our energy and our time as if it was an infinite, as if they were infinite resources. And they are not. So anybody who's struggling with time and energy management, it's recommended that they spend a little bit of time doing, I just sent one to a client yesterday. It's a sheet like a spreadsheet. And you basically note down how you're spending your time, their 24 hour period over a week. And you do that for like two weeks. And it gives you feedback about how you're actually spending your time and your energy. Because frequently when we're feeling overwhelmed and like we our boundaries are all intermeshed and we're not taking care of our fundamental needs. It's because we're spending our time and energy more in places where maybe it's not the best and less where we actually need it. And so we need to get a portrait of where we're actually spending it. And this is based on the concept that any financial advisor would have us do. If you're trying to get your finances under control. First, start by identify where are you actually spending your money. Let's start there. And then massage and put more here and less from there. And it's the same thing with time and energy, because they're finite resources.

    KC Davis 43:57

    What it also reminds me of is it be interesting not only to look at how I'm spending my time, but also mentally where am I? How much of the day do I spend thinking about those dishes? How much of the day am I spending thinking about those clients? And I'm reminded of a couple of things that have really worked in my home is I sort of famously have the dirty dish rack right? Because for reasons that are not important to this podcast, I sometimes have a difficult time taking a dish using a dish, rinsing it off putting in the dish. I mean, it's just a lot of steps for me, right, I can do about half those steps with ease. So I got a dish rack because what was happening was that when when the dishes were piled up in the sink, it was very overwhelming to me. I couldn't have access to the sink. And now I'm thinking about what a huge mess it was when I got a dish rack and put it next to the sink and started stacking up the dirty dishes. For some reason, the same amount of dishes stacked organized on a rack seems so much less intimidating and fewer dishes actually even then when they're bundled in the sink and I'm I'm also thinking about, you know, when we are looking at how much time am I spending thinking about these things versus doing these things? I'm wondering if there are these small organizational steps that someone like ARIA could take where, okay, you don't maybe have 10 minutes in the morning to do all the dishes. But do you have three minutes to put them on a dish rack? Because then maybe you won't think about them so much, because they're not cluttering the space. They're not, you know, oh, it's such a mess. It's like, no, it's staged, right, it's there ready to go when you have time. And maybe there would be a comparable way of sort of, it's almost like when she needs to work, she needs a way of triaging the home stuff. And when she's at home, she needs a way of triaging. And there's, I can't help but think that there's got to be some visual and organizational systems that can help her feel as though Okay, these things have been bookmarked to be taken care of. And I don't have to sit here and think about them.

    Alison Lush 45:54

    So what you've just identified with the dish rack is, it's a container, you have given a specific container that has been earmarked for a purpose. And so you've legitimized the dirty dishes, which is the perfect solution in your situation, it's a perfect solution, when they were sitting in the sink, they don't really belong in the sink, because it makes the sink, not functional, it makes the sink difficult to access. So when you want to fill up that big pot of water to make past at lunch, you can't do it, because there's all kinds of dirty dishes. So to make the sink functional, you created a reserved specific space for the dirty dishes. And that was a perfect solution. So if anybody like for example, Arya looking at something that's dysfunctional, the bothering her, if it keeps bothering her, I would encourage her to look at it and try to ask herself the questions. In what way? Is it bothering her? Is it that she's reminded of it all the time? Is it that there's some guilt associated with it? And if there's guilt, where's the guilt coming from? Is it some old cassette in her brain that was, you know, doesn't need to be there that she could replace with something else? Is it reasonable to feel guilty about it? Or is it perfectly normal to have dirty dishes, for example, and what other options might exist? So it's when we take any individual specific little thing exactly as you did with the dirtiness in the sink? And look at it and ask ourselves what is necessary here, and what don't I need, and then what is a simple solution to containerize and legitimize the thing

    KC Davis 47:23

    that is awesome, we get away from the scripts about what should be in our home. And we just look at what is actually in our home, if we can make the decision to get rid of some things that aren't functioning, but when things are in our home, just legitimizing it and giving it permission to exist, allows you It frees you up for the creativity to go okay, so then we need a system here, we need a container, we need a place for these to exist, that doesn't impede the functioning of the sink that doesn't have it always on my mind. I love that, because I'm thinking of so many things in my home. That, you know, it reminds me of when I used to like it was a newborn and I would change her diaper. And we soon found that because the doors closed all the time for nap, the dirty diaper been made the room smell, and we're like, oh, she can't sleep in there. So we started, we moved it out into the hallway. Well, when you're changing a baby's diaper, and then you'd have the dirty diaper. Well, but now you have to put the baby into the crib, you're not just like walking out with it. And so I would toss them into the hallway, thinking well, I'll toss them into the hallway, and then I'll pick it up on my way out, except I never picked it up on my way out. So I always had this pile of peepee and poopoo diapers right outside of the nursery. And then I walked by be like, Oh, that's such a piece of shit. I can't believe I've done that. So disgusting. But one day, I really did look at them and legitimize them like you know what this is what's happening right now this is like low on the totem pole of things that need to be solved in my life. And I just put a wastebasket there, right where the pile was. So that as I tossed them out of the room, they were going right into a little trash can. And now I can empty the trash can when it's full. And I just legitimize the pile of dirty diapers and gave them a container. And you know what, it was a short season of our life. And it's not an issue anymore. And I'm glad that I didn't beat myself up, or make myself sort of do what I should have done with them. Because at the end of the day, who's got time for that

    Alison Lush 49:19

    I have three other echoes on that on the theme of categorizing and legitimizing. When I'm working with clients, we always come across things that they're not ready to make a decision about yet. Decision making is very, very difficult. I don't know what to do with this thing, whatever this thing is, I don't know if I should keep it or if I should let it go. If a person is really stuck on it, the worst thing that we can do is just put it down because then we're just creating chaos. If we're really close to like I've got a lot of categories and things are going well. And I have this one thing I don't know what to do with if I have a box called something like the ripening box or the indecision box or something a space that is actually a container week. input things in there that we have no idea what to do with right now and then come back and revisit it later. And frequently, just the passage of time. When we come back, and we look at that thing in the future, sometimes it's obviously, but we're ready to make a decision, because we've just let some time pass. So that's one. The second one is, when we're organizing and creating categories and putting labels on all kinds of categories, frequently, we ends up with things that they just don't fit into a category, they just don't. And so we use this word called Miss kibble. So the Miss kibble box is just like all the random stuff, it's like, rather than calling it the junk box, it's the Michigan mibelle. Box, and we don't know what to do with it, just toss it in there, it'll be safe, you know, it's not lost, if you need it, you can go and look for it, it's a safe place to put things. And the third one is, many of my clients are creative types. And they have bits of pipe and bits of leather, and bits of fabric, and bits of plastic and all these things. And they say, but I might be able to use it one day, which is totally legitimate, but they don't know what to do with it. And they feel everybody's always saying, Oh, just get rid of it. It's just a piece of junk. But they're creative people. And they see things in terms of possibility. So they see they know that they need raw materials in the future. So we create a category called raw materials. And that gives them a name and legitimacy. And we can create a box for it and put all the stuff in that one box all mixed up. And they're happy, and they get to keep the stuff that they need. But it's got walls in a container, and it doesn't take over the whole house.

    KC Davis 51:24

    I love that there. I think that there are probably a lot of people here. And we will wrap up with this. But I just there's probably a lot of people that resist reaching out to an organizer, because they know they're not ready to purge things, they're not ready to get rid of a bunch of stuff, they're not ready to, you know, go through that emotional process. And what I'm hearing is that you would be a safe person for someone to reach out and say, I'm not ready to do some big declutter, overhaul, get rid downsize. But I need some help. And I love that because you deserve to function in your space. You deserve to have someone that can meet you compassionately with creative solutions on how you can raise your quality of life. Even if you're not ready to do some big purge,

    Alison Lush 52:11

    Not everybody needs to purge stuff. What I focus on is helping people get unstuck. That's the way I think of it, people come to me and they say, I'm stuck. I don't know how to get past this thing. It's like this big boulder in my way, and I can't get past it. So we focus on what can we do about the boulder? Does it need to be, you know, blown up? And then it's going to be a whole bunch of little pieces? And you can just step over it? Or can we figure out a way to get around it? Or can we figure out a way to look at it differently. And it'll be see through, that's what we do is we focus on whatever is blocking the person, I sometimes do sessions with people. And we do one session or two sessions. And that's all they need in order to get unstuck. And then they're often they go on their own. We don't necessarily embark on a process where we're working together weekly for the next year or something like that. Every single person has different needs, and I adapt my services. And for whatever the person needs. It's totally, totally flexible and absolutely meets the person where they are. Not everybody needs to get rid of their stuff. That's a very dangerous assumption. I think that that's one thing about the professional organizing industry that is a shame is that we've got this reputation of being we're going to tell everybody to throw it all their stuff. I absolutely do not agree with that.

    KC Davis 53:20

    Not helpful. Well, Alison, where can people find you if they want to find you on social media, if they want to work with you?

    Alison Lush 53:28

    The easiest thing to do is just to Google me and find my website. That's the absolute easiest thing to do. Alison lush.ca is my website. So you will find me. And there's information there. There's answers to questions. There's a link to a 20 minute introductory exploratory call, which is free I phone the person, we have a 20 minute phone call to see what their needs are and what services I'm offering and figure out if we'd make a good team together. So if people are curious about my services, they'll get information there and they can reach out to me and I'm on social medias as well. But that's the main place is my website or my tic tock alongside Casey, Casey news.

    KC Davis 54:03

    And Alison is with one L. Yes. Okay. And she's also linked on my website. So if you go to struggle, care.com and you click on Resources and homecare, she is one of the resources that I listed there. If you want to check out her website and what is your tick tock handle?

    Alison Lush 54:19

    I think it's Alison lash underscore enough. I'm pretty sure that's what it is. Alison lash underscore enough.

    KC Davis 54:25

    Great. Well, Alison, I can't thank you so much. This has been an awesome conversation. And I hope that everyone goes and follows Alison, but if you don't follow me, come follow me too. And Alison, it's been a joy. Thank you so much.

    Alison Lush 54:38

    It's been such an honor. Thank you very much, and congratulations again. Thanks.

KC Davis
04: Q&A: A Housekeeper and an Organizer Walk Into a Bar...

Today, we start with my take on a question that I get asked almost every day about how to keep from losing motivation to complete tasks, especially those simple ones like cleaning a room. If you’ve beaten yourself up over this struggle, then join me for a fresh perspective on cleaning your space! 

Show Highlights:

  • Why losing motivation to clean a room comes down to not realizing that tidying, organizing, and cleaning are three different projects

  • What is required to “tidy a room”: a five-step method

  • How organizing differs from tidying and cleaning

  • What the cleaning process entails

  • Why there’s nothing wrong with being a neat or messy person, but a functional level of organization is essential

  • How the tasks of tidying, organizing, and cleaning bring emotional barriers, especially for those with executive function disorders

  • Why we need to remember that these care tasks are morally neutral–and the only reason to do them is so we can function better

Resources:

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

KC Davis
03: Eco-Shame with Rebecca Gray

You have probably heard me say, “You can’t save the rainforest if you are depressed.” The truth is that eco-shame and eco-perfectionism can get in the way of our taking steps toward better functioning. If you have ever felt guilty for not being “eco-friendly enough,” this episode is for you! 

Rebecca Gray is an environmental epidemiologist. With her master’s degree in public health, she studies disease, the patterns of disease, and health at population levels within communities and countries. She also studies how factors in the environment impact health by causing and promoting disease. Rebecca works with government agencies like the EPA and CDC to develop water guidelines to keep pollutants out of the water supply. 

Show Highlights:

  • How Rebecca has experienced forms of eco-shame in her profession

  • How some people push the environmental movement in ways that are able-ist

  • The trap we fall into to “embody the archetype” of the space we occupy

  • How social media plays into the eco-perfectionism pressure we feel

  • Why functionality matters more than the morality of what we do in care tasks, eating, the environment, etc.

  • Rebecca’s view of today’s environmental movement

  • Why we should ask ourselves how an eco-behavior affects our health and well being

  • What really does need to happen to prevent climate change

  • How our capitalistic society colors what we can do to be eco-friendly

  • How differing narratives make us feel pressured to make individual changes and collective changes to “save the world”

  • How to identify what we need to function well, fill in gaps with eco-friendly behaviors, and learn how to conserve our energy

  • How to take a more reasonable–and less stressful–view of sustainability swaps

  • Actions that have the least impact and the most impact on environmentalism

  • Rebecca’s advice about letting ourselves off the hook for the decisions we make

Resources:

Connect with Rebecca: LinkedIn 

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

  • KC Davis 0:00

    Okay. Hello, you sentient balls of stardust. I'm KC Davis. And this is struggle care, the mental health podcast that does not expect you to save the rainforest when you're depressed. Today, I'm talking to Rebecca Gray, who's an environmental epidemiologist, and we're going to talk about eco perfectionism and eco shame. So if you've ever felt guilty for not being eco friendly enough, this one is for you. Hello, and thank you for joining me today. One of the things that I've talked about a lot in my channels, and I talked about in my book is my principle, you can't save the rainforest if you're depressed. And it's basically talking about how eco shame and eco perfectionism really can get in the way of us taking steps towards better functioning. And I wanted to do a couple of episodes on this. And the guests that I have today is Rebecca gray. She's an environmental epidemiologist, and I'm gonna let her introduce herself. Rebecca, tell us your sort of background and what you do for a living?

    Rebecca Gray 1:01

    Yeah, great. Thank you so much for having me, I'm really excited to be here. So first of all, I have my master's degree in public health, which means that I look at disease and health at a population level. So if medicine were the individual, I look at communities, countries, etc. And I'm an environmental epidemiologist. So I feel like the word epidemiology has gotten a lot of press during the pandemic. But essentially, it is the study of patterns of disease in human populations. And the environmental part comes in because I study how things in the environment impact our health either promote it or cause disease. So that could be chemical pollutants and our air or our drinking water. Or it could be more physical characteristics of our environment, like temperature, or extreme weather events, etc. So obviously, climate change overlaps with that quite a bit. That is like kind of the overall gist of environmental epidemiology. In my job, specifically, I work with government agencies. So I've worked with the Centers for Disease Control, and the environmental protection agency to help develop water guidelines for different pollutants in our water to keep the community safe from getting sick from bad things in our water.

    KC Davis 2:13

    Awesome. So you and I connected when I actually made a tick tock that said, I want to talk to someone who is an environmentalist that can talk about, you know, eco shame, eco perfection. And you know, you and I connected and you reached out. And what I really was drawn to is that you not only had professional experience, and environmentalism and knowledge, but you also have quite a bit of personal experience and sort of what I've been calling environmental perfectionism. Can you share a little bit about that?

    Rebecca Gray 2:42

    Yeah, absolutely. So I would say, as a college student, and then a graduate student who was training to be not only an environmental scientist, but also an environmental scientist focused on human health, I felt an immense amount of pressure to be kind of a poster child for both eco conservation and a picture of human health. Obviously, both of those things are unattainable. But in terms of, you know, from standpoint of eco perfectionism, it was things like feeling really compulsive and obsessive about reducing my carbon footprint, not using single use plastic, not creating food waste. And obviously, I was never able to have not been able to achieve any of those things perfectly, which caused a lot of like, very crippling anxiety and guilt. And that really fed into again, a lot of this pressure I felt to be perfectly healthy person. So I really struggled with an eating disorder called orthorexia, which is unhealthy fixation on kind of eating the quote unquote, right foods or a fear of eating the quote unquote, wrong foods and contamination. And I really, you know, for several years, the level to which my anxiety about being an imposter, as both an environmentalist and a health scientist was debilitating and did interfere with my ability to do my job and live my life productively.

    KC Davis 4:05

    So yeah, it was so interesting is, you know, the study of how the environment affects our health. And there's also this sort of, like, you're kind of in the upside down where it's like, this is an example of environment affecting housing health. Yeah. But it's like all of the good things about being an environmentalist, it's trying to achieve a good thing to perfection ends up having this really negative impact.

    Rebecca Gray 4:32

    Absolutely. And, you know, I say that, as a person who has a lot of privileges that actually make it I think, very easy for me to fit into the environmental movement. I am a white person, I am a thin person, I'm an able bodied person, a middle class person. So all of those things give me access to these spaces and having, you know, more marginalized identities on top of that, I think, I imagine would make it even more difficult. So yeah, I don't know the idea of like a poster. child or a perfect embodiment of these values definitely has weighed on me in my life and is

    KC Davis 5:07

    I recently had Imani Barbara and on and she's a disability activist. And we talked about the intersection between disability and environmentalism. And she was sharing with me about how much of the environmental movement is ableist. Or at least the ways in which people are pushing environmentalism can be ablest can be anti black. And it was a fascinating conversation. Because when I think about, you know, what you're describing is like the poster child for environmentalism, I do always picture like a thin white woman who is like drinking out of a ball mason jar, right. And like, who is, you know, biking to her job that allows that is somehow close enough to bike to, but as paying her enough that she can buy things that are more expensive, because they're more sustainable. And it's truly it's such a nuanced intersection. And so I think it's really interesting to talk to you and hear you say, you know, I kind of am someone with these privileges that fit into that mold. And even for you, it was damaging.

    Rebecca Gray 6:18

    Yeah, absolutely. And I think something that I love about your content, and the work that you do is separating morality and functionality. And I think such a contributor for me personally, and for a lot of people is the feeling that embodying this archetype is moral, but archetypes of people don't have morality attached to them. And, you know, while individual behaviors can absolutely be productive, and moral and contributing, engaging in everything all the time looking and being a certain way, all of the time is not a good measure of our worth, or our contribution as people because we are always going to fall short of that.

    KC Davis 7:00

    Let me tell you, when you said the words, embodying the archetype, I got chills, like I got goosebumps. And I almost feel a little choked up. Because I feel as though you've put into words, something that I've experienced my whole life, I've occupied several different spaces. You know, I occupied the recovery space when I was in recovery from drug addiction, sort of the 12 step space, the absolute space space, I've occupied, you know, the evangelical space at a time in my life, I have occupied the mental health space. And I really resonate with what you're saying, even when I was in my addiction. For me, when I was having this root fear of not being enough of not being worthy of love, what I always sort of tried to do to fix that was to look for whatever space I was occupying, be it culture, institution, subculture, I was always striving to be the perfect embodiment of the archetype. So when I was using it was, how do I be cooler? How do I get better drugs? How do I be perceived as, you know a badass how to why and I was striving for that, and I felt I could not reach it. And then I get sober. And I learned so many things. And there were so many really great ways that I became healthier. But that route of feeling unworthy of love, just at some point shifted its focus to now I need to embody the archetype of recovery woman. And that imposter syndrome that you're talking about remained right, I move into the church and I find myself I want to stand in the front and I want to be a missionary, and I want to be on staff and I want to be an recognizing and actually did become a missionary and then had sort of a crisis of faith fall apart during it. And it was around this idea where I realized, so much of what I've been striving for isn't actually fueled by my real beliefs. It's fueled by this promise, this intangible promise that if I can embody the archetype of this space, I will finally be good enough, I will finally get love. I will finally like myself and others will like me too. I just have never really been able to put that into words before so I thank you. That's, I think, like a gift that's gonna stick with me forever. And it applies here, too, right? When we start to occupy spaces that we actually might really believe in with causes that we really do care about, but we can kind of get hijacked by that primal human need to be loved and to be worthy and to belong.

    Rebecca Gray 9:39

    Yeah, absolutely. And I think, I mean, you're gonna thank me for putting into the word into where it's like, I'm gonna thank you for putting into words care tasks are functional, not moral. I mean, I think that so much of like my growth and learning and recovery from an eating disorder and an anxiety disorder came from honest sleeves social media seeing people who had done this and had spent time thinking about it put feelings that I had into words that helped me understand them. That happened to me, you know, when I was getting recovering from orthorexia. I hadn't found like the term intuitive eating yet, but I was like starting to think it I remember telling friends, like, it's just easier if I don't like think too much about what I'm eating. And then like a year later, I'm on Instagram and like, kids eating color is like, it's it's called intuitive eating, and things like that, which I think, I don't know, social media is like such a great tool. I love social media.

    KC Davis 10:37

    Me too. I always laugh if you've ever seen like, sometimes every once in a while, it happens a lot. Some artists will draw like these kind of metaphorical representations of like the evils of technology, and it'll be like two people in a room, but they're looking at their phones. Yeah. And I'm always like, where's the artists who's gonna draw like the woman suffering from postpartum depression? Who's like Lifeline is coming through that social media? Yeah,

    Rebecca Gray 11:03

    I'm like, people want to knock Instagram infographics, as if I haven't learned like, most of my like activism from Instagram and Tiktok,

    KC Davis 11:13

    I have I have learned most of my activism from tick tock, and tick tock in particular, has put me in touch with creators that I would never have come across. Like I just I live in a very white space, I live in a very abled space. And sometimes, you know, the value of not just being surrounded by that, but at the same time, purposefully, trying to be friend, a person of color, because they're a person of color is also like, not, not it, not it right. And so there is this sort of how do I diversify my mind? How do I decolonize my views and social media has been the way that's happened by following these creators that I never would have been able to cross paths with in real life. And so I totally get you there. And, you know, it's interesting, because that aspect of social media has been so helpful. And I'm sure that social media has also been part of the issue with eco perfectionism. You know, because we do see people post only their best moments.

    Rebecca Gray 12:15

    Absolutely. And I think, you know, I would say, like four years ago, I don't know about anybody else. But my Instagram was filled with, again, the archetype of a zero waste girl, a slow fashion girl, like mainly white women, mainly thin women with expensive, sustainable clothing, with plastic free bathrooms with I don't know, who had time to like bake bread twice a week, and like, filming Instagram video of it. And I was like, in grad school, and technically, my income was below the poverty line. And I'm like, Well, I guess I'm doing it wrong,

    KC Davis 12:51

    even when I like so I have an online shop, I sell a lot of digital downloads, but I also sell some physical products. And as I'm moving into this space, where I want to start selling like workbooks and planners and things like that, there is the option of like, sustainable packaging, and all these sorts of things. And as I look into it, it's like, it's more expensive. And I know that the majority of my demographic like, probably can't afford so I'm always trying to look for how can I make this the most accessible resource or the most accessible product, while still keeping the business running? And you have to choose between the two sometimes, right? And I think one of the other things that you said that really hit me was when you were talking about intuitive eating. So I actually read the bucket diet by Caroline donor a few years ago, and I've been, you know, my philosophies and struggle care have been supremely influenced by the intuitive eating anti diet movement, where we're taking the morality out of food. And so, you know, taking the morality out of care tasks, was something that I started talking about, especially with people who are struggling with mental health, chronic illness. And one of the ways when I stopped thinking it was this moral obligation, I realized that there also weren't any rules. And then I could kind of get creative about how can I make these rhythms and rituals of care tasking work for me, and for me, as a person that was, you know, I was at home, I had some postpartum depression, I had ADHD, I was finding these what I call adaptive routines, like, okay, my dishes are going days and days and days, and I'm getting bugs because I can't and then I'm overwhelmed. But if I put my dishes in the dishwasher at seven o'clock every night and I run the dishwasher, that's more manageable. And then I found that if I do it a half a load, like if I don't wait until the dishwasher is full, I'm less overwhelmed. I'm less paralyzed. I don't. And so when I started talking to people about these adaptive routines, I would get comments and they were usually pretty cruel about I guess you don't care about the environment. If you're going to wastewater like that. I talked one time about how, you know all calories are good calories when you're grieving. And, you know, I had a radical vegan comment about how you know, we were killing other mothers just to save human mothers. And there's this like visceral cruelty with environmentalism that is really pretty horrifying and toxic. Yeah. And so I'm curious to hear as an environmentalist, you know, what kinds of things do you think that the environmental movement, as it stands today? What things are we doing well, that are actually helping? And what ways is some of the avenues we're taking the environmental movement not being helpful? Or maybe even being oppressive?

    Rebecca Gray 15:39

    Yeah, absolutely. Well, I think like your example of the dishwasher is such a good one, because it's like, okay, it helps you be a lot more functional and taking care of yourself and your family. And it used twice as much water. So like, obviously, there's a cost environmentally there. But I think an exercise that I have tried to work on doing over the past few years that I would really encourage other people to do is when thinking about like an eco behavior or sustainability behavior, asking yourself and being really honest with yourself, can I engage in this behavior and honor my health and well being? And that answer is going to be different depending on the person and the behavior. So something that you bring up that I really like is, I think it's like 1000, unseen privileges and barriers. So like, for example, for years, I was a vegetarian, because I was like, Well, I have an understanding that vegetarianism is good for the environment, and it's good for my health. Actually, turns out being a vegetarian and restricting my food is not good for my health, because I'm a person with a history of Ed, for other people, vegetarianism is a great way to engage in an eco behavior and reduce their carbon footprint, and it works really well for their health. That wasn't true for me, it was not a behavior that I could engage in healthfully, like on the flip side of that, I really like to walk places when I can, instead of driving, that reduces my carbon footprint, I have a lot of privileges that make that accessible to me, you know, I'm able bodied, I have the relative luxury of time, I live in a really walkable community, and I enjoy doing it. So that fits into my life, it might not for somebody else with different privileges and barriers. And, you know, sometimes it's even more clear cut than that there are people with chronic health conditions or injuries who need single use plastic to stay alive. Not that it has to be a question of, you know, yes or no survival, but a question of, I think your functionality and your happiness, and the only person you can really have that conversation with is yourself. So like in on the topic of which behaviors are really good and work and which don't, I think it is so nuanced, and so personal. And I also genuinely think that, you know, humans are pretty inclined to be moral and contributing. And when the answer is yes, this behavior does fit into my life, people are pretty inclined to engage with it, of their own freewill. I mean, most of us do use washable reusable dishes instead of single use ones unless circumstances make it challenging to do that. So I think the pressure on the individual to perform perfectly is a real negative of the environmental movement. And I don't know, like the idea that each of us individually is responsible for changing the outcome of climate change, or the trajectory of the world by remembering our reusable bags every day is a pretty unrealistic myth.

    KC Davis 18:34

    Yeah, one of the things that I have found interesting is this hyper focus on the individual, like, you know, it's up to all of us to not use straws to save the world. And, you know, this is not my area of expertise. But what I'm learning is that there's a lot of misplaced impetus on who is really capable of saving or damming the world. And, you know, I don't want to move into a space where we think oh, because, you know, since what I do doesn't matter, who cares, but there's got to be some sort of nuance that we can wrap our heads around, like, what really does need to happen to prevent climate change?

    Rebecca Gray 19:15

    Great question. Yeah. Well, I think what you're getting at too is in America, we live under capitalism, capitalism places, the onus on the individual for their success. And capitalism has placed a lot of the onus on us, the individuals to stop climate change, and a lot of that time that involves us buying things to be or look sustainable, or investing our time and energy which are limited.

    KC Davis 19:40

    So I just have to say that again, what you just said, you said, you know, we live under a capitalistic society. That's just a neutral statement. It's just a truth. And a lot of the environmentalism that we are taught or given is based around us purchasing something because that's what keeps capitalism going or Having the time and energy to engage in behaviors or activism, time and energy that is typically only available to people in upper classes in a capitalistic society?

    Rebecca Gray 20:12

    Absolutely. I mean, having the time to walk somewhere to wash and reuse something, too, like buy food in bulk, and prepare meals at home time is a limited commodity, especially where we are in society right now.

    KC Davis 20:29

    Well, on top of that, this idea that production is morally superior to rest, where we feel like, you know, if you say, Well, it's a luxury to have the time to do this. I think there's a lot of people that think, well, I, I technically have the time, you know, if I didn't have hobbies, or rest, or look at tick tock. And there, we feel like there's this moral imperative to produce, produce, produce, produce produce. And so we feel like resting, relaxing, recreating our indulgences, they're disposables. And that if we're doing something like that, you know, unless we're replacing every minute of our day, with something productive, we still have time. And so if we're not using that time to do A, B, and C, we feel guilty.

    Rebecca Gray 21:14

    Yes. And, I mean, I think that's true from an environmentalism lens. From what I'm not a parent, but I understand that to be true about parenting, about our academic lives, our work lives, our relationships, we are constantly being pressured to produce and churn something out and move forward. But in terms of I mean, who is collectively responsible for fixing climate change, there are like 100 corporations in the world that are responsible for like 70% of climate emissions. I mean, who is responsible for climate change? It is like enormous corporations, it is the US Department of Defense, it is huge entities that are, for the most part out of our individual control. And I don't say that to be nihilistic. Because another kind of myth that I think we've been sold about climate change is that it's something that is going to happen, that's going to be catastrophic event, like at some point where we're going to go over a cliff, and suddenly life will change. But the reality of climate change is that climate change is already damaging people's health, it already takes lives every year, it is the result of it are already some people's reality, and have been people's reality. And if you are in a position to not be directly feeling it, it's probably because you are living in a place of relative privilege. And so it's not really helpful to think about it as like this doomsday kind of thing that we all have to band together before a certain point, or we're all going to get blown off the face of the earth. You can think of it as small actions in your community, smaller initiatives organizing, and kind of, what am I talking about progress over a big sweeping change?

    KC Davis 22:53

    Yeah, so when we talk about these 100, corporations, and so we recognize, okay, this is kind of where the make or break, change will happen. And I feel like there's kind of two ways in which that could change. One narrative that we're given is, if we all band together, and stop the demand of these plastics, waterways, blah, blah, blah, right? Like we all band together and stop buying water bottles, then these companies will have to change. That's one narrative that I've heard. And then the other narrative is, if we all band together, and place collective political pressure on our government, to regulate, you know, industries that are within our country's control, that is the way to go. And so I'm just curious, from your perspective, which of those narratives is more accurate? Which of those narratives should we be focusing on? Which one's more realistic?

    Rebecca Gray 23:50

    I think that they both have their place. And in terms of the first question, which kind of a boycott economy, right, let's keep our money, realizing that that is not always realistic, again, due to personal finances, what people need to live like plastic water bottles have their place, other forms of single use plastic have their place, political action, I do think is important and effective. And something that I learned working as a contractor for the EPA and the CDC, for the past four years, you know, I worked for those agencies under the Trump administration. And what was interesting is there were a lot of really good scientists and activists at those organizations doing their best to chug along and perform good science and get things done. And so I think that continuous political pressure is worthwhile. Especially, you know, we tend to think of things at the national level, what's the presidential administration doing? What is our Congress doing, but at the state and local levels as well, organizing and pressuring politicians does work and does have an impact and voting for people to put in office? Who will protect and promote programs and social services that align with your values does have an impact. And as important,

    KC Davis 25:09

    I think what the majority of people that I talked to that are really struggling when you know, they're looking at, okay, when I don't buy prepackaged food, I tend to not eat that day. Or when I, you know, my dishes pile up in the sink, my anxiety goes nuts, and I don't have the capacity to engage right now at this time without kind of like selling my mental health soul, so to speak, right? And so when these people are asking themselves, you know, what can I do? And I like how you sort of painted this picture of start with, you know, what do you need to function, and then fill in the gaps with more compatible, eco friendly behaviors that work in your life. And I also want to encourage people, you know, I think that especially when it comes to mental health disability, sometimes because we're struggling with perfectionism, we can't, by ourselves, determine what do we really need, because we're always thinking what we really need is just us being lazy, right? And so I think talking to a therapist, or a counselor, or even just a friend that you trust, allowing someone to have some input on to know, Casey, just buy some paper plates, like you need to eat, right, like letting someone else that you trust, have a voice in that conversation, because I think that we tend to have just the right amount of self loathing to say, Oh, if you, you don't really need that you're just being lazy. And a lot of times, that's not true. And so getting someone else to help you with that conversation on what adaptive routines Do I really need to live and thrive in my life? And once you sort of realize that, how can I then fill in the gaps with some eco friendly behaviors? In that moment, when we talk about how can I fill in the gaps with eco friendly behaviors? I feel as though we are sort of drawn to the boycott economy narrative as like, that's where we should go first, like, okay, how can I have less plastic? How can I do this? And those things are all good behaviors. But if it's true that the more impactful behavior might be getting involved politically to make those changes, then would you say that it's valid for a person to say if I have this limited capacity leftover, the best use of that capacity is not getting, you know, obsessive, or worrying about how much plastics in my house, but is using that energy instead? To see what's going on with my city council or something like that?

    Rebecca Gray 27:39

    Yes, I think energy is, again, it's such a limited resource. And you know, things like voting, think voting is very important. Voting takes like a lot of energy. In some states, you can't register on the same day, you might have to find time off of work, you know, find childcare, this takes a lot of energy. And like if voting and being involved politically aligned with your values, then conserving energy in order to engage with that, instead of, I don't know, cooking all week to make sure that you don't have any food waste at the end of it has value, especially I think, in terms of conserving energy, something that I find useful is to remember to conserve energy when I have it. So like, oh, it's like a Saturday afternoon, I've had my little iced coffee, I'm feeling really good. And I'm thinking to myself, Okay, it's time to clean the house top to bottom or get ahead on any other tasks, thinking to myself, What would two hours of lazing around, like do for me right now, it might do a lot, and it might give me a little bit more Go Go juice for the rest of the day or the week or whatever.

    KC Davis 28:48

    I love that. And I mean, I'm even thinking about, you know, you can even get smaller than, you know, city level. I mean, there are parents who might be able to participate in a PTA, where they can bring up, you know, is there a way we could send home digital announcements instead of paper announcements, right, where, you know, it might be that using paper plates for dinner gives you the capacity to attend a PTA meeting, where you can push for what's going to be a much bigger impact of, you know, a school, even just one school, reducing their paper usage or something like that.

    Rebecca Gray 29:26

    Absolutely. And I also think that specifically in terms of, I think, a lot of sustainability swaps center on food, like what should we be buying? What bags should we be using? How should we be cooking? What plates should we be using? And I just want to like, let everybody buddy know, give them some peace of mind from an epidemiologist. The biggest way that food impacts yours and your family's health is the importance of getting enough of it and getting enough variety. And so if eating off paper plates if ordering in if buying Less expensive produce that wasn't produced sustainably allows you to feed yourself and your family in a way that satisfying and you know, bonus if you get to meet all your nutritional needs, like that has inherent value, it's going to make our bodies more resilient to any kind of environmental stressors. This is especially important, you know, communities that are experiencing the most intense effects of climate change, are tend to be communities that are poor, that are of color that already faced food insecurity and nutritional deficiencies. And, you know, our very basic human needs of food and you know, shelter, etc. Those usurp our need to engage in environmentalism.

    KC Davis 30:41

    So when we were emailing back and forth, I was asking you sort of like, what do you view as sort of the most the actions that have the most impact and perhaps the Eco actions that have the least impact? And one of the things you said that was surprising to me, as you said, using the social programs that are available to you is one of the most impactful things you can do in terms of environmental behaviors. Can you talk about that for a minute?

    Rebecca Gray 31:03

    Yeah, sure. So when I say using social programs that are available to you, I mean, things like Medicaid, if you have any food related benefits, so snap, or chip, or WIC, these are programs that the government puts money into to make sure that your basic human needs are met, they are imperfect, and a lot of the time, they are not successful at meeting everybody's basic needs. But the government uses the amount of money spent on those programs year to year to budget for them. So essentially, if you qualify for those programs, and you use them, not only is it hopefully going to benefit yourself and your family, it's going to tell the government, okay, this community needs this investment, it's using this investment. And that's really important, especially because, again, the communities most impacted by pollution and climate change, tend to be communities that have a lot of people in them who qualify for those programs. So, you know, for example, a low income community might live near a highway, they might have higher rates of air pollution, adequate nutrition in that community is going to help make their bodies more resilient to examine environmental stressors. And making use of those programs is going to tell the government that these things that meet basic human needs need to be prioritized.

    KC Davis 32:22

    So are you saying that when we use social programs that we social sort of safety programs that we qualify for like this, that we're not just saying, Oh, this is affecting my family, but that in doing that, we're actually communicating back to the government, which communities need the most assistance, even in other areas.

    Rebecca Gray 32:42

    Sometimes, the government definitely has research initiatives, where we look at the kinds of communities and the socio economic characteristics of people who require and use services, but even more, so it will help the government to understand the needs of your personal community.

    KC Davis 33:01

    Yeah, that makes sense. Okay. And then you talked about limiting air travel.

    Rebecca Gray 33:07

    Yeah. So this is, I'm not here to tell anybody that they can't get on a plane. First of all, there are lots of good and valid reasons for air travel, you know, maybe your loved ones are far away, or I don't know, I like vacation as much as the next person. But if you are truly feeling overwhelmed, and having shame around your carbon footprint, I just am here to let you know that all of the little actions day to day that you may engage in are really barely making a dent against the amount of carbon that is emitted from taking a single flight. So if you can find opportunity, if you're really looking for environmental behaviors, to engage in finding opportunities to forego air travel, is, it's a lot of bang for your buck.

    KC Davis 33:52

    I love that. So it's not something to necessarily beat yourself up over if you're taking airplanes. But it's a lot of bang for your buck in terms of I'm having a really hard time functioning this year. And if I could just replace one vacation that we would travel on an airplane with a road trip to a closer location, then maybe that gives somebody sort of the sigh of relief of I'm doing my part. And now I can just kind of focus on getting kind of surviving the rest of the year. Yeah, absolutely.

    Rebecca Gray 34:23

    It's really just, again, give yourself that peace of mind if you are experiencing intense shame or intense guilt, because I don't know, you talk a lot in your content about how those feelings don't actually lead us to functionality or productivity. So any tool in the toolbox to combat guilt and shame. I'm a fan of

    KC Davis 34:45

    Yeah. And then in terms of the behaviors that have the least amount of impact, you talk about, you know how some conservation behaviors are just naturally rewarding. But, you know, your approach to environmentalism is really Human health focus. And so I love that you talk about giving people permission to prioritize their own health and happiness. You talk about that, too. I mean, we've kind of been talking about that the whole time. But

    Rebecca Gray 35:10

    yeah, absolutely. I think in terms of behaviors that have the least impact, again, like I mentioned, any time that you are feeling that little Goblin and your brand, say, I need to go out and buy this thing. In order to be more sustainable, I need to buy this jar, I need to buy this water bottle, etc. Just take a breath, and ask yourself, Do I already own something that could fulfill that purpose, like plastic takeout containers, I mean, like things in your house, they don't have to look photogenic, it does not have to look like a zero waste Instagram page in order to be sustainable. So I would say like, you know, rushing out or to like buy sustainable fashion pieces, which I have been guilty of in the past, like, it's okay to just wear your fast fashion pieces that you own, and you love they're already made. You're not creating waste by doing that. And I think, again, in terms of honoring your own health and well being while engaging in environmentalism, when you think about a behavior just clocking, am I feeling excited about this? Does it feel doable and accessible to me? Or is it giving me a really bad feeling in my gut of like, I already know that I'm not going to be able to sustain this commitment. And I'm already experiencing shame about it, I would invite everybody to just take a deep breath and ask themselves, why am I feeling this? antagonizing shame? It's probably related to barriers in your life, either due to circumstance or your health or your identities and releasing yourself. Easier said than done. Right. Okay.

    KC Davis 36:44

    The other thing that you said was was so great, you said if the government is allowed to consider practically when setting environmental health regulations, then you're allowed to do the same when thinking about your own behavior. So the government is asking themselves questions like, can I afford this? Can we do this program and still be able to do the other programs we need? And so your point is kind of like, you know, you as a person get those same sort of Li ways?

    Rebecca Gray 37:12

    Yeah, absolutely. Again, I work on setting drinking water guidelines for the EPA. And on every project, every drinking water guideline, we have a dedicated team of economists saying, what is it going to take to enforce this? Can we reasonably ask people to do this? Can we follow through? Again? Do we have the money? Those are questions that you are allowed to ask yourself? And the answer is allowed to be? No,

    KC Davis 37:36

    it's okay, if you do not embody the archetype of eco warrior.

    Rebecca Gray 37:41

    That is okay. I don't know that any of us ever do. So.

    KC Davis 37:46

    Awesome. Well, I love everything that you've said, I think this picture of seeing sort of eco friendly behaviors as a buffet, where, you know, you can pick and choose ones that are complementary to your life that match your capacity at the time. And even if there's a period of time where somebody is truly focusing on surviving, you know, your period of survival is not going to make or break us

    Rebecca Gray 38:16

    know, also, in service of that, when you're going through your period of survival. There are other people out there that are remembering their reusable bags and not using the paper plates. And, you know, maybe your circumstances change at some point, and you're able to engage with those behaviors. Maybe they don't, that's also fine.

    KC Davis 38:33

    And for me, I feel like that motive would work even better to me where it's like, okay, if I have the opportunity to, like, do the extra thing, being like, you know what, I'm going to do the extra thing today, you know, so that someone out there can eat that pre packaged salad. That's what they need.

    Rebecca Gray 38:49

    Yeah, exactly. And I like, I don't know, something that I've noticed in your closing duties videos you're like, and the last thing I do for closing duties to set myself up for success is I brew cold brew, because I want that in the morning. But then sometimes you're like, actually, I was surviving. And I decided I'm gonna get Starbucks tomorrow. Yeah. And then living in peace with that decision. Getting Starbucks on Friday allows you to, again, maybe then you have the energy to make your coffee at home the rest of the week.

    KC Davis 39:16

    Awesome. Well, Rebecca, thank you so much for spending the time with us. And is there anything that you want to say in closing?

    Rebecca Gray 39:24

    Oh, gosh, I would love for everybody to just let themselves a little bit more off the hook, then. I think we are inclined to do just take a deep breath. It's okay. I feel like as an environmental scientist, sometimes it feels like taboo to say like, it's okay. But it is and taking care of yourself is okay and allowed.

    KC Davis 39:47

    We have better things to do today then hate ourselves over a bag of clothes. We can't manage to get to the donation bin.

    Rebecca Gray 39:53

    We absolutely do. So many better things.

    KC Davis 39:56

    Awesome. Well, thank you Rebecca, so much

KC Davis
02: Q&A: Too much self compassion?

Welcome to another episode of Struggle Care! In our first episode, you heard my conversation with Dr. Lesley Cook about executive functioning. Because she has so much great information and wisdom to share, I decided to bring her back to discuss self-compassion. Is it a bad thing to have TOO MUCH self-compassion? Join us for the conversation with Dr. Lesley!

Dr. Lesley Cook is a psychologist who does a lot of work with ADHD and other neurodivergencies. Born and raised in Hawaii, she now lives in Virginia and works with children, adolescents, adults, couples, and families. 

Show Highlights:

  • How to find the balance between the message of self-compassion and the need for better life management and progress

  • A basic understanding of self-compassion from Dr. Kristin Neff’s writings

  • A closer look at shame and how we experience it in relation to self-compassion

  • How to gently shift shame into self-compassion

  • How self-compassion can become a learned behavior that we pass down to our children

Resources: 

Connect with Dr. Lesley: TikTok and Instagram

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

  • KC Davis 0:10

    Hello, you sentient balls of startups. This is struggle care, the podcast that will eventually get a tagline. It doesn't have one now. But you're you're, you're good here. We're happy you're here. Anyways, I'm KC Davis. And welcome back. I've got Dr. Leslie cook with me, psychologist extraordinaire. And we've just been rolling through some Q and A's that I get into my inbox into my comment section. And most of y'all know that I'm a therapist. And so we're just putting our little psychology heads together. And I have a couple of questions here. Leslie, thank you for coming back. First of all,

    Lesley PsyD 0:47

    yeah, thanks for having me.

    KC Davis 0:48

    Okay, so I want to roll through a few questions here about like ADHD and kids, because I know you have a lot of experience with that. I want to start with this one. Well, this one's not about kids, but it's just in general. Okay. It says, Do eight, does being on ADHD meds actually help with everyday life, like running a household? Or is it more useful for academic type focusing?

    Lesley PsyD 1:08

    That's a fantastic question. I don't know that I've ever been asked that question in that way. So the answer is a general Yes, with a lot of caveats. So ADHD medications are in different classes, usually, people are talking about stimulant medication. So we'll talk about that, at least at first. One very oversimplified way to think about stimulant meds is that they help to wake up the parts of the brain that function like a brake pedal. So without those medications, sometimes ADHD feels like having a wonky brake, where sometimes it works. And sometimes it doesn't. But it really doesn't work when you need it to work. And that does not end well. So stimulant meds have wake up the part of the brain that lets us break or not break when we want to. So in general, yes, it will help you. If you're a good candidate for that, that medication, it will help you focus what more when you want to, and it will help you have less, usually less anxiety about what you're going to choose to attend to. So instead of having to do that manually, and think about things, you may find it easier to say, it makes sense for me to do this first and this second.

    KC Davis 2:23

    That's a good answer. I can really only answer from my personal experience, because I actually got on stimulant medication. When I was a stay at home mom. So like, I wasn't going to a job, or work or school or anything like that. And I can say that, for me, the main thing that it did for me what will two parts one was like task initiation. And like, energy, like I wouldn't say motivation necessarily, because like you and I have talked before, like, motivation is about like understanding the value of something like wanting to do something. This was more like, it was almost like now I'm excited that I'm gonna get this thing done. And I'm able to do it. And the difference for me was very much like, before I was on meds, I'd be sitting on my chair. And I'd be like, I need to get up and do the dishes. And I'd be like, I need to I need to, but it felt like the transition from sitting in the chair to like getting up to the dishes was like walking through mud. And it also felt like I couldn't like forecast with enough tangible illness. What the reward of getting the dishes done would feel like, does that make sense? I was like I could know cognitively like yes, I'll probably feel better. But it wasn't real to me, compared to how stuck and inert I felt sitting in the chair.

    Lesley PsyD 3:56

    Yeah. And I gave you a little bit of the clinical answer first and then you give this lovely real world experience. So I'll tell you that as a person that takes stimulant meds, the more fun answer is I can do the dishes when I take my medicine without feeling I don't know another way to describe it besides like mental agony. Yeah, without medication, every task in doing the dishes is its own task. And it's so difficult to just make my brain stay because it doesn't I guess it doesn't just believe that this is going to be finished. And my medication helps me just do it. It helps me be in my body and do the task and not have all of the things with it. So for me it quiets my mind more than anything else.

    KC Davis 4:42

    I also this image of like if you've ever tried to pull like a sled over concrete, like I'm from Dallas, Texas, and we never get any snow but every time we would get like an eighth of snow I would like demand my dad took me out on the sled and so like even though the the snow Like the ground is white, you would just all you could hear was just like or have been like pulling this metal sled over concrete. And that's what it feels like to like get myself up and moving towards like a thing I need to do. Whereas when I take for me, I take Vyvanse, when I take a stimulant Med, it's, it's like I'm suddenly on. I'm a cart on greased, like rails. And it just slides like the transition from getting up to getting to the it just slides. And I'm able this is like a weird part for me. But I'm able to forecast, like, viscerally the reward that I'm going to feel once it's done. And that feels motivating. Does that make sense? Like that makes me want to get up. So it's not just I need to get up, I've got to get it's like, I want to get this done. And I can make myself stand up and go do it. And that's kind of my experience. And what's interesting also is that when I first got on, I was told like the old line of like, you need to take your tolerance breaks. So it'd be good to take it like try not to take it on the weekends. Which is like, I first of all, I love my psychiatrist, and I don't think my psychiatrist is misogynistic at all. However, I think that old line that just gets passed down about taking breaks on the weekends is like such a patriarchal, stupid piece of advice. Because you know, who gets to rest, you know, who doesn't need to be productive on weekends? Men? If anything, I needed more on the weekends. Yeah, absolutely. Like, that's when especially now like I actually am working nine to five, but like, the weekends is where I have my kids all day, it's where I need to make a 9000 Snacks is where I need to reset the whole house and get the laundry done and, like, pack us up to go do something fun. Like that's it? So the answer to that question is yes, yes. Okay. And that's also by the way, why it makes me so mad when I hear people say that they tried to talk to their psychiatrist about meds? And the answer was, well, you're not in school, so you don't need them. That makes me furious. Okay, number two, how can an ADHD parent adjust to all the routines and requirements of having kids in school?

    Lesley PsyD 7:21

    Rule number one is self compassion. When when we're trying to make movement, as an ADHD person, we're gonna take as a given the premise that days will be different, that there isn't one goal we're trying to get to where we've mastered ADHD and life is always going to be good part of this diagnosis is understanding that things are going to be harder and easier, depending on the day.

    KC Davis 7:48

    You mean, I can't just aim for the perfect morning routine. And that will fix all my problems.

    Lesley PsyD 7:52

    No, or the or the best planner or the best token system for your kids. So it's an unsatisfying answer, I think for some, but it's very, very true, that part of really moving from one phase of life into another with this diagnosis, is also bringing with us the understanding that it's going to be easier and harder. I think the other thing to think about when you're transitioning to parenthood is what is already working for you and bring that into your parenting. So if it works for you to be slightly disorganized during the day, and then on the weekends reorganize. Don't try to become a Pinterest mom, tomorrow when you have a baby. Stay with what works. Invite yourself to be curious about how you can apply what's already happening and going okay, in your parenting.

    KC Davis 8:44

    Yeah, I also I'm thinking like I was talking to some moms last night, and they were talking about feeling overwhelmed by the amount of things that need to be like signed and filled out. And we were talking about the suggestion and their kids are a little bit older, the suggestion of like, putting a folder on the wall somewhere, and then being like, it's you're like, Okay, kiddos, it's your responsibility to like, put your papers into this. And then every day at seven, you know, I'll go through and sign it. But I'm also thinking like, because I just went through this, I just put both of my kiddos into school. And it's like the amount of paperwork and small tasks about like, download this form and then fax it to the doctor and then text the doctor and then we'll send it back and then download it as a PDF and then upload it to the school site, which you have to use the QR code in order to get in and then set your password and then verify your email. It's like it's such a nightmare of like many tasks, like am I and I tasks. That's really hard.

    Lesley PsyD 9:43

    It's so hard. So another tip I would give people is don't be afraid to utilize your support people. If you've got folks in your life that you trust a best friend, a mother, a father and uncle a spouse who is very good at some parts of this it is okay to offload parts of it, if you're not so good with the tech, try to negotiate with your support people and don't do the tech, it's okay. You don't have to do everything. Your other point was lovely. And we also we have like a Dropbox area. So when papers come in, they're not beautifully sorted in a color coded thing on the wall, they go into one box. This is the to do box, the stuff that needs to get done. And next to it, we have a whiteboard. And so anytime someone says, Hey, Mom, by the way, I run to that whiteboard. I have a meeting on Friday after school that goes on the whiteboard, and then you're done. So really trying to make things visual and simple. Don't overthink it. Try not

    KC Davis 10:38

    to I put a lot of things on my calendar. I also love the website monday.com. Love Monday. It's like a task management one. But it's really intuitive. And what I find is that I don't do well with like different informations coming out, right. So it's like, okay, sometimes I'm getting emails from teachers, sometimes it's a notification on this app, sometimes it's a folder I'm supposed to check in or whatever. And what I find is that, as I'm going through, especially my emails, like when I'm getting school related to dues, like having that little app, that Monday app where it's like any school related to dues that I get during the day, I'm putting on that like list. And then maybe like after the kids go to bed, I can like sit down for like, if I have some uninterrupted time, it's it's easier for me to get through all the many tasks versus like trying to work and be like, oh, there's this email, or, Oh, I've got to get this form. So that might be helpful. Okay, let me let me get you another one here. Who, so I love this. So this one is about my book, How to keep house while drowning. And it says how do I teach my kids the principles in your book, I don't want them to connect worth with cleanliness. And I love this question. And I've talked a little bit about it on my channels before. But I you know, it's sort of like the great experiment that I've been doing with my kids. And I know you have kids that are older. So I just thought this would be fun to discuss shortly for a short time, which is like trying to teach I mean, here's my theory, here's my like, if I get my kids to age 18, and they have never cleaned successfully, like the way I would like them to, but they have a morally neutral relationship to care tasks. And I have taught them the skills about how to do things. That success. It's annoying, it's stressful. But it's success, because they might be 25 or 38. Right. I was like 32. When I woke up one day and went, I'd like to put systems into my house so that things are more functional. I know my mom would love that I had wished I'd done that at 16. But conversely, and I'm not saying it has to be just one way or the other. But also like, there are a lot of parenting techniques that I could use to like force behavioral compliance for my kids in areas of like tidiness and chores. But what I don't want to do is get my kid to the edge of age of 18, always having like a spic and span clean room. And then like immediately when they're out of my house, they're like, finally, I don't have to do that shit anymore. And then they don't actually have like, the relationship to care tasks where they understand like, these are functional tasks to care for myself. And then like, that's the most important skill to me. So I try to teach that to my little kids. And I have all sorts of like weird ways of doing that. But I'm just curious what your thoughts are?

    Lesley PsyD 13:44

    Well, two parts. The first is when it comes to parenting and these kind of like value building a value system, which I think is what you're talking about, mostly. That primarily comes for most kids from observation of what is being modeled. So the great news for all of you who are listening who are parents, especially of young kids is you don't have to be perfect. You just have to be you don't have to be we invite you to be kind to yourself. And here's the big part I see results with with my older kids is your language. Talk to yourself during these tasks, right. So look at your dishes and say, Well, if I do all of the plates and cups, and just rinse the other things that will be enough for tomorrow and that's okay. You don't even have to be telling your children but that helps you hear it. It helps you utilize these principles and the children will internalize these voices over time. And I can zoom you ahead because I have a 20 year old who's going into her second year of college and she is just as messy as I currently am and was at that time, but she is capable of solving crises. She is capable of asking for help when she is not doing as well. She is capable of making friendships and choosing those friendships based on whether those folks are going to echo her values. And when she has to, she can clean up really, really good. She's got the skills in there. So I would echo that, that your goal isn't to put a child out there who has a better housekeeping home, your your goal is to put a child out there that has all of the skills and abilities to exist in the world and be kind to themselves.

    KC Davis 15:31

    And one of the things that I do with my kids, and most of my kids are two and four. So if you're at that stage, you know, things that I've been trying is, I don't Institute things for my kids, or like limits or structure that seem arbitrary. So we don't have like a you have to clean up every night before you go to bed. Because that's not connected to anything in my kids brains. So what I've been doing is, now I might say you need to take all the toys back to the playroom, because mom can't function in the kitchen, if there's Paw Patrol on the floor. But I don't have a leg now everybody has to clean up their, you know, put everything back. But what I have been doing is I'll wait until I can tell that my four and a half year old is in a spot where functionally something's not working, and she recognizes it. So this will be she trips over a toy. She steps on a Lego, she can't find something she's looking for. She wants to have a dance party, but the space is too cluttered. And all y'all like jump on that moment and be like, Oh, no, you tripped. I'm so sorry. That happened. What can we do to make the space a little more functional? So we don't trip? She's like, let's clean up, right? And I'm not saying it's like some magical dust that my kids like excited to clean up. But like you said, like, my goal isn't to like make her because she then she'll say I don't want to. And it's like, alright, well, fine, keep tripping, I guess. And I will like, I never want to put out this idea that I've like just like I'm magic. Like, I will absolutely get to the point where I'm like, I'm canceling your playdate. If you don't pick the freaking Paw Patrol up, right, like I get to that point. However, I'm also like, like you said, like helping her make those connections of like, functionality of her space, directly impacting her like, right now experience. And I also clean up with my kids all the time. I think we really overestimate like, I think we both overestimate and underestimate, like what kids are capable of. Like, I still do tasks with my kid, like, I can get my four and a half year old to maybe go feed the cats by herself. But everything else she wants to do with mom. She wants to do the exact same task. So it's not. She does not help me pick things up, right? I'm always helping her. It's always me helping her. That's always what cracks me up. When people see my messy house. They're like, why don't you just teach your kids to pick up? Like I do it? What world do you live in that teaching small children? How to do care tasks? Is like less of a burden. Yeah, no, it's more work. Right? So anyways, that's what I've been doing. It's just like pointing those things out verbally. And I think that's helping. Yeah,

    Lesley PsyD 18:15

    I also love like the idea of building small things or routines into the normal rhythm of the day. That makes sense. So it's not when you get home from school, make sure you do your five chores before you go out and play. It's when you get home from school, I understand that you're going to be tired. So do what you want to do. But after dinner, if everyone could just hang around for about five minutes and pick one of we have a list that says how can I help today. And it's just got a list of random stuff. Nothing's assigned. But it's like right, pick one thing. And and when you have enough people in there functioning, even if they're little guys, if what they did is bring the cups from the table to the counter, you're building a value system, they're around help. It's also building experiences with your parents, I think we underestimate how important it is to just be around our kids for these little moments and not seeing an hour of face to face Barbie play. I'm saying five minutes of putting music on while you unload the dishwasher. These things are very impactful for a very long time.

    KC Davis 19:17

    And I also think like, I have this story that I told one time about, like my kid, she took I think she was three she took all the diapers out of her diaper box. And I was like, You need to put all of those diapers back. She was like, No, we can't. No, no, not gonna not kind of can't. And I was like, Oh, yes, you can. She was like, No, I can't. I was like, you can't your arms are broken. And we had this like, you know, like, very classic argument about it. And then she finally because I have done a few things right. She like kind of broke down and then got really vulnerable and was like, but there's so many I can't pick them all up at once. And I was like, Oh, she's not unwilling. She's overwhelmed. Yeah, absolutely. Like, it doesn't make sense to a three year old brain like When you say pick all of those up, her three year old brain hurt, literally put them all in your hands at once. So I had to break it down to like pick one up and she picked one up now pick three up, I'll be four. Now pick two what like cuz she's learning her numbers, right? teaching her like the five things tidying like, okay, we're all gonna get, we're all going to reset the space. And she's like mixtures in that phase. Everything's cool with mom. And I'm like, let's find all the trash and we put a song on and look for all the trash. Let's find all the laundry, put us on that look all the laundry. And it's not only like you said, like that moment we're having together. But I'm also like, it. I think when we talk about like teaching our kids, we default to like teaching them discipline and responsibility when it's like the bigger skill is like, how do I break down a big task intuitively into like, smaller steps that don't feel like I want to like, you know, yeah, drive off the

    Lesley PsyD 20:55

    front door. Yeah, we bathrooms are a really good example for my kids. So growing up, I used to have the written list of the steps, which is still helpful for some kids. And some kids will actually write it in whiteboard marker on the mirror. I don't know if people know you can do that. And it just wipes right off. Now what I have them do even the older kids, even the 16 year old, I'll say do the bathroom and they say great what first and I'll be like Mears that's the blue bottle, right? Yep. And then they'll come back. Okay, toilet, that's this thing, okay, and then they'll come back. So there's support there, they don't have to hold all that information and working memory like you we have music on. It's a cooperative tasks are not alone, right. That's another piece of this too, is that children, even adolescents aren't just little grown folks, they get more easily overwhelmed. So for you and I cleaning a bathroom might be just one or two tasks. But them knowing that you're right here with them, can help break down that anxiety, which can lead to that escape avoidance behavior that parents tend to really parents I'm pointing at myself, tend to get frustrated with because we're tired.

    KC Davis 22:02

    And then can you walk us through you had a really great video one time on your tic toc channel about helping your son clean his room, and you had like a really unique approach to it. Can you tell us about that?

    Lesley PsyD 22:16

    Yeah, so we have a couple of approaches, and I let him pick the approach every time but the one he usually picks is that we take everything that's on the floor, and we throw it out into the hallway indiscriminately. And then whatever's left in the room, we just set it up really quick. So it looks nice. Now that's very easy, because most of the stuff is on the floor. They're not on surfaces. So the room with all the junk in the hallway, the room looks great, it looks finished. So he already within 10 minutes feels accomplished. Then we put again, we put music on not everybody or sometimes a YouTube video. And basically we sit together and we bring items back in that we want in the room. And we put them where they go. So I'll be like airplane. Yes, I want that. Okay, cool. Where was where would airplane live? Oh airplane could live here. And then we'd put it there. A lot of times as he's getting older, we don't need this as much. But I also would limit that. So we would do 10 minutes. And then yes, there would still be a pile in the hallway. And sometimes that pile would be there the next day. But pretty much because there's not a lot of anxiety about it, it was more of a fun task, we would move through it pretty quick.

    KC Davis 23:21

    I love that I also love like, what I was talking in a different episode about how when I need to do a task, I often like overestimate how much time it's gonna take. And I know cognitively that it's gonna feel good when it's done. But I can't like really viscerally. See it in my mind's eye enough to be like, Mm, it's worth it. And I feel like getting the room to that like space where it looks really nice. Everything's super functional. It's like immediate gratification of like, oh, yeah, I do like this. I do like this. Because there's nothing more overwhelming and defeating to me than trying to clean up a room or tidy up a room where I'm just like picking up one item at a time. And trying to put it away somewhere. And like my brain doesn't see any progress.

    Lesley PsyD 24:12

    Yeah, and I think doing it in this way. And so for for adults, this is kind of the bulldozing method that I've used before where I take everything on the floor and put it into one corner. It's more of a treasure hunt than your room is already clean, like I clean my room. And now I get to hunt through this pile of stuff for things that I want. So instead of this deficit model of I'm trying to climb this hill, it's Oh, I love this shirt. I forgot I had this shirt. I'm gonna put this shirt away. I think it's just really about rewriting the story of what taking care of your space is about. It's not about resetting it so it looks pretty. It's about liking the things that you have, and being able to locate them frankly and use them when you want to.

    KC Davis 24:55

    I love that. Okay, here's what I'm going to end with and it's not a question it just is Just a comment, which made me laugh not at this person, but just laugh because it was, frankly funny. So, if you don't know, I did a tech talk video where I said, Hey, like, what questions do you all want me to answer? This one says, my mental health is a dumpster fire.

    Lesley PsyD 25:18

    There's no question. We all just nod slowly in agreement, like,

    KC Davis 25:28

    yes, I've been there. Not to you. Yeah. Welcome. I love it. Okay, we've got about four more minutes before I'm going to allow you to leave. I'm going to take this whole time. We don't have enough time to answer this in full. But this is my tricky way of trying to get you to come back and answer more questions with me. Okay, where's it? Where's it? Where's it? Just because, okay, it says, Before the pandemic i have i Okay, let's start, let me start off. Before the pandemic, I had a whole life before 6am workout read journal emails, I quote unquote, earned my sunrise. And now I cannot get out of bed before 7am.

    Lesley PsyD 26:21

    Interesting. I feel the same way. But my brain doesn't frame it as I can't get out of bed before 7am. I think my brain frames that that my values have been realigned. The pandemic was a scary time for a lot of us. Even if we felt like we weren't physically at risk. It was dysregulated and disruptive. And it changed who we are and what we think about our time. And so I guess I would invite people to consider the fact that maybe that shift is in your favor. Maybe that's okay. And that even if you do return to doing things at 6am, I'm kind of pulling back that way. Now, it's by choice. It's not because we're needing to earn it, it's because we've decided that we want to do it that way, because we like it better.

    KC Davis 27:11

    That's what really stood out to me. And I would bet you money that that phrase, earn your sunrise is from some motivational, Tony Robbins esque speaker out there, which we could get into a whole episode about how I feel about those sorts of gurus. Because you're right, you do not have to earn your sunrise, you don't have to earn your sunsets, you don't have to earn any of that. And doing those things before sunrise is great if that is great for you. But I have always detested how sort of commercial self help has put this huge emphasis on like the moral superiority of waking up early. Like there's so many self help books out there that like when you really get down to like their quote unquote, advice. It's like wake up early. Like, I don't want to, I'm not going to, I have my entire life and continue to roll out of bed at the last second. And that doesn't make me like less productive than other people. It doesn't mean it's not about willpower. Like I quite literally just have a different brain and body. And there's no difference between doing something at five and doing something at 10pm. Unless there is a functional difference for you and you're enjoying it, enjoying it that way. Like I just really want to invite everyone who has been either trying to make themselves like an early morning earlier or sunrise person that like you can just stop. It's okay if you like it if it works for you keep doing it. But I just want the rest of us to stop feeling this like weird subtle shame about the fact that we don't wake up early and I don't want to.

    Lesley PsyD 28:56

    I am in agreement. 100%

    KC Davis 29:00

    So, well, once again, thank you for being here. Do you want to plug yourself real quick where people can find more of your excellent tidbits?

    Lesley PsyD 29:07

    Sure. I'm on Tik Tok at LesleyPsyD. And I'm on Instagram, although less frequently at Leslie Le s le y underscore PsyD, and I'd love to see you stop by

    KC Davis 29:20

    awesome and you guys know where to find me at domestic blisters on Tik Tok at struggle care on Instagram. And you can also check out my website struggle care.com

    Lesley PsyD 29:29

    Thank you

KC Davis
01: Executive Functioning with Lesley PsyD

Today, we are diving into executive functioning, which is a popular term being bounced around in mental health communities. I want to take a closer look at what it means and how it shows up in people’s lives. Join me to learn more from today’s guest!

Dr. Lesley Cook is a psychologist who does a lot of work with ADHD and other neurodivergencies. Born and raised in Hawaii, she now lives in Virginia and works with children, adolescents, adults, couples, and families. Dr. Lesley and I met on TikTok, and I’m happy to have her here today!

Show Highlights:

  • A common-language definition and explanation of executive functioning

  • How executive function deficits show up in someone’s life

  • How shame, guilt, and inconsistent performance are clues to executive function problems

  • The difference between motivation and task initiation

  • Why the underlying issue with lack of motivation is more about what a person values

  • How a person’s sense of self is affected when they believe their authentic self is “bad”

  • Why external supports are necessary when an internal system is down

  • Why rhythm is better than routine for those with executive function disorder

  • How neurotypical people experience interruptions with executive functioning on a regular basis because of overload and anxiety

  • How blips in executive function occur in neurotypical people with predictability and response to intervention—as opposed to someone with a diagnosis

  • How someone with ADHD can have incredible deficits in executive function on days when everything is going their way–and won’t respond reliably to normal interventions

  • How to build into each day differing levels of acceptable outcomes–and give yourself permission to choose what fits your needs at that moment

  • Lesley’s advice to those who think they have executive functioning issues

Resources: 

Connect with Dr. Lesley: TikTok and Instagram

Connect with KC: TikTok and Instagram

Get KC's Book, How to Keep House While Drowning

Find great resources about executive functioning: 

 www.understood.org, www.psychologytoday.com, and www.chaad.org

  • KC Davis 0:03

    Hello, you sentient balls of stardust. I'm KC Davis. And this is struggle care, the mental health podcast that promises never to tell you to journal. today. I'm in the studio with psychologist Leslie cook. And we are talking about executive functioning. So pull up a chair, use this time to do something kind for yourself and enjoy the conversation. Hello, you sentient balls of stardust, welcome. I'm so excited for this episode, because I have Dr. Leslie Cook, who is a psychologist, and she does a lot of work with ADHD and other neurodivergent sees and actually met her on Tik Tok. So Leslie, thank you for being here.

    Lesley PsyD 0:42

    Thank you for having me, this is really exciting for me, because I feel the same way about you and your content. So this is going to be a great talk.

    KC Davis 0:51

    Oh, I'm so excited. So I wanted specifically for us to talk about executive functioning, because I feel like it's a real buzzword right now. Or buzz words, sort of floating around the mental health community. And I really wanted to learn more about it, I have such sort of like a cursory knowledge of it as a therapist, but I have heard you in your content, talk about executive functioning. And I just thought, you know, this is someone who I really want to sort of pick their brain, about the way that executive functioning shows up in people's lives and the way that it relates to trying to do everyday care tasks.

    Lesley PsyD 1:29

    Yeah, I think that this is an area that is both extremely exciting for me that people care about, because I don't think it would have been a buzzword a year or two ago. So that makes me happy. But I also love that we're going to talk about how it applies, you know, both to people with diagnoses, but also just to folks in general, because if you have a central nervous system, you have to use these functions on a daily basis.

    KC Davis 1:51

    So what's interesting is that I used to run a family program for a drug rehab. And one of the things that we would talk about was about how we had this little Did y'all ever do this, it was like the hand, like made the fist to talk about like the different parts of the brain. Yep. And we'd be like, Okay, this is the brainstem by your wrist and your little thumb coming over is sort of the seat of like the instincts and the fight or flight. And then your prefrontal cortex is the front. Except when I was talking about that to clients and families, what I was focusing on was actually the fight or flight aspect of it, and talking about how when your fight or flight gets triggered, you kind of go, your frontal cortex goes offline. And since that's the part of our brain responsible for impulse control, and sort of cause and effect, it would help families and clients think about how when they're feeling really activated, whether in therapy or just in the world, how all of these amazing coping skills that they're learning in rehab might temporarily go offline. So I really focused on talking to them about that part of the brain kind of getting hijacked, focusing on the fight or flight. But now that I've been diagnosed with ADHD, and I've been doing this work around helping people who have functional barriers, deal with care tasks around their home, for the first time, I'm starting to want to learn more about that frontal lobe, that part that's going offline, like, what all is that responsible for? So I wanted to start I send you like, kind of six questions. And I would love to hear you describe executive functioning for a layperson, like someone who doesn't know any type of psychological terminology or therapeutic language.

    Lesley PsyD 3:34

    Yeah, this is actually something that I am continuing to hone, because it's really hard to translate. It's really complex. So hopefully, this will be easy to understand. And thank you Disney feel like I should be paying them for the movie Inside Out. The best image I can think so as I talk through this, a good visual image is that control panel inside of the main character's brain. So there is the what are the behavior that she's engaging in, which is more choice based in that movie, then there's the emotions, and they have an effect on the control panel, but they're not the control panel themselves. So executive functions are these eight core functions of that control panel that tell our body, how to do things when why, to what extent when to stop. And here's the list of them. There are abilities to inhibit, like, stop ourselves, to shift from one thing to another. Controller emotions, start a behavior, remember things as we're learning them, how to plan and organize, how to monitor what we're doing in the middle of it, and how to monitor how we're feeling about what we're doing. So you can imagine how complex this control panel is. Wow.

    KC Davis 4:47

    Yeah. A lot. That's like, I feel like when you describe those eight functions as a therapist, that's like everything that I'm trying to teach someone is like how do we be are aware of our emotions? How do we regulate our emotions? How do we think through things? That is such a great, great summary, it almost kind of gives me like the visual of like a dam. And you know how you can like open the dam a little or you can open the dam a lot. But like that dam is really in control of what is coming and going, and in what amount, whether it's attention, or feelings or emotions. And so I could definitely see how like if somebody's control panel is shorting out, or someone's dam isn't like letting in or out the right amounts of things. Why that would make life so complicated.

    Lesley PsyD 5:37

    Yeah, incredibly, so in for diagnoses, like ADHD, it's like those emotions showing up to work every day in Riley's brain. And somebody's like, a shift is down today. Oh, man. All right, Colin, task monitoring, he'll have to work an extra shift. And you really can't predict like what's going to be offline or on line on a given day. So you can imagine how that would not only make your day difficult, but also would affect emotions in the opposite direction, then you get frustrated that you can't shift when you need to.

    KC Davis 6:07

    So what does it look like when somebody has issues with executive function like when there are disruptions? So that control panel like, how does that show up in someone's life? Like, What would someone have to tell you like in a session to make you go, I wonder if there's some executive functioning issues here.

    Lesley PsyD 6:23

    So a lot of the time, the first way that shows up is people expressing how bad they are at something. So I always get curious when someone says, you know, I know that my difficulty, like losing things is really impacting my life. But I'm just so terrible at that. That's usually some kind of note to me to ask more questions. Because if you were just terrible at that, you probably would never do it. Usually when that shame kicks in of like, look at this part of me that so bad, I'm not doing well, it's because you feel like you should be able to, or you feel like, you know, I can on this day. So maybe it's just my effort. So whenever I hear shame and guilt in there, I'll ask more. And there's a difference between not being great at a skill, and then having an actual executive function disturbance. So I am not great in developing physical systems to organize my stuff. But I am fantastic at developing tracking systems for my work. If I'm great at developing tracking systems from my work, then my tracking system should work every day, but they don't system. So that's the second factor is inconsistent performance, even with effort and energy,

    KC Davis 7:36

    which is interesting, because I think that somebody who is experiencing inconsistent performance like that, that's the reason why they assume that they must just be lazy, because they go to work. And they never miss, you know, a work call, they're on top of what they need to do at work. And then they came come home, and can't seem to motivate or activate themselves to do the dishes in the laundry. And they're confused, because they're like, it's the same skills, I'm going to work and I'm seeing what needs to be done. And I'm doing it. But then I come home, I see what needs to be done. And I can't seem to do it.

    Lesley PsyD 8:11

    I would add to that, that when I see clients in my office that present with that kind of concept, they're even harder on themselves, I hear, I can go to work and manage a multimillion dollar contract, but I can't do my laundry. So they also kind of push these care tasks down in important importance in their life somehow, like I should be able to do this, it's so much easier. But it's not really laundry is about 15 different tasks. And so that's another thing that I'll look for is when they say I'm good in this environment, but I'm terrible over here, that's usually a sign that there's something else going on.

    KC Davis 8:46

    Yeah, and I totally see that too. We especially the comments that I sometimes get off tic TOCs was just clean as you go, just put it in the dishwasher, just do your laundry, because for people whose executive functioning is firing on all cylinders, like they don't recognize that they're actually doing 12 different steps and utilizing eight different skills to do something like their brain has automated that to the degree where it feels like a simple, non complex task,

    Lesley PsyD 9:15

    if there was something that came up the most, that is the bit of information that's really helpful I found for family members who don't experience executive function problems is that because you don't perceive that you're doing 15 tasks, does not mean that you're not doing them, it means that your neurology showed up to support your motivation. Those are two different things. You can't motivate yourself into better executive function you can't

    KC Davis 9:40

    fascinating and you know, one of the questions that I had, and we'll sort of skip around just because coming up is I want to kind of talk about the difference between motivation versus task initiation. Because those things I think, get confused and I think there's a lot of people showing up to their therapists office saying, I'm just not motivated. I'm just not motivated. And I think a lot of therapists are getting curious about what does that mean? What does that look like? So they're jumping right to sort of interventions that can help with motivation, when the actual issue is task initiation. So can you talk about the difference between those two things?

    Lesley PsyD 10:15

    Sure, motivation is either the desire to do something or the acknowledgement that it's really something that would be good if it gets done now. So it's more of a sensation than anything else. Motivation is a feeling, look at that pile of laundry. So even though that's full of dread, that's motivation, I'm not looking at the pile of laundry going. And I really love that that is an art sculpture, I hope that never goes anywhere. Which is might be true, that's where I've reached that level in my life. But motivation can be positive, or, you know, I hate to use negative, but it can have a distressing component. But then there's the behavior of task initiation. And actually, that is even multiple tasks in itself. So the signal to the body to move for individuals who do not have ADHD, or other forms of executive function disturbance, the motivation is followed by activity to that motor cortex almost immediately, they think it they do it, they just do it, and they don't have to tell themselves to do it. Anyone who has depression or significant anxiety, or ADHD knows the feeling of staring at the task and saying, move, get, move your leg, just move a foot, just do something. So there's a disruption there, the motivation is not leading to the body moving, and then we have to fight to get up. And so task initiation goes from what should be a seamless reflex almost, to a mountain to climb. And that can be incredibly distressing in itself and make us feel real bad about ourselves. It's interesting,

    KC Davis 11:43

    because what you're describing sounds exactly like what I described when I first got on Vyvanse, where I said, all of the sudden, the transition from sitting in a chair, to getting up to do the laundry was seamless, like the rails had been greased, it was not a hard transition to make. Whereas before, I would sit in the chair and think about how I needed to do the laundry. But I just so badly, either didn't want to or couldn't get up. And it took a long time to almost talk myself into and create. And I had to come up with all of these methods of creating momentum, so that I could get myself to go do the laundry. The other thing that reminds me of so most of my career was an addiction. And I have totally had those conversations with clients where it was a lack of motivation. And the way that they describe it is I don't care, I don't care that the laundry is not done. And sometimes it's really frustrating because you're sometimes talking about addiction, or you're talking about something unsanitary. And the poor families are like how could you not care? How could you not care that you're dying? How could you not care that you're not taking care of yourself? How could you not care that you have dirty clothes, and you smell and they would literally say I just I don't care, I can't make myself care, I feel complete apathy, when I think about those tasks, or they say, I don't think that I deserve those things. And so I have no motivation to do them. And that, for me really helped realize, oh, so motivation, a lack of motivation. And you can correct me on this shows up more like apathy.

    Lesley PsyD 13:18

    Yeah, lack of motivation is the best way that I can think about it is motivation is a sensation, it's not an action. It's just something that you feel. And so there's probably 1000 different versions of motivation, you can be slightly motivated, you can be not motivated at all. But what I see a lot when I have clients with actual motivational issues, is that they can convince me all day long, why they should do something. But then when we get down to it, and I say, Do you want to do this? Is this something you want in your life? They'll kind of exhale and be like, No, and I don't understand that. Like, what does that mean about me? And it's okay, we can deal with motivational issues. There's interventions for that. But confusing, the two really leads to a shame and guilt cycle.

    KC Davis 14:03

    Yeah. And a lot of times, especially around care tasks, when people talk about, you know, I just struggle with the motivation to do XYZ. And maybe it's something like clean my room. And sometimes it's a task initiation sheet, right? I want it clean, I function better when it has some order. But when I look at all the things there are I get overwhelmed. I don't know where to start, I get distracted. I have overwhelming emotions. But sometimes when people say, Oh, I can't find the motivation to do it. When you get really curious, you find that it is an actual value issue. Actually, I don't value a cleanroom I only think I should value it because of the way that I was raised. But I function fine and a messy room. And so sometimes you find that the motivation is about what you value and you just, you don't actually value that thing. You just feel like you're supposed to or that's what good people are supposed to value You

    Lesley PsyD 15:00

    that is exactly why in all of my interventions related to this, the first question I asked someone is, if no one was watching, and no one could say anything to you about this, how would you do this? Just you and people, not only have most of them have never even allowed themselves to think about it that way. But usually, there's a big realization at that point, oh, I think if it was up to me, I would probably just leave all the laundry in the laundry room, I wouldn't be moving stuff all over the house. And so then we say, alright, so if that's what your brain wants, can't we just build a system around that? So you don't have to fight yourself?

    KC Davis 15:36

    Yes. And I think, you know, one of the pillars of struggle care that I talked about is that shame is the enemy of functioning, and how shame can create short term compliance or short term change, but it doesn't really create long term change, nor does it create or sustain any type of intrinsic motivation. And I think it's what you said exactly about, at some point, you're alone. And shame is always about what someone else thinks of you, or the fear that you won't be accepted. Or, you know, I'm full of shame, because I'm a piece of shit, I'm a bad person, I'm not lovable, I'm not good enough. And that all has to do with the need for belonging and acceptance in your tribe. But if your tribes not around all the time, like you're going to default to whatever motivational or initiation issues are there. And so the shame doesn't work. And as someone who went to long term residential behavior modification for 18 months, you know, I was on point I followed every rule, I did really well, like I won, I won the game. And I functioned really well, when there was constant. outside pressure outside, it was like having an external control panel, right, there was always an external pressure, and external accountability. You know, these rules, regulations, structure, peer pressure monitoring. And once I left, although I did learn lots of great things there, there were so many things that was like, Oh, I'm two days in, and I'm not getting up at the crack of dawn and doing chores and doing all these things that were so easy for me when I was in structure.

    Lesley PsyD 17:17

    And I think that what that in both of those examples in your example of leaving that highly structured environment and the other example of people having what they often describe to me as relapses when no one's around, what's really happening in those moments is that people are returning to what is authentic, and guilt and shame causes us to interpret authenticity as bad. So imagine what that does to our sense of self, when being who we truly are, is the bad way to be. How do you escape that?

    KC Davis 17:47

    Yeah, well, and then you carry it into every relationship, because no matter how much someone says, they love you, no matter how much praise or validation, you get, there's always this voice inside your head that says, if you only knew, and what's interesting, you know, kind of going back to talking about the way we show up at work, the hardest job I ever had, was working at a restaurant, I worked at a really high end restaurant for Hillstone Restaurant Group, and they ran their waitstaff, like a boot camp. I mean, I can't even describe to you like everything was very regimented. Everything from like, you had to memorize certain abbreviations, you could only walk into the kitchen and one door, you had to have things in your hand, as you left the door, you had to put drinks on the table, within 30 seconds food on the table, within 10 minutes. Everything was highly, highly regimented. And so as you're going through your shift, you're having to multitask, prioritize, work with your working memory. And I was excellent at that job. But there was this structure there, there was this external structure, and there were all of these other people. They're doing it with me. And I think it's so fascinating how there are environments in which my executive functioning can fire on all cylinders. And then I can go home and look around my home and not be able to sort of turn everything back on. And I will assume it must be because I'm not trying hard enough. It must be because I'm not good enough, as opposed to, there is an obvious environmental difference between work and home.

    Lesley PsyD 19:23

    Absolutely. And that's what we talk about as, as clinicians who work with people with executive function disturbance, and in this case, especially ADHD is that if our internal structure is inconsistent, and we know that then we need to build external supports. So if we do that, right, that's not good. And then we shift that if we do that, effectively, that in a way that works for us, we do it so that it enhances our view of ourselves because if we notice that our control panel shift button is down that day, we can complement it with other external support. So we can utilize that concept or really well, I think what happens is, we don't teach people about this, when they're well, we're not teaching children and teens about executive function. So we have all of these assumptions, I can do it at work, but not at home. That must mean I don't care as much about my home, well, no work is set up perfectly for you, you've got all these external supports that help you so that no matter what function is down, you've got a compensatory strategy. And I find that that's a lot of your work that I witnessed and have on a daily basis, is you're really helping people figure out where you know what system is down for them, and how not just individual solutions, but how to think about yourself and your environment, to provide your own external support that goes with you from place to place well,

    KC Davis 20:43

    and I find that so many of the resources that talk about like running your home, and setting up systems and routines are very intimidating, because there's like, you know, 9000 checklists for the day, and it's really all consuming. And I think that we can write those things off as if no, no, no, those things are for people who have their shit together. Those are for healthy people that are on top of it, that are using those kinds of strategies, as opposed to I mean, and you see this too, with like, when you watch the TIC TOCs, about people like restocking their pantry, like when you look at the all the clear containers, and that like that gets written off as Oh, that's something Pinterest moms do. But in reality, there's some real functionality to having clear canisters where you can see things and having a time of the week where you restock everything. It's just that we sometimes I think need help making those systems accessible. And so it reminds me of when I started having a cleaning schedule, I always said no, I'm not going to do that. And then I started one and I really call it a care tasks at schedule. And it's literally one thing a day just one like I do laundry every Monday. On Tuesdays, I restock bathrooms. On Wednesdays I clean one thing in my kitchen. On Thursdays I do the sheets and on Fridays, I do the floors. And then on Saturdays, I do the groceries. And so it's really simple. It's nothing that anybody would like all over Pinterest in but setting up that system mirrored some of the more structured environments I've succeeded in in the past and circumvents ways in which my control panel short circuit so because my working memory is unhelpful to me at times, I found that when I do laundry on Mondays, it took about a month but now the idea that laundry is supposed to be done on Mondays is not something being handled by my working memory. It has been filed away in short term memory and contextualize. So that Monday and laundry are inextricably linked in my mind and my associations. So from the moment I wake up on a Monday, it's like it gets flagged it goes it's a laundry day. And before when I was just waiting to do laundry for when we ran out of clothes, it had no associations. So I'm either procrastinating it not doing it getting into the wash and forgetting about it, getting into the washer, the dryer, but then putting it on the floor. And it totally changed my ability. I mean, I literally can't tell you, Leslie, I have never been able to do laundry in a timely manner and have clean clothes put away until eight months ago. And what else is funny, I was looking at it tic toc that I did recently where I talked about how I used to try to be on the house's schedule. Like oh, I noticed that the clean sheets are dirty time to clean the sheets. And when we run out of food or grocery shopping, we run out of clothes, all laundry, and I never could keep on top of anything. And so when I started washing sheets every Thursday, all of a sudden, the sheets were getting washed. And it was for some reason it kind of went to like an enjoyable activity because I felt like I was participating in the routine. And I was doing it and that felt really good. So it even changed my like reward system relationship with the task. And I think it's really funny how for Casey Davis, the only two options for the frequency of how often I wash sheets is every week, which I recognize is too often or literally once a year. Like that's it.

    Lesley PsyD 24:20

    But I love the idea that that's based on trying things and then honoring yourself. And when you find that thing that starts to work really leaning in and not worrying about is this what I'm supposed to do isn't weekly too much. I don't think I have to do that. It doesn't matter if you are finding a rhythm and I think rhythm is a really important word. For people with executive function issues. Rhythm is better than routine for a lot of people routine is like you said it and then I have to do it that way. That's how I do it. Rhythm is paying attention to how it feels and leaning in when it feels right.

    KC Davis 24:54

    Wow, that gave me goosebumps rhythm is more important than routine. And I think that that must be What I'm feeling because rhythm is so satisfying to me. Rhythm is even if it's, it could be the most monotonous task. But if it's on a rhythm, if it's in the flow, all of a sudden, I feel a sense of reward when it's accomplished only if it's in the rhythm and in the flow.

    Lesley PsyD 25:17

    Exactly. It's funny because I think we're both going to say things like in the last year in the last eight months, because the pandemic really created this opportunity to really look inward. In all the time we have with ourselves. I really found in the last year that I enjoyed the fact that my family all slept in later, because they weren't going to school, both of my kids stayed home and fully homeschooled. And so I don't sleep in past seven, I never have, it works for me, I like it. And all of a sudden, I had an hour, from seven to eight of this pristine quiet. And what I found is that I was starting to get a cup of coffee and sit in the same chair and do my notes, my notes for work for if anyone who's not a psychotherapist, it's kind of the bane of our existence. Usually, we need to do it. And it's important, but it's not fun. We like the people, right? We like working with our people. And so I hate notes, and I would often get behind. But what I found is I started getting up at seven, no one's awake, sitting in my chair with my cup of coffee, doing my notes, and then all of a sudden, that became a really joyful time for me a peaceful time. And if I heard footsteps, I very kindly reminded a child not until eight, you have to, like stay in your zone. And so I agree with you, I think when we find our rhythms, and we lean in, we really are honoring ourselves. I think it's just hard in our modern society to feel like we're allowed to do that. Well, I

    KC Davis 26:40

    love that you came to that rhythm gently. Because that's been my experience with all the rhythms that work in my house. Now I came to them gently, I wasn't forcing them. And so what I mean by that is like you didn't say one time, like, you know what, I'm gonna start waking up an hour earlier, so that I have some time to myself, and then you know, you wake up and you snooze, you don't it was like it kind of accidentally happened, and then you realize you liked it. And so all of the things, the rhythms for me that stick are the ones that I sort of happen upon gently, they're not the ones where I'm trying to force myself into a routine or force myself into a schedule. And that's kind of what I'm hearing about your rhythm too.

    Lesley PsyD 27:19

    Yeah, I'll give you an example of how two people can utilize the same compensatory strategies in opposite ways. In my house, we don't have a set day for any task, because that didn't feel rhythmic. To me, it didn't feel authentic to me, what I do is in my brain is surfing. So I have a rhythm of the things that need to be done, not on a daily basis, but more and more like monitoring the house. And I do what feels right that day. And I just don't repeat the same thing two days in a row. And so that's another way to utilize the same skills to get the same result, but in a completely different manner. And that really, I think, speaks to why it's so important not to just look at someone else's strategy and say, I'm going to copy that exactly. And if it doesn't work, that's my fault.

    KC Davis 28:06

    Yeah. And that's why I try really hard not to make it sound like when I'm talking about what works in my home, that I'm not handing it out as a prescriptive routine, like, oh, everyone should do this. This is the answer. Because people are so different. This is just what works in my house. And maybe it'll work for three weeks, and I'll try a new system, maybe it'll work for three months, and then I'll try a new system. One thing I know about me now is that the challenge and the novelty is really important. And so if I use a system for a rhythm for three months, and then I stop using it, I don't have to, I can either just kind of go with the flow and naturally get back on it. Or I can go maybe it's time for a new rhythm, a new system, it doesn't mean that I failed, or that I've done something wrong, or I've relapsed, I can't keep on a system for the life of me. Maybe it's just my natural need for novelty and challenge. And so instead of sort of beating myself up and trying to force myself back onto something I can go, so what's a way that I can do it now what feels right now that will still get those same functioning goals done. And I think it's okay to change your rhythms as they change.

    Lesley PsyD 29:16

    Absolutely. And I think that's what I really enjoy about your content is the strategies that you provide are kind of like a bouquet of flowers, you might pick these flowers to hold and smell today. And maybe later, you'll be like, I want to go back to closing duties. And we've implemented your concept of closing duties in our house. And what I noticed is that we do them for a while, and then they become pretty easy to do. And we don't look at the list anymore. And then all of a sudden we'll kind of notice and noticing is by the way, just as a pause. It's a really helpful concept with executive function disturbance. Because noticing is different than criticism. So Oh no, I'm not using my planner can become. Oh, that's interesting. I haven't used my planner in a week. So when we noticed that in the evenings, we're feeling more stressed. Faster, there's more mess, we'll just recenter ourselves and be like, Oh, time to go back to closing duties. And if you do it that way, it's really a way to think about having this variety of tools in the same toolbox.

    KC Davis 30:11

    And it's totally fine. It's funny, because last night, I had my three year old do her closing duties, and then I did my foreclosing duties. But I honestly hadn't done either one of them fully in a week. And I had that same noticing of just non judgment. It's not Oh, I haven't done this, I need to do it. It was, you know what it would feel good to do them tonight, it would feel good to have these done for the morning. And that's totally fine. Because I get that question all the time. I feel like I start out strong, and then I fall off, what do you do to get back on the horse? And I think the answer is there is no horse. Yeah, there is no horse, there is no falling, there is no horse, it's just meandering through the woods. And sometimes, you know, you start to walk off path because it's interesting, and it meets your needs. And then, you know, when you get a little disoriented, and it serves your needs to get back on the sort of beaten path, then you do that there's no moral judgment on either side. So let me ask you this. One thing that all of this sort of came to head for me was, although I now know, looking back that I've had ADHD my whole life, when I had my second daughter, and I was postpartum, in a pandemic, that's when the majority of the executive functioning came to a head where I couldn't function anymore, right, I look back on my life, and I see where ADHD has been. And and then at the same page, I see all these compensatory behaviors. But when I was postpartum, in a pandemic, it was as though the control panel broke down even more, and the compensatory sort of tools I had didn't work anymore. And one question I wanted to talk about, because we've been talking about ADHD, and depression and sort of these diagnoses that cause executive dysfunction. But certainly there are instances or circumstances or seasons when even someone who's neurotypical can experience interruptions with their executive functioning. And I wonder if you could talk about that.

    Lesley PsyD 32:03

    Yeah, not only can that happen, it happens for everyone, at some extent, probably every few days. So one of the things that's challenging to really cover in full on a short format, social media, like tick tock is all the nuance that's involved in this. So I like to kind of make the quip that you know, if you have a central nervous system, you have executive functions. And if you have executive functions, then you're gonna have days with executive dysfunction, it's just how we were we're homeostatic. So you know, we deplete ourselves of calories, we get hungry, we eat. And that's the same for all of these self monitoring strategies. The biggest thing that impacts executive function, the two biggest things are overload, and anxiety, any kind of anxiety, not even clinical anxiety, just that pressure and nervousness, predominantly impacts things like working memory, and focus for every human being. So if all of a sudden, you are home with your kids all day, and you still have to work or take care of your home, and that is your primary work, and they are having a tantrum, there's a lot going on. So you could be overloaded on two counts, which is going to decrease some of these executive functions. So you might be in the middle of, I was just gonna say, Well, everyone who listens to this, maybe find this to be familiar with, let's say, you are cleaning up a mess that a child has created. And then you have another child who's on the bathroom, you know, on the potty and needs to be wiped, and then someone else who's crying because they're hungry, that's too much for a human being to process in the moment, you're going to have to sacrifice something, it's very likely that if you had another task, you're going to either let it to the side on purpose, or you're going to forget completely. We also know that because just because you mentioned being postpartum, we do know and there's emerging data that shows that estrogen fluctuation, and to some extent other hormones as well impact executive function for all people, especially so for ADHD. But even for neurotypicals, it's not unheard of that folks would have all of a sudden more difficulty with their attention and focus, you know, Miss An appointment, misplace their keys when their estrogen is particularly high or low. Problem is we don't have concrete evidence, whether it's the high or the low. And we don't know why it affects some people and not others. Interesting.

    KC Davis 34:23

    And when you say that, like worry and anxiety can affect executive function, even for neurotypicals. What came to mind for me was I think everyone's had the experience of being at work. And you know, you're in the groove, you're being productive, and then you get the email from your boss says, hey, I want to talk to you at 430. Right? And then all of a sudden, it's like, it's impossible to go back to work and be productive again, like you can't focus you can't think you just have this worry and anxiety. And so that totally makes sense to me. You know why that can happen if someone is experiencing stress or anxiety or just overload?

    Lesley PsyD 34:56

    Yeah, and those things can compound each other. So I think one of the things As the pandemic did is not only did it remove a lot of people's external coping, it compounded our anxiety in a way that we've never experienced. So gonna be anxiety provoking to teach your children at home. But when you have the extra worry of making sure that they're safe and early in the pandemic, we were, you know, washing the grocery bags and leaving are outside. I imagine for a whole lot of people, they found themselves experiencing a whole lot more disruption in these areas than typical and that may last for quite a long time.

    KC Davis 35:31

    Yeah, I wonder if you would say, you know, when you were talking about how there are people who have these kind of long term diagnoses, who will experience executive functioning barriers, but then a neurotypical person experiences them every once in a while, or even once every couple of days. And to me, you know, because there is a real difference between the way that someone who has a diagnoses whether it's the degree is different, or the frequency is different. And it almost reminded me of, you know, when somebody is chronically ill, their experience of medical problems and medical issues and barriers in their life is completely different from someone who's not chronically ill, who's not chronically ill, and but even someone who's not chronically ill get sick sometimes. Right? And so there's some way in which they think they can relate, you know, someone who has had the flu might look at someone who is chronically ill talking about being fatigued and having a fever and think, Oh, I know what that's like. But contextually, you know, the degree to which someone experiences executive dysfunction can really make a quality of life difference between someone who is just sort of on the normal course of life experiencing little blips here and there.

    Lesley PsyD 36:44

    Yeah, absolutely. And the way that I explained this to folks is that for someone who does not have ADHD, but is having a particularly stressful moment, and finding that they have some executive function challenges, maybe they just feel overloaded, or they forgot a bunch of things. Their challenges with executive function are two things, they're more predictable. So it makes sense when they happen, oh, I can see why, gosh, it's been a crazy week at work. And my kids are yelling, so they're more predictable, and they respond to intervention. So in the middle of it, if an individual who does not have an actual diagnosis does not qualify for that says, whoa, slow down. All right, you know what, I'm going to take some things off my plate, I'm going to take a minute for myself, their executive function skills will probably return right back to typical because they're more bound by the environmental stress. The core feature of something like ADHD is that the symptoms are fundamentally unpredictable. And don't make sense with the environment. People with ADHD can have incredible deficits and executive function on a day where everything is going their way, there is nothing wrong, they feel great. And conversely, they could be having the worst day of their life and remember everything and they don't respond to typical interventions. So things like just slow down and focus, just use a planner, right? Just use a planner, don't you think you should get more rest, stop drinking so much coffee Wanderlei have done all of these things today. They don't respond reliably, they may respond sometimes, but they don't respond reliably. And that's why ADHD can be hard to diagnose, especially in very young children, because we need that pattern and the severity, to understand it. So for folks who don't have ADHD, try to imagine yourself on your worst day where you were the most disorganized. And imagine that that worst day could happen at any moment, with no warning and didn't respond to anything you did. That's what it feels

    KC Davis 38:36

    like. And I think that's probably also you know, what we're talking about the shame and beating ourselves up. Because, you know, if you get a phone call in the middle of the day, and you get some sort of scary health news about a family member, and then shortly after that, you suddenly kind of lose all motivation to do anything else with your day, you're gonna go well, that makes sense, right? I've had this big stressful conversation, I'm, well, I'm worried. And there, it's easier to be kind to yourself in that mess. Maybe I do need to just take it easy today. But if you have ADHD, or really any of these diagnoses that can create executive functioning issues, and you wake up one day, and you're going about your day, and then randomly at 12, you don't have a phone call, but just randomly everything goes through and just powers down. And you don't want to do anything else with the rest of your day. We don't tend to give ourselves the same kind of kindness of Oh, well. Let me just you know, that makes sense. That seems valid. Let me just take it easy today. And I think the biggest difference that I have been able to experience since getting my diagnosis. Was it being easier to be kind to myself, and I'm incredibly privileged, that the stuff that I work on in terms of my struggle care platform is very flexible, and I control my own dates and goals. because to some extent, because I will wake up going, I'm gonna get this and this and this and this done. And then all of a sudden, everything just powers down at 1030. And I get to go, Well, I guess it's not getting done today, or I guess it's only kind of going to get done or I guess, let me see if there's some other sort of flow that I can jump into, and maybe just switch projects completely. Now, we don't always have that option in life, there are things that have to get done at certain times. But even when we have to sort of trudge through the ability to sort of be kind to ourselves, and I think that's been my experience is trusting myself and honoring myself that if I feel that power down, that is something that really just happened. I don't know why maybe there was no triggering point, but it did happen. It was not a moral failing. It's not laziness, and it's okay to just kind of go with it.

    Lesley PsyD 40:50

    Yeah, absolutely. There's a model that I use with clients that's so similar to this. And it's been expanded upon by my friend, Abby on Tiktok. She's at Proactiv busy body of the stoplight model. So those of us with these challenges, we typically have red, yellow, and green days. And a Green Day is where for some reason, we're just firing on all cylinders, we're doing really well. And on those days, we don't need as many supports as we usually would need. And we can kind of raise our expectations for ourselves. So if we wake up, and we're feeling great, that's the day to say, Alright, I'm gonna get some extra stuff done, we have our yellow days where you're feeling a little uneasy, you're doing okay, but you could really use maybe some extra supports. And then we have red days where we wake up, and anyone with ADHD typically will will resonate with this. And by half an hour after waking up, we know what they were about to have, we've already lost our keys three times and then found them in the freezer. And on those days, we need to lower expectations and increase supports. And moving through those lights is a way to both hold ourselves accountable, right? We're not that's why it's not laziness, we're not saying it's a red day, I'm doing nothing. No, we need to increase our supports, and really decrease our expectations to focus only on the most important things, which always, by the way, includes self care.

    KC Davis 42:09

    It also reminds me of why you know, when I did sort of build myself this care tasks schedule over the week. And when I did my closing duties, I tried to build into each one of my routines, differing levels of acceptable outcomes. So like, I have a list of things that I do for my closing duties when I closed on my house, and it's like six things. And then I have a another list that I call survival day closing duties. That is just two things that absolutely need to be and I have full permission to choose whichever list fits my needs and my abilities in that moment. And the same thing with when i This is always my suggestion when someone says I want to try a cleaning schedule, what do you suggest. So I suggest, you know, if picking a room or a task a day, but when you say Tuesdays as bathrooms, it doesn't mean on Tuesdays, I clean every single bathroom, it just means on Tuesdays, I clean something in a bathroom. And that allows you to stay within the rhythm that feels good while still honoring sort of your needs of that day. Because it might be a day where you go in and you wipe the countertop off, and then you walk out. Or it might be a day where you go in and clean the whole bathroom top to bottom or every thing in between. And so that we don't feel like when we have a day where we can't accomplish the whole thing that we failed, because any of those options within one thing, or all the things is acceptable, and frankly, no things is acceptable to I have things on my little cleaning schedule that auto like almost week to week, barely ever get done. And sometimes they do. So as we sort of land the plane here. I want to kind of talk about, you know, if someone's listening to this podcast, and they're really relating, and they're thinking, oh my god, I think maybe some of my struggles might be related to executive functioning issues. Where would you suggest someone start? I want to ask this in two parts. Where do you suggest they start in terms of who is the right maybe person or provider to look for? Because I don't think all providers are really knowledgeable about executive functioning issues. And then for people who maybe don't have access to one on one providers, any resources that you would suggest to them?

    Lesley PsyD 44:28

    Sure, yeah, we have in psychology right now in particular the area of support for Neuro divergence, we have an issue, clients and community members not being able to reliably tell if we are going to be helpful to them and we are working on this. So the biggest suggestion that I make is if you have access if you have a mental health benefits through insurance going to a licensed clinician making sure that they have a credential of some kind and make sure when you make contact with them if you're looking for supports that you interview them, ask them questions, ask them Do you know what executive function is this is what I'm specifically looking for. This is one of the things that I find that people don't realize they're allowed to do. And any good clinician would welcome. So if you have access to those kinds of benefits, a psychologist or a therapist, really just starting with even psychology today.com, which is a little bit limited, or just Googling your zip code, and executive function, and therapists, it will give you a nice fat list of a lot of people more than you could contact. But working with a licensed clinician, if you have access to that is really helpful. If you don't have access, or if you want to do something to start dipping your toe in this pond and figuring out if this sounds like you, I absolutely love understood.org. It is a wonderful website, I do not make any money from understood.org. Just so everyone knows, I'm not sponsored by them. I'm just a patron, they have a wealth of articles, they have a simulator so that if you have this disturbance, and you'd like someone in your family to know what it feels like, you can have them do a simulator for executive function challenges. And there are also articles about what concretely to do to start helping yourself and also how to reach out for support. Those are my favorite two suggestions.

    KC Davis 46:10

    Awesome. Yeah, and I will say, as a licensed professional counselor, I have a Master's in Counseling. And I can honestly say that my education did not provide that much information. In fact, I don't remember hardly any information about executive functioning. Certainly, my education and counseling gave me the tools to understand what I was learning when I went out to learn about executive functioning. But I just wanted to sort of echo it's definitely something to ask of a therapist, because not all therapists are going to have experience in that area.

    Lesley PsyD 46:43

    Yeah, absolutely. And they're even if you don't have ADHD, Chad, CH A D is.org is another resource. Sometimes individuals forget that. If you don't have a diagnosis, that doesn't mean you might not benefit from the information. So it's really okay. You don't have to feel like I have to have the diagnosis to even look at this. There's probably a wealth of information that can be helpful to you.

    KC Davis 47:05

    Awesome. Well, thank you so so much for all of this do you want to go ahead and plug your socials and where you are and how people can watch you and contact you if they want to?

    Lesley PsyD 47:16

    Sure I am predominantly on Tik Tok. It is my favorite social media platform that's ever been invented because it's everything is one minute, which works for me. I'm also on Instagram. My Tiktok is Lesley Psy d l es el EYPSY. De my Instagram is actually Lesley underscore Saudi. And that'll be more of the professional information. I'm not on Instagram as much so Tiktok is the best way to peruse my contents.

    KC Davis 47:42

    Awesome. Well, thank you so much.

    Lesley PsyD 47:45

    Thank you for having me. This

    KC Davis 47:45

    is wonderful. This has been an incredible talk. And so if you are listening, I hope you guys check Lesley out and thank you for tuning in.

KC Davis
Struggle Care Trailer

Meet KC Davis! Struggle Care is a podcast about self-care by a host that hates the term self-care. Therapist KC Davis, author of the book How to Keep House While Drowning talks about mental health, care tasks, and more!

Stay tuned for more episodes coming 10/3/22!

  • KC Davis 0:00

    I think for me what I found when I was struggling and looking for support from like the self help genre, I found that most of the advice was this really canned, commercialized one size fits all advice.

    And the worst part of it was that when people would give this sort of, quote unquote self care advice, it was always just some extra task that I was going to need time and energy to complete. And I like the reason I was struggling is because I didn't have enough time or energy.

    And, like, when I feel when I feel like I'm drowning, and I'm overwhelmed, the last thing I need is something else on my to do list that I'm going to feel like a failure when I don't get it done. And if I if I have one more person telling me to journal, I am going to scream. And please don't tell me that I'm gonna feel better if I clean my house. So the reason that it's hard for most people to clean their house is because they already feel like shit. Like that's the barrier. And so that's kind of like a nonsense piece of advice.

    So where do we go to get real mental health and self care advice? Oh, God, I can't even I hate the term self care. I wish there was a better term for it.

    But like, what if what you really need is a place that promised to skip the pop psychology and the one size fits all advice, and just talk about real struggles and real nonjudgmental, practical help?

    Well, that's what this podcast is.

    Welcome to Struggle Care.

    I'm KC Davis, the therapist and author of How to Keep House While Drowning. Each week, I'm gonna bring you a new episode where we talk about how to care for ourselves, even when we struggle. Sometimes I'll bring on guests that will share their expertise and long form episodes. And other times I'll take some listener questions and short q&a episodes. So I hope you subscribe. Join us. Until next time, take care of you sent to you ball of stardust. You deserve to function.

KC DavisComment